Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can a judge sentence me if my presentence report has errors? State v. Irey

2017 UT App 178No. 20160815-CADecided Sep 21, 2017Criminal AppealsAffirmed/Remanded in part

Holding

A district court’s failure to resolve PSI objections on the record under Utah Code section 77-18-1(6)(a) requires a limited remand, but not resentencing where the court considered the corrections and did not rely on the disputed information, and the denial of probation was not an abuse of discretion.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals upheld Irey’s prison sentence but sent the case back so the judge can rule on the record on his objections to the presentence report.

  • When a defendant objects to errors in a presentence report, the judge must state on the record how those objections are resolved.
  • Failing to do that led only to a limited remand here, not a new sentencing, because the judge considered the corrections and nothing showed he relied on the disputed information.
  • A defendant has no right to probation, and disagreeing with how the judge weighed the factors was not enough to overturn the prison sentence.

What happened?

Michael Shaun Irey was convicted of operating or possessing a clandestine laboratory (a first degree felony), distributing a controlled substance (a third degree felony), and attempted aggravated assault (a class A misdemeanor). The district court sentenced him to concurrent prison terms of five years to life, zero to five years, and zero to 365 days.

Before sentencing, the court received a presentence investigation report, often called a PSI. It is a report about the defendant’s background that the judge uses when deciding the sentence.

What was wrong with the report?

At sentencing, Irey’s lawyer said the PSI wrongly described an extensive history of substance-abuse arrests and three failed probations, while another part of the report said he had no adult supervised probation on record. The lawyer also disputed what the report said about Irey’s attitude and lack of remorse.

The judge offered to order a new PSI because there were “obviously a couple of errors.” Irey’s lawyer declined and asked to go forward with the corrections made in court. The State agreed Irey’s criminal history score should drop from one to zero.

What did Irey argue on appeal?

He raised two points. First, the judge never resolved his objections to the PSI as Utah law requires. Second, the judge should have given him probation instead of prison.

The State agreed the objections were not resolved and that the case should go back for that limited purpose. But it argued the sentence should stand.

What did the court decide about the report?

The Court of Appeals agreed with Irey that the judge had heard his objections but did not state on the record what he decided about their accuracy and relevance. Because the PSI “will follow [Irey] through the justice system,” it should be corrected. So the case goes back for the judge to resolve the objections.

But the court held that a new sentencing was not needed. The judge had accepted the general accuracy of the corrections when sentencing, nothing in the record showed he relied on the disputed information, and Irey did not specifically argue the errors hurt him at sentencing.

Did the prison sentence stand?

Yes. A defendant is not entitled to probation; the judge may grant it if it serves justice and the public interest. The judge found two aggravating factors (facts that weigh toward a harsher sentence): about $90,000 in property damage from a fire caused by the lab, and Irey threatening a potential drug buyer with a gun. He found one mitigating factor (a fact that weighs toward leniency): Irey was a fairly young offender.

The appeals court said Irey’s argument came down to disagreeing with how the judge weighed those factors, which is not enough to show an abuse of discretion, meaning a decision no reasonable judge would make.

What happens now?

The district court will rule on the record on Irey’s objections to the PSI. His sentence stays in place.

What should people take from this?

Objections to a presentence report need a ruling on the record, but the lack of one does not by itself undo a sentence when the judge considered the corrections.

Bottom line

Remanded for the limited purpose of resolving the PSI objections and affirmed in all other respects (per curiam; Orme, Pohlman, and Hagen, JJ.) (¶ 9). The district court did not state on the record its determinations of accuracy and relevance on Irey’s PSI objections, but resentencing is not required because the court considered the corrections before sentencing (¶¶ 5–6). The denial of probation stands (¶ 8).

Issue 1: Resolving PSI objections (correctness, ¶ 5): reversed

The district court failed to resolve Irey’s PSI objections on the record, requiring a limited remand but not resentencing. The State conceded the point (¶¶ 3, 5). Defense counsel challenged the PSI’s account of substance-abuse arrests, three unsuccessful probations, and Irey’s attitude and remorse, and declined the court’s offer of a new PSI (¶ 4). Although the court “considered and acknowledged” the objections, it did not record its determinations, and because the PSI follows the defendant, it should be corrected, following State v. Monroe, 2015 UT App 48, ¶ 10, 345 P.3d 755 (¶ 5). Relying on Monroe, the court held the failure did not require resentencing: the district court accepted the general accuracy of the corrections, nothing showed reliance on the disputed information, and Irey did not specifically argue prejudice (¶ 6). The remand follows State v. Samulski, 2016 UT App 226, ¶ 24 (¶ 9).

Issue 2: Denial of probation (abuse of discretion, ¶ 2): affirmed (no error)

The district court did not abuse its discretion by imposing prison rather than probation. A defendant “is not entitled to probation,” and denial will be overturned only if “inherently unfair,” under State v. Rhodes, 818 P.2d 1048, 1051 (Utah Ct. App. 1991) (¶¶ 2, 8). The court weighed about $90,000 in fire damage from the lab and Irey’s threatening a potential buyer with a gun against his youth (¶ 7). Irey’s argument was a disagreement with the weighing of factors, which is insufficient, following State v. Alvarez, 2017 UT App 145, ¶ 6 (¶ 8). His reliance on State v. Moreno, 2005 UT App 200, 113 P.3d 992, was misplaced: Moreno involved a statutory duty to explain the choice among three minimum mandatory terms, which is not present here (¶ 8 n.1).

Disposition

Remanded for the district court to resolve Irey’s PSI objections on the record; sentence affirmed (¶ 9).

Takeaways

  • An unresolved PSI objection gets a limited remand, not resentencing, when the record shows the court accepted the corrections and did not rely on the disputed information (¶ 6).
  • Arguing that the PSI errors prejudiced the sentence matters; Irey did not specifically argue prejudice (¶ 6).
  • Disagreement with the weighing of aggravating and mitigating factors does not show an abuse of discretion in denying probation (¶ 8).
  • State v. Moreno, 2005 UT App 200, 113 P.3d 992, does not require a court to explain on the record how it weighed factors outside the statutory three-term setting (¶ 8 n.1).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State v. Irey
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2017 UT App 178
Case no.
20160815-CA
Filed
2016
Decided
September 21, 2017
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Irey
Disposition
Affirmed in part and Remanded in part
At stake
A prison sentence instead of probation, and correction of alleged errors in the presentence investigation report

The panel

Diana H. HagenPer curiam
Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Jill M. PohlmanPer curiam
Trial court
Fourth District Court, Provo Department · Judge Samuel D. McVey

Parties & counsel

Irey — AppellantIndividual(s)Emily Adams
State — AppelleeState of UtahSean D. ReyesMarian Decker

Practice Tip

When challenging a sentence based on PSI errors, argue specifically how the errors affected the sentence; without a showing of reliance or prejudice, the remedy may be only a limited remand to correct the report (¶ 6).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.