Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can I challenge a protective order after I’m charged with violating it? State v. Hegbloom

2014 UT App 213No. 20120264-CADecided Sep 11, 2014Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

A civil protective order entered after a commissioner denied the respondent an evidentiary hearing was not void, because he had notice, attended the hearing, was told how to seek an evidentiary hearing and could have appealed, so he could not collaterally attack it in his criminal prosecution for violating it.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld Hegbloom’s convictions for attempted violation of a protective order.

  • A person who had notice of a protective order hearing and could have appealed the order generally cannot attack it for the first time in a criminal case for violating it.
  • Not every due process error makes a court order void; the court treated the denial of an evidentiary hearing differently from a lack of notice.
  • The court said it might well have reached a different answer if Hegbloom had never had notice of the proceeding.

What happened?

Hegbloom and K.M. shared custody of their child. K.M. got an ex parte civil protective order against him, meaning one entered before he had a chance to respond.

At the later hearing before a court commissioner (a judicial officer who hears matters and makes recommendations to a judge), both parents represented themselves. Hegbloom brought evidence, but the commissioner proceeded by proffer, meaning the parties described their evidence rather than presenting it. He asked several times for a “formal evidentiary hearing.” The commissioner denied it and told him he could object to her recommendation in writing and ask the judge for that hearing.

Hegbloom said he agreed to the terms proposed by the guardian ad litem. He never filed a written objection. The district court entered a permanent protective order, and he did not appeal.

How did this become a criminal case?

A few months later, K.M. reported that he had sent her text messages and had come to her apartment “dressed as a clown.” He was charged with nine violations of the order, all third degree felonies.

He argued in the criminal case that the order was void because he was denied due process (the constitutional right to fair procedures). The criminal court disagreed, finding the commissioner had explained how to object and he had not done so. He then pleaded guilty to two counts of attempted violation of a protective order, class A misdemeanors, keeping his right to appeal that ruling.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It affirmed. The court explained that a judgment can usually be challenged only by a direct appeal. A “collateral attack,” meaning a challenge raised in a later, separate case, is allowed against a void judgment, but courts read the idea of a void judgment narrowly.

None of the cases Hegbloom cited allowed a collateral attack because an evidentiary hearing was wrongly denied. The closest case, Wiscombe v. Wiscombe, 744 P.2d 1024, 1025 (Utah Ct. App. 1987), treated the denial of a full hearing as a due process problem, but it was a direct appeal and said nothing about void judgments.

The court also rejected his effort to describe the problem as a lack of notice. He got notice, went to the hearing, and was told how to ask for an evidentiary hearing. The court said it might well agree an order was void if a person had no notice at all, because that person would have no chance to appeal. Hegbloom did have that chance.

Quoting State v. Clark, 2005 UT 75, ¶ 36, 124 P.3d 235, the court said “the proper method for contesting an adverse ruling is to appeal it, not to violate it.”

The court also declined to consider a separate Utah Constitution claim because Hegbloom had not developed a separate state analysis.

What happens now?

The convictions stand. The court did not decide whether the commissioner’s instructions were correct; it held only that any errors did not make the order void.

What should people take from this?

Once a protective order is entered against someone who knew about it, the court said that person must either appeal it or obey it. Disobeying it and challenging it later in the criminal case did not work here.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Voros, J., joined by Pearce, J., and Billings, Sr. J.). Hegbloom, the defendant, entered conditional guilty pleas to two counts of attempted violation of a protective order, reserving his challenge to the order’s validity (¶ 8). Whatever errors occurred in the protective-order proceeding “did not render the judgment entered there void and subject to collateral attack” (¶ 23).

Issue 1: Collateral attack on the protective order (correctness, ¶ 9): affirmed (no error)

The wrongful denial of an evidentiary hearing, where the respondent had notice and could have appealed, does not make a protective order void, so it cannot be attacked collaterally in the prosecution for violating it.

Framework. A final judgment can, “with rare exception,” be attacked only on direct appeal, State v. Hamilton, 2003 UT 22, ¶ 25, 70 P.3d 111 (¶ 10). A void judgment is open to collateral attack, but voidness is “narrowly construed in the interest of finality,” Brimhall v. Mecham, 494 P.2d 525, 526 (Utah 1972), and arises from lack of jurisdiction or a due process violation (¶ 11).

Authority. None of Hegbloom’s cases addressed wrongful denial of an evidentiary hearing (¶ 15 & n.4). Garcia v. Garcia, 712 P.2d 288, 291 & n.5 (Utah 1986), involved lack of service under rule 60(b)(5), and Olson v. State, 77 P.3d 15, 16–18 (Alaska Ct. App. 2003), rested on lack of notice (¶ 16). Wiscombe v. Wiscombe, 744 P.2d 1024, 1025 (Utah Ct. App. 1987), treated wrongful denial of an evidentiary hearing as a due process violation, but it was a direct appeal and never mentioned voidness; the court declined to extend it, noting that not every due process violation that makes a judgment erroneous makes it void (¶¶ 18–20).

Notice. Hegbloom received notice of the ex parte order and its extension, attended, and was told how to seek an evidentiary hearing. Even if the commissioner’s instructions were wrong under rule 7 and section 78B-7-107(1)(f), that error did not deny him notice (¶ 17). The court “might well agree” an order entered without notice is void, since such a litigant cannot appeal (¶ 21), but Hegbloom could have appealed, as the husband in Wiscombe did (¶ 22). Quoting State v. Clark, 2005 UT 75, ¶ 36, 124 P.3d 235: “The proper method for contesting an adverse ruling is to appeal it, not to violate it” (¶ 22).

State constitution. The court declined to consider a separate state constitutional claim because Hegbloom offered no unique state analysis, citing State v. Worwood, 2007 UT 47, ¶ 19, 164 P.3d 397 (¶ 9 n.2).

The court noted that Hegbloom did not assert that a proper written objection would have been denied or that an appeal would not have corrected the error (¶ 14 n.3).

Takeaways

  • A respondent who had notice and an avenue to appeal must appeal or obey a protective order; disobeying it and attacking it in the criminal case fails (¶¶ 22–23).
  • The court distinguished lack of notice, which might render an order void, from wrongful denial of an evidentiary hearing, which did not (¶¶ 17, 21–22).
  • Wiscombe-type due process errors are reviewable on direct appeal, but the court declined to extend that holding to collateral attacks (¶ 20).
  • A nominal state constitutional claim without separate analysis will not be considered (¶ 9 n.2).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State v. Hegbloom
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2014 UT App 213
Case no.
20120264-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
September 11, 2014
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Hegbloom
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Two convictions, entered on conditional guilty pleas, for attempted violation of a civil protective order that the defendant argued was void

The panel

J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Author
Judith M. BillingsConcurred
John A. PearceConcurred
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Denise P. Lindberg

Parties & counsel

Hegbloom — AppellantIndividual(s)Peter A. DainesIsaac E. McDougallJohn B. Plimpton
State — AppelleeState of UtahSean D. ReyesJohn J. Nielsen

Practice Tip

A client who believes a protective order was entered without a proper evidentiary hearing should object as instructed and appeal; the court held that disobeying the order and challenging it in the later criminal case did not work (¶¶ 22–23).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.