Utah Supreme Court · Published Opinion

Can a city take my land just to trade it to a utility? Salt Lake City Corp. v. Evans Development

2016 UT 15No. 20130741Decided Mar 24, 2016Real Property & Land UseReversed

Holding

Utah’s eminent domain statutes do not permit a city to condemn private property solely to transfer ownership to a third party that will carry out the public use, because the condemnor must be in charge of the public use, oversee construction, and remain answerable to the condemnee under Utah Code § 78B-6-520.

Key takeaways

The Utah Supreme Court sided with Evans Development Group, the landowner, and ordered the City to give the land back.

  • Under Utah’s eminent domain statutes, the government that takes the land must be the one in charge of the public use on that land.
  • Salt Lake City could not take Evans’ land just to hand ownership to Rocky Mountain Power.
  • The court did not say every property exchange is forbidden, only that this one was not done the way the statutes require.

What happened?

In 2007 Salt Lake City began a $50 million project to move railroad lines off 900 South and Folsom Street. To do that, it needed a 2.39-acre parcel owned by Rocky Mountain Power, which wanted that land for a substation.

The City and PacifiCorp, Rocky Mountain Power’s parent company, signed a “Property Exchange Agreement.” The power company would give its land to the City if the City supplied another site that worked for a substation.

To meet that promise, the City used eminent domain (the government’s power to take private land for public use, with payment) to condemn a 2.67-acre parcel owned by Evans Development Group. Evans was the landowner and the defendant in the City’s case.

What did each side argue?

Evans argued that taking land just to trade it away is not a public use the statutes allow. The City argued that railroads and power plant sites are both public uses listed in the statute, and that the trade was simply how it reached those goals.

The district court agreed with the City, decided the issue without a trial, and entered a final judgment of condemnation. Evans appealed.

What did the court decide?

The Utah Supreme Court reversed. It said a public use must be served on the land actually being taken, not on some other parcel. The railroad project might justify taking Rocky Mountain Power’s land, but it did not justify taking Evans’ land.

The power plant use did not help either, because Rocky Mountain Power, not the City, would own the Evans land and run the substation. The court pointed to three parts of the statutes. The complaint must name the party in charge of the public use as the plaintiff. The party that takes the land must start and finish construction in a reasonable time. And if it does not, the former owner can sue that party to undo the taking. If the City had already handed the land to Rocky Mountain Power, Evans would have no one to recover it from.

The court distinguished an earlier case, Utah Cty. v. Ivie, 2006 UT 33, 137 P.3d 797, where the county that took the land kept ownership and control even though another city paid for the road.

What happens now?

The district court’s final judgment of condemnation is vacated (set aside). The district court must order the City to return the land to Evans and resolve Evans’ remaining claims for damages and attorney fees.

Evans also argued that construction had not started within a reasonable time. The court did not need to decide that.

What should people take from this?

The court said a property exchange “may not be altogether prohibited,” but it cannot be done the way the City did it here. The court suggested that a lease, where the City keeps ownership, would have kept the owner’s remedy intact.

Bottom line

Vacated and remanded with instructions (Durham, J., joined by Durrant, C.J., Lee, A.C.J., and Himonas, J.; Pearce, J., did not participate because he joined the Court after oral argument). The City condemned Evans’ parcel to swap it to Rocky Mountain Power for land the City needed for a railroad realignment (¶¶ 2–5). The condemnation violated the eminent domain statutes because the condemnor must be in charge of the public use on the condemned property (¶¶ 13–14, 23).

Issue 1: Condemnation for exchange purposes (correctness, ¶ 9): reversed

The City had no statutory authority to condemn the Evans property for transfer to Rocky Mountain Power. Public use must be satisfied “on the property subject to the condemnation,” under Utah Code § 78B-6-504(1), so the railroad use in § 78B-6-501(4) could support taking Rocky Mountain Power’s land but not Evans’ (¶ 13). The power-site use in § 78B-6-501(8) failed because a third party would own the land and run the use, and even assuming the exchange was an “other public use” under § 78B-6-501(3)(f), three provisions require the condemnor to keep ownership and control (¶ 14):

  • § 78B-6-507(1)(a): the entity “in charge of the public use” must be the plaintiff, and Rocky Mountain Power was not a party (¶ 15).
  • § 78B-6-520: the condemnor must commence and complete construction and use within a reasonable time. It may contract out the work but must remain “in charge of” the property (¶ 19).
  • § 78B-6-520(1): the condemnee’s remedy to set aside the condemnation runs “against the condemnor,” which would be lost if title had passed to Rocky Mountain Power (¶¶ 20–21).

Utah Cty. v. Ivie, 2006 UT 33, ¶ 10, 137 P.3d 797, was distinguished: there the condemning county kept ownership and responsibility while Provo City paid costs, a valid arrangement between entities that each acted within their own powers (¶¶ 16–18). The court noted that a lease or indemnification agreement, such as a hypothetical 100-year lease, would preserve the condemnee’s remedy (¶ 22).

Disposition

The Final Judgment of Condemnation is vacated. The district court must order the City to return the property to Evans and resolve Evans’ remaining claims for damages and attorney fees (¶ 23).

Not reached

Whether construction commenced within a “reasonable time” under § 78B-6-520. The court did not reach it because the condemnation itself violated the statute (¶ 8 n.1).

Takeaways

  • The public use must be satisfied on the parcel being condemned, not on a different parcel the condemnation helps acquire (¶ 13).
  • The condemnor must remain in charge of the public use and answerable under § 78B-6-520(1). Transferring title to a third party defeats that (¶¶ 19–21).
  • The court did not hold that exchanges are always barred. A lease or indemnification arrangement that keeps the condemnor in charge may be permissible (¶¶ 22–23).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Salt Lake City Corp. v. Evans Development
Court
Utah Supreme Court
Citation
2016 UT 15
Case no.
20130741
Filed
2013
Decided
March 24, 2016
Opinion type
Authored
Heard
Argued
Who appealed
Evans Development
Disposition
Reversed
At stake
The City's condemnation of Evans' 2.67-acre parcel so it could trade the land to Rocky Mountain Power for a substation site

The panel

Christine M. DurhamAuthor
Matthew B. DurrantConcurred
Deno G. HimonasConcurred
Thomas R. LeeConcurred
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake County · Judge Robert P. Faust

Parties & counsel

Evans Development — AppellantBusinessRobert E. MansfieldSteven J. Joffee
Salt Lake City Corp. — AppelleeGovernment agencyKevin Egan AndersonJ. Elizabeth Haws

Practice Tip

When a condemnation is part of a deal with another entity, check whether the condemnor keeps ownership and control of the condemned parcel. The court said a lease or indemnification arrangement could preserve the condemnee's remedy, while a transfer of title did not (¶¶ 21–22).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.