Can proof that police paid key witnesses reopen a death case? Carter v. State
Holding
Summary judgment on Carter’s Brady and Napue claims was error because, drawing all inferences in his favor, a genuine dispute of material fact exists on whether the suppressed evidence of benefits, coaching, and threats to the State’s key witnesses, and the uncorrected false testimony about benefits, prejudiced him at the guilt and sentencing phases.
Key takeaways
The Utah Supreme Court partly sided with Douglas Carter, ordering a hearing on his claims about the Tovars’ testimony while upholding the district court’s other rulings.
- Carter gets a hearing on whether hidden evidence about the Tovars, and Mr. Tovar’s uncorrected testimony about payments, harmed him at trial and at sentencing.
- The court did not decide that Carter must get a new trial or a new sentence; that depends on the hearing.
- His claim that the prosecutor vouched for the Tovars came too late, and the district court’s rulings on his other evidence stand.
Utah cases relied on
- Tillman v. State2005 UT 56
- Heslop v. Bear River Mutual Ins. Co.2017 UT 5
- State v. Carter888 P.2d 629 (Utah 1995)
- State v. Ashcraft2015 UT 5
- State v. Carter776 P.2d 886 (Utah 1989)
- Steffensen v. Smith's Mgmt. Corp.862 P.2d 1342 (Utah 1993)
- State v. Davis2007 UT App 13
Case details
- Case name
- Carter v. State
- Court
- Utah Supreme Court
- Citation
- 2019 UT 12
- Case no.
- 20170641
- Filed
- 2017
- Decided
- March 21, 2019
- Opinion type
- Authored
- Who appealed
- Carter
- Disposition
- Reversed and Remanded
The panel
Parties & counsel
Practice Tip
When opposing summary judgment on a Brady claim, show how a key witness's testimony changed over time and tie those changes to the alleged benefits or pressure; the court treated that link as a reasonable inference rather than speculation (¶¶ 67–68, 75).
Need appellate counsel?
Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.
About these Decision Summaries
Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.


