Can I win an appeal over recordings no one has heard? State v. McHugh
Holding
A defendant who only speculates that undisclosed recordings contain a witness’s inconsistent statements shows neither favorability nor prejudice under Brady, and an ineffective-assistance claim for failing to obtain those recordings fails when they are absent from the record and no rule 23B remand was sought, because counsel is then presumed effective.
Key takeaways
The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld McHugh’s conviction for making a terroristic threat.
- Guessing that withheld recordings might help the defense was not enough to show the State unfairly hid evidence.
- Strong other evidence of guilt meant McHugh could not show the missing recordings hurt him.
- When the appeal record does not show what the lawyer failed to get, the court presumes the lawyer acted properly.
Utah cases relied on
- Tillman v. State2005 UT 56
- State v. Bisner2001 UT 99
- State v. Dunn850 P.2d 1201, 1225 (Utah 1993)
- State v. Litherland2000 UT 76
Case details
- Case name
- State v. McHugh
- Court
- Utah Court of Appeals
- Citation
- 2011 UT App 62
- Case no.
- 20090767-CA
- Filed
- 2009
- Decided
- March 10, 2011
- Opinion type
- Per curiam
- Who appealed
- McHugh
- Disposition
- Affirmed
The panel
Parties & counsel
Practice Tip
If an ineffective-assistance claim turns on evidence the trial lawyer never obtained, move for a temporary remand under Utah R. App. P. 23B to put that evidence in the record; otherwise the court will presume counsel performed effectively (¶ 5).
Need appellate counsel?
Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.
About these Decision Summaries
Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.


