Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I appeal after pleading guilty or waiving my appeal? State v. Smith

2011 UT App 336No. 20090174-CADecided Oct 6, 2011Criminal AppealsDismissed

Holding

Because Smith did not timely move to withdraw his guilty plea and raised no sentencing issue, the court lacked jurisdiction over his challenge to that conviction under State v. Rhinehart, 2007 UT 61, ¶ 15, 167 P.3d 1046, and his knowing and voluntary waiver of the right to appeal his jury conviction, given for plea-bargain consideration, barred that appeal.

Practice areaCriminal Appeals

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with the State and dismissed Smith’s appeal of both of his convictions.

  • A defendant who does not move in time to withdraw a guilty plea cannot attack the plea on direct appeal; the court held such a challenge must go through the Post-Conviction Remedies Act.
  • A defendant can give up the right to appeal, and the court enforced Smith’s knowing and voluntary waiver made in exchange for a plea bargain.
  • Smith’s appeal was dismissed without the court deciding his ineffective-assistance claims.

What happened?

Shawn Michael Smith had two criminal cases in the Fifth District, Cedar City Department. In one, a jury convicted him of assault by a prisoner, a third degree felony. In the other, he was charged with possession of a dangerous weapon by a restricted person.

On February 3, 2009, both cases were settled in a plea bargain. Smith pleaded guilty to the weapon charge, and the State agreed to a sentencing recommendation covering both cases. The judge went through the required questions before accepting the plea and told Smith he could move to withdraw it any time before sentencing. Smith asked to be sentenced that day and never moved to withdraw the plea.

At the same hearing, Smith confirmed he was giving up his right to appeal the assault conviction. He got zero to five years in prison on each conviction, running together with each other but after the five-years-to-life sentence he was already serving for aggravated robbery.

What did Smith argue on appeal?

Smith appealed both convictions anyway. He argued that his trial lawyer was ineffective during the jury trial, that the right to appeal cannot be waived, and that the statute on withdrawing guilty pleas cannot block an appeal. The State, the party defending the convictions, asked the court to dismiss the appeal.

Could Smith challenge his guilty plea?

No. Under State v. Rhinehart, 2007 UT 61, ¶ 15, 167 P.3d 1046, if a defendant does not file a timely motion to withdraw a guilty plea, the appeals court lacks jurisdiction (the legal power to hear the case) over any claim except a challenge to the sentence. That includes claims that the lawyer handled the plea badly.

Smith raised only issues from before his conviction, not sentencing issues. The court noted that he did not deal with the many cases against his position. His challenge must be brought instead under the Post-Conviction Remedies Act, a separate process for attacking a conviction after the fact.

Could Smith appeal the jury conviction?

No. The court relied on Manning v. State, 2005 UT 61, ¶ 35, 122 P.3d 628, which says a defendant who knowingly and voluntarily gives up the right to appeal has not been unconstitutionally denied that right.

The trial judge had found on the record that Smith waived his appeal “knowingly and intentionally and voluntarily.” In return, Smith got the amended charge in the other case and a favorable joint sentencing recommendation.

What happens now?

The appeal is over. The court granted the State’s motion and dismissed it. Because of the dismissal, the court did not need to consider a motion to send the case back under rule 23B of the Utah Rules of Appellate Procedure, a rule that allows a remand to develop facts for an ineffective-assistance claim.

What should people take from this?

Giving up the right to appeal in a plea deal can be binding. Skipping a timely motion to withdraw a guilty plea also closes the door on a direct appeal of the plea, leaving the post-conviction process as the route the court pointed to.

Bottom line

Appeal dismissed (per curiam; Orme, Thorne, and Christiansen, JJ.). Smith appealed a guilty-plea conviction for possession of a dangerous weapon by a restricted person (case 051500608) and a jury conviction for assault by a prisoner (case 081500508), both third degree felonies (¶ 1). The State moved to dismiss on two grounds, one for each conviction, and the court granted the motion (¶¶ 6–7).

Issue 1: Appeal from the guilty-plea conviction (none stated, ¶ 4): the State’s motion to dismiss granted

The court lacked jurisdiction over Smith’s challenge to the guilty-plea conviction because he never moved to withdraw the plea. Failing to file a timely motion to withdraw a guilty plea leaves the appellate court without jurisdiction over any claim except a challenge to the sentence, State v. Rhinehart, 2007 UT 61, ¶ 15, 167 P.3d 1046, and the bar covers ineffective-assistance claims tied to the plea, see State v. Briggs, 2006 UT App 448, ¶ 6, 147 P.3d 969; State v. Navarro, 2010 UT App 302, ¶ 2, 243 P.3d 519 (¶ 4). Such challenges go through the PCRA under Utah Code Ann. § 77‑13‑6(2)(c) (2008) (¶ 4). Smith’s argument that section 77‑13‑6 cannot bar an appeal failed because he did not address “the body of case law to the contrary” (¶ 4). He raised only pre-conviction issues, no sentencing issues (¶ 6).

Issue 2: Appeal from the jury conviction (none stated, ¶ 5): the State’s motion to dismiss granted

Smith’s express, knowing, and voluntary waiver of his right to appeal the assault conviction barred the appeal. Rejecting Smith’s claim that the right to appeal cannot be waived, the court quoted Manning v. State, 2005 UT 61, ¶ 35, 122 P.3d 628: a defendant who knowingly and voluntarily waives the right to appeal “has not been unconstitutionally denied that right” (¶ 5). The district court found the waiver knowing, intentional, and voluntary, made as an incentive for the sentencing recommendation (¶ 3). Smith received consideration: the amended charge in case 051500608 and a favorable joint sentencing recommendation (¶ 6). His ineffective-assistance claims about the jury trial were therefore not considered.

Not reached

Because it dismissed the appeal, the court found it unnecessary to consider the motion for remand under rule 23B of the Utah Rules of Appellate Procedure (¶ 7).

Takeaways

  • Without a timely motion to withdraw a guilty plea, the only claim open on direct appeal is a challenge to the sentence; plea-related ineffective-assistance claims go to the PCRA (¶ 4).
  • An argument that section 77‑13‑6 cannot bar an appeal fails if it ignores the contrary case law (¶ 4).
  • A waiver of the right to appeal a jury conviction, made on the record in exchange for plea-bargain consideration, supports dismissal (¶¶ 3, 5–6).
  • A pending rule 23B motion falls with the dismissal (¶ 7).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
State v. Smith
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 336
Case no.
20090174-CA
Filed
2009
Decided
October 6, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Smith
Disposition
Dismissed
At stake
Two third degree felony convictions, assault by a prisoner and possession of a dangerous weapon by a restricted person, each carrying zero to five years in prison

The panel

Michele M. Christiansen ForsterPer curiam
William A. Thorne Jr.Per curiam
Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Fifth District Court, Cedar City Department · Judge G. Michael Westfall

Parties & counsel

Smith — AppellantIndividual(s)Matthew D. Carling
State — AppelleeState of UtahMark L. ShurtleffAndrew F. Peterson

Practice Tip

If a client may want to challenge a guilty plea, file the motion to withdraw before sentencing; otherwise the court held only the sentence can be challenged on direct appeal, and plea challenges, including ineffective-assistance claims, go to the PCRA (¶ 4).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.