Trial by Consent in Utah: When Silence Adds a Claim
Trial by consent in Utah can add an unpleaded issue when counsel stays silent. Boyer v. Rubin shows what to object to and when.
Appellate Services
Appellate Practice Areas
Learn the Appellate Process
Utah Appellate Court Opinions
Utah Court Rules Filing Deadlines & Timelines
Trial by consent in Utah can add an unpleaded issue when counsel stays silent. Boyer v. Rubin shows what to object to and when.
The verdict is in, and you keep replaying the trial. A witness said something that should never have come in. The judge made a ruling that seemed plainly wrong. And your trial lawyer said nothing. Now one question won’t let…
Complex multi-week trials present the preservation problem in its most acute form. The volume of evidentiary issues is large. The pace is relentless. Unexpected developments arrive daily — witnesses who say things they were not anticipated to say, documents admitted…
The question of when to add appellate co-counsel to active litigation is not primarily a timing question — it is a recognition question. The timing follows from recognizing that appellate concerns are present in the case in a form that…
The verdict has been entered. Most of the trial team’s attention is turning toward what comes next — whether that is filing a notice of appeal, beginning settlement negotiations, or advising the client on how to respond to enforcement of…
Evidentiary rulings are among the most frequently appealed issues in Utah civil and criminal practice — and among the most frequently denied on harmless error grounds. The reason is a structural problem: most evidentiary objections at trial are made quickly,…
Jury instructions sit at the intersection of everything that matters in appellate practice: they are reviewed for legal accuracy under the most favorable standard available to appellants (de novo — no deference), they often determine how the jury evaluates the…
The preservation doctrine is one of those rules that every litigator knows in principle and many underestimate in practice. It is not enough to raise an issue — it must be raised in the right way, at the right time,…
Ask most litigants what determines the outcome of an appeal and they will point to the appellate brief or the oral argument — the performance at the appellate level. That intuition is understandable but wrong. The brief and the argument…
Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals throughout Utah, serving clients in all counties and courts across the state including: