Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I win an appeal over recordings no one has heard? State v. McHugh

2011 UT App 62No. 20090767-CADecided Mar 10, 2011Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

A defendant who only speculates that undisclosed recordings contain a witness’s inconsistent statements shows neither favorability nor prejudice under Brady, and an ineffective-assistance claim for failing to obtain those recordings fails when they are absent from the record and no rule 23B remand was sought, because counsel is then presumed effective.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld McHugh’s conviction for making a terroristic threat.

  • Guessing that withheld recordings might help the defense was not enough to show the State unfairly hid evidence.
  • Strong other evidence of guilt meant McHugh could not show the missing recordings hurt him.
  • When the appeal record does not show what the lawyer failed to get, the court presumes the lawyer acted properly.

What happened?

John M. McHugh was convicted of making a terroristic threat. According to the court, two witnesses for the State testified that McHugh told them, in separate conversations, that he called in the bomb threat. Phone records showed the call came from McHugh’s phone and that the phone was with him around the time of the call.

McHugh appealed to the Utah Court of Appeals.

What did McHugh argue?

He made two arguments about some recordings. First, he said the State broke the rule from Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963). That rule says the prosecution violates a defendant’s right to a fair process (due process) if it holds back evidence that helps the defense and matters to the outcome. McHugh claimed the recordings might show a witness, Tammy Baker, saying inconsistent things.

Second, he said his trial lawyer was ineffective, meaning the lawyer’s work fell below an acceptable standard and hurt his case, because the lawyer did not get the recordings.

What did the court decide about the withheld evidence?

The court rejected this argument. To win a claim like this, a defendant must show the evidence was helpful to him, the State held it back, and holding it back caused harm.

McHugh only speculated that the recordings might contain inconsistent statements. Nothing in the record showed the recordings, “if any,” held anything helpful. He also could not show harm. He called Baker the State’s key witness, but the court noted she was actually called by the defense. With two other witnesses describing his confessions and the phone records, the mere possibility of some inconsistent statements did not show prejudice.

What about his lawyer?

This argument failed too. A defendant claiming a bad lawyer must show both poor performance and harm. It is the person appealing who must make sure the appeal record has what the court needs to judge the claim.

The recordings were not in the record, so no one knew what they said. That made the claim speculative. Utah’s rules offer a way to fix this: rule 23B of the Utah Rules of Appellate Procedure lets a defendant ask to send the case back temporarily so the trial court can add facts about the lawyer’s performance. McHugh did not use it. When the record falls short, the court presumes the lawyer did the job properly, and it did so here.

What happens now?

Nothing more. The conviction stands.

What should people take from this?

On appeal, a claim about evidence no one has seen is hard to win. If a defendant believes missing material would show the trial lawyer fell short, there is a set procedure to get it into the record, and skipping it leaves the court to assume the lawyer acted properly.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; McHugh, Thorne, and Christiansen, JJ.). McHugh’s challenges both rested on recordings he believed might contain inconsistent statements by a witness, Tammy Baker. Speculation about their content did not establish a Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963), violation (¶ 3). Without the recordings in the record and without a rule 23B motion, the ineffective-assistance claim failed under the presumption of effective performance (¶ 5).

Issue 1: Brady violation (none stated, ¶¶ 2–3): affirmed (no error)

McHugh did not show the allegedly suppressed evidence was favorable or that its suppression prejudiced him. The court applied the three Brady elements (favorable evidence, suppression by the State, prejudice) from Tillman v. State, 2005 UT 56, ¶ 28, 128 P.3d 1123 (citing Strickler v. Greene, 527 U.S. 263, 281-82 (1999)), and noted that reversal follows only where the defense did not learn of the evidence until after trial, see State v. Bisner, 2001 UT 99, ¶ 36, 37 P.3d 1073 (¶ 2). Nothing in the record showed the recordings, “if any,” contained exculpatory or impeachment material (¶ 3). There was no prejudice: Baker was called by the defense, not the State; two State witnesses testified to McHugh’s separate confessions to the bomb threat; and phone records tied the call to his phone and showed it was in his possession during the relevant time frame (¶ 3).

Issue 2: Ineffective assistance for failing to obtain the recordings (none stated, ¶¶ 4–5): affirmed (no error)

The claim failed because the record was inadequate and McHugh did not seek a rule 23B remand. Under State v. Dunn, 850 P.2d 1201, 1225 (Utah 1993), a defendant must show deficient performance and prejudice (¶ 4). The appellant bears the burden of an adequate record, and must move for a temporary remand under Utah R. App. P. 23B when aware of nonspeculative facts outside the record, State v. Litherland, 2000 UT 76, ¶ 16, 12 P.3d 92 (¶ 4). Because the recordings’ content was unknown, McHugh could not show prejudice, and the court presumed counsel performed effectively, applying Litherland’s rule that record deficiencies are “construed in favor of a finding that counsel performed effectively” (¶ 5).

Takeaways

  • A Brady claim built on what withheld material might contain does not show favorability (¶ 3).
  • Strong independent evidence of guilt, such as confessions to others and phone records, can defeat Brady prejudice (¶ 3).
  • When an ineffective-assistance claim depends on material outside the record, the rule 23B remand is the mechanism to get it in; without it, the court presumes effective performance (¶ 5).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
State v. McHugh
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 62
Case no.
20090767-CA
Filed
2009
Decided
March 10, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
McHugh
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A conviction for making a terroristic threat based on a bomb threat call

The panel

Michele M. Christiansen ForsterPer curiam
William A. Thorne Jr.Per curiam
Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Trial court
Fourth District Court, Provo Department · Judge Gary D. Stott

Parties & counsel

McHugh — AppellantIndividual(s)Dana M. Facemyer
State — AppelleeState of UtahMark L. ShurtleffBrett J. DelPorto

Practice Tip

If an ineffective-assistance claim turns on evidence the trial lawyer never obtained, move for a temporary remand under Utah R. App. P. 23B to put that evidence in the record; otherwise the court will presume counsel performed effectively (¶ 5).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.