Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I raise a merger argument for the first time on appeal? State v. Larsen

2011 UT App 426No. 20100473-CADecided Dec 15, 2011Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

A claim that five theft-of-a-firearm counts should have merged as a single criminal episode was not preserved where the district court raised merger only as it pertained to sentencing, and because the defendant argued no exception to the preservation rule, the court declined to address it.

Key takeaways

The State won: the Utah Court of Appeals let all five of Larsen’s firearm-theft convictions stand.

  • The court did not decide whether the five firearm-theft counts should have merged into one.
  • Larsen’s merger argument failed because she never raised it in the district court, and she did not argue that any exception to that rule applied.
  • A judge bringing up merger only in connection with sentencing did not preserve a different merger argument about combining the counts.

What happened?

Jennielue Crosby Larsen was convicted in the district court of five counts of theft of a firearm. She appealed, and the State of Utah, which prosecuted her, defended the convictions.

What did Larsen argue?

Larsen argued that the five counts should have “merged” into one count. Merger here means combining several charges into one because they come from the same set of events. Her claim was that the five thefts were part of a single criminal episode.

Why didn’t the court decide whether she was right?

As a general rule, an appeals court will not consider an argument the trial court never heard. The objection also has to be specific enough to alert the trial judge to the exact error the party complains about. This is called “preservation.”

The court found that Larsen never specifically asked the district court to merge the counts. She said the issue came up when the judge raised merger on the judge’s own initiative while the jury instructions were being discussed. The court looked at the record and found that the judge talked about merger only as it related to sentencing. The judge never raised whether all five counts should become one count because they came from a single episode. So the issue was not preserved.

Could the court have reviewed it anyway?

The court can sometimes review an unpreserved argument under an exception. The exceptions include plain error (an obvious and harmful mistake the judge should have caught), exceptional circumstances, or ineffective assistance of counsel (a lawyer’s performance so poor that it hurt the case). Larsen did not argue that any of these exceptions applied, so the court did not use them.

In a footnote, the court also said Larsen’s argument was inadequately briefed, meaning not developed enough. Her argument was less than one page. It did not try to apply the case law on merger, or the statutes allowing separate charges from a single episode, to her facts.

What did the court decide?

The court declined to address the merger issue and affirmed. All five convictions stand.

What should people take from this?

An argument usually has to be made clearly in the trial court before an appeals court will hear it. A judge mentioning a related topic for a different purpose may not be enough. If an argument was not raised below, the appeal needs to explain why an exception applies.

Bottom line

Affirmed. Per curiam decision (Davis, P.J., Voros and Roth, JJ.). Larsen appealed five convictions for theft of a firearm, arguing that the counts should have merged into one because they arose from a single criminal episode (¶ 1). The court declined to reach the claim because it was not preserved and Larsen argued no exception to the preservation rule (¶ 4).

Issue 1: Merger of the five counts (none stated, ¶¶ 2–4): not reached

The merger claim was not preserved, and because Larsen argued no exception, the court declined to address it. Claims not raised below generally may not be raised on appeal, State v. Holgate, 2000 UT 74, ¶ 11, 10 P.3d 346, and an objection must be specific enough to give the trial court notice of “the very error . . . complained of,” Beehive Med. Elecs., Inc. v. Square D Co., 669 P.2d 859, 860 (Utah 1983) (¶ 2). The court also relied on State v. Johnson, 774 P.2d 1141, 1144 (Utah 1989), which requires a contemporaneous objection or some other specific preservation of error in the record (¶ 2).

Larsen said the issue was preserved when the district court raised it on its own during a discussion of jury instructions. The record showed that the court raised merger only as it pertained to sentencing, not whether the five counts should become one because they arose from a single criminal episode (¶ 2).

The court may review unpreserved claims for plain error, exceptional circumstances or ineffective assistance of counsel, see State v. Cram, 2002 UT 37, ¶ 4, 46 P.3d 230, but Larsen argued none of them, so the court did not consider them (¶ 3).

In footnote 1 (at ¶ 3), the court added that the argument was also inadequately briefed under State v. Smith, 2010 UT App 231, ¶ 3, 238 P.3d 1103 (mem.) (per curiam). The argument was less than one page and did not apply merger case law or the statutes allowing separate charges from a single criminal episode to the facts.

Not reached

The merits of the single-criminal-episode merger claim, as unpreserved with no exception argued (¶¶ 2–4).

Takeaways

  • When a trial judge raises merger only as it relates to sentencing, that does not preserve a separate claim that the counts should merge into one because they arose from a single criminal episode (¶ 2).
  • If an unpreserved claim is raised, the opening brief has to argue an exception. The court will not apply plain error, exceptional circumstances or ineffective assistance when none is argued (¶ 3).
  • A merger argument under one page that does not apply the case law or statutes to the facts may be treated as inadequately briefed (¶ 3 n.1).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
State v. Larsen
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 426
Case no.
20100473-CA
Filed
2010
Decided
December 15, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Larsen
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Five convictions for theft of a firearm that the defendant argued should have merged into one count

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Stephen L. RothPer curiam
Trial court
Eighth District Court, Duchesne Department · Judge Edwin T. Peterson

Parties & counsel

Larsen — AppellantIndividual(s)Michael L. Humiston
State — AppelleeState of UtahMark L. ShurtleffKris C. Leonard

Practice Tip

Do not count on a trial judge's own remarks about merger at sentencing to preserve a single-criminal-episode merger claim; make that specific objection on the record, and if it was missed, argue an exception on appeal (¶¶ 2–3).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.