Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I appeal an unemployment fraud ruling years late? Carr v. Department of Workforce Services

2011 UT App 33No. 20100768-CADecided Jan 27, 2011Employment & Workers' CompensationAffirmed

Holding

Substantial evidence supported the Workforce Board of Appeals’ determination that Carr lacked good cause under Utah Admin. Code R994-508-104 for appealing a 2001 fraud determination nearly nine years late, so the Board correctly concluded it lacked jurisdiction over the merits.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with the Department of Workforce Services and left the Board’s decision against Carr in place.

  • A person denied unemployment benefits has ten days to appeal, and a late appeal is heard only if there is “good cause” for the delay.
  • The Court of Appeals upheld the Board’s finding that Carr had no good cause, because enough evidence supported it.
  • The court did not consider arguments that went beyond the single question the Board decided.

What happened?

On October 18, 2001, the Department of Workforce Services (the state agency that handles unemployment benefits) decided that David Carr committed fraud by improperly reporting his work and earnings. The decision set an overpayment, a penalty and a period when he could not get benefits. It was mailed to Carr’s address of record.

Carr had ten days to appeal. He did not file his appeal until June 9, 2010, nearly nine years later.

What did the agency decide about the late appeal?

An administrative law judge (a hearing officer inside the agency) ruled that the appeal was late and that Carr had not shown good cause for the delay. Carr appealed to the Workforce Board of Appeals, which agreed.

Under the agency’s rule, good cause is limited to three situations: the person got the decision too late and appealed within ten days of receiving it; the delay was caused by things beyond the person’s control; or the person had compelling and reasonable reasons for the delay. Without good cause, the hearing officer has no power to hear the appeal.

What did Carr argue?

Carr said that in 2002 he contacted the Department to appeal and believed the matter was settled until his paycheck was garnished, meaning money was taken from his pay to cover the debt.

The Board did not believe him. It found that in 2002 Carr made voluntary payments on the fraud overpayment and authorized his employer to deduct payments for it. The Board reasoned he would not have done that if he truly believed he did not owe the money. It also found not believable his claims that he did not know about the decision before the garnishment and that he had appealed earlier.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

The court took up the case on its own motion for summary disposition, a quick ruling without full proceedings. It affirmed the Board.

The court explained that it does not weigh the evidence again. It asks whether there was substantial evidence, meaning enough evidence that a reasonable person could accept the Board’s conclusion. The court held there was. Carr did not show that he got the decision too late, that the delay was beyond his control, or that he had a compelling and reasonable explanation. So the Board was right that it lacked power to reach the merits of his appeal.

What about Carr’s other arguments?

Carr raised other issues on appeal. The court declined to address them because they went beyond the only question before the Board: whether he had good cause for his late appeal.

What happens now?

Nothing goes back to the agency. The Board’s August 19, 2010 decision stands.

What should people take from this?

Deadlines to appeal agency decisions are short, and the reasons that excuse a late appeal are narrow. In this case, the Board relied on what Carr did after the decision, such as making payments, to find that he knew about it.

Bottom line

Affirmed, per curiam (Orme, Voros, and Christiansen, JJ.), on the court’s sua sponte motion for summary disposition (¶ 1). Substantial evidence supported the Board’s determination that Carr had no good cause for filing his appeal of an October 18, 2001 fraud determination on June 9, 2010, so the Board correctly concluded it lacked jurisdiction over the merits (¶ 7).

Issue 1: Good cause for the untimely appeal (mixed, ¶¶ 4–7): affirmed (no error)

The record supports the Board’s finding that Carr’s appeal was untimely and without good cause. A claimant must appeal within ten days under Utah Code Ann. § 35A-4-406(3)(a), and good cause for a late appeal is “strictly limited” to the three circumstances in Utah Admin. Code R994-508-104; without it, the ALJ lacks jurisdiction (¶ 2, following Autoliv ASP, Inc. v. Workforce Appeals Bd., 2000 UT App 223, ¶ 12, 8 P.3d 1033). The court reviews the Board’s application of law to facts for whether it “exceeds the bounds of reasonableness and rationality,” and asks whether substantial evidence supports the decision, without reweighing the evidence (¶ 4). The Board found not credible Carr’s claims that he tried to appeal in 2002 and did not know of the decision before his wages were garnished, relying on his 2002 voluntary payments and his authorization for payroll deductions toward the overpayment (¶ 5). Carr did not show late receipt, circumstances beyond his control, or a compelling and reasonable explanation (¶ 7).

Issue 2: Issues beyond the Board’s scope (none stated, ¶ 8 n.1): not reached

The court declined to address Carr’s other arguments because they went beyond the only issue before the Board, whether he had good cause under Utah Admin. Code R994-508-104 for his untimely appeal (¶ 8 n.1).

Takeaways

  • The three good-cause categories in Utah Admin. Code R994-508-104 are “strictly limited,” and without good cause the ALJ lacks jurisdiction to hear a late appeal (¶ 2).
  • Conduct after the decision, such as voluntary payments and authorized payroll deductions on the overpayment, can support a Board finding that the claimant had notice and could have appealed on time (¶¶ 5–6).
  • When the Board decides only timeliness, the court will not reach arguments about the underlying determination (¶ 8 n.1).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Carr v. Department of Workforce Services
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 33
Case no.
20100768-CA
Filed
2010
Decided
January 27, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Carr
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Whether Carr could appeal, nearly nine years late, a 2001 Department determination that he committed unemployment fraud, with an overpayment, penalty and disqualification period

The panel

Michele M. Christiansen ForsterPer curiam
J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Workforce Board of Appeals

Parties & counsel

Carr — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Department of Workforce Services — AppelleeGovernment agencySuzan Pixton

Practice Tip

When the Board decides only whether a late appeal had good cause, focus the petition for review on that question; the court declined to address issues beyond it (¶ 8 n.1).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.