Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Is a child’s testimony enough to prove who hurt him? State v. Bates

2011 UT App 439No. 20100797-CADecided Dec 22, 2011Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

Bates’s sufficiency-of-the-evidence claim was not preserved because the record showed no motion to dismiss, and in any event his son’s direct testimony that Bates injured him was sufficient for the jury to find Bates inflicted the conceded nonaccidental injuries.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld William Leroy Bates’s conviction.

  • A claim that the evidence was too weak generally must be raised in the trial court first, or the appeals court may not consider it.
  • Here, the son’s direct testimony that Bates injured him was enough for the jury to find Bates did it.
  • Bates’s conviction stands.

What happened?

William Leroy Bates was convicted after a jury trial. The case involved injuries to his son. On appeal, Bates conceded that his son’s injuries were not accidental, but argued there was not enough evidence to prove that he was the person who caused them.

The State of Utah, which prosecuted Bates, was the other side on appeal.

Did Bates raise this argument at trial?

No, the court said. The general rule is that an argument not raised in the trial court cannot be raised for the first time on appeal. The court explained that this “preservation rule” gives the trial judge a chance to address and fix a claimed mistake.

Bates said he had raised the issue in a motion to dismiss. The Court of Appeals looked at the record (the official file of everything filed and said in the trial court) and found nothing to support that. There was no written motion, no motion made out loud at trial, and no page or document matching the place Bates pointed to. So the issue was not properly before the court.

Would Bates have won if he had raised it?

No. The court went on to say that even if the issue had been preserved, the evidence was enough. A jury’s verdict is reversed for weak evidence only when the evidence is so inconclusive or hard to believe that reasonable people must have had a reasonable doubt.

The court also explained that weighing evidence and deciding who is believable is the jury’s job. As long as there is some evidence, including reasonable inferences, from which the jury could find every part of the crime, the appeals court’s review stops there.

Here, Bates’s son testified directly that Bates was the one who injured him. The court held that this direct testimony from the victim was enough for the jury to find that Bates inflicted the injuries.

What happens now?

The conviction is affirmed, meaning it stands. Nothing was sent back to the trial court.

What should people take from this?

This short decision shows two things. First, a challenge to the strength of the evidence generally has to be raised in the trial court, and a claim that it was raised needs support in the record. Second, in this case, a victim’s direct testimony identifying the person who hurt him was enough to support the jury’s verdict.

The decision was issued “per curiam,” meaning by the three-judge panel as a whole rather than by one named judge.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Davis, P.J., Voros and Roth, JJ.). Bates’s sufficiency challenge was not preserved (¶¶ 2–3), and in the alternative, the victim’s direct testimony identifying Bates was sufficient (¶¶ 4–5).

Issue 1: Sufficiency of the evidence (sufficiency of the evidence, ¶¶ 2–5): affirmed (no error)

The court held the sufficiency claim unpreserved and, in the alternative, rejected it on the merits.

Preservation. Claims not raised below generally may not be raised on appeal, and a defendant must bring a sufficiency issue to the trial court’s attention, citing State v. Holgate, 2000 UT 74, ¶ 11, 10 P.3d 346 (¶ 2). Bates claimed he preserved the issue in a motion to dismiss, but the record had no written motion, no oral motion at trial, and no “page, line, or document” matching his record citation (¶ 3). The court did not apply any preservation exception.

Merits. A verdict is reversed only when the evidence is “sufficiently inconclusive or inherently improbable” that reasonable minds must have had a reasonable doubt, and the inquiry stops if there is some evidence, including reasonable inferences, supporting each element, quoting State v. Mead, 2001 UT 58, ¶¶ 65, 67, 27 P.3d 1115 (¶ 4). Bates conceded the son’s injuries were nonaccidental and contested only identity. The son testified directly that Bates injured him, which was sufficient for the jury to find Bates inflicted the injuries (¶ 5).

Takeaways

  • A record citation offered to show preservation must match something in the record; the court checked and found no written or oral motion (¶ 3).
  • Under State v. Holgate, 2000 UT 74, ¶ 14, 10 P.3d 346, a sufficiency claim must be brought to the trial court’s attention to be preserved (¶ 2).
  • Here, a victim’s direct testimony identifying the defendant was sufficient on the contested identity element (¶ 5).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
State v. Bates
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 439
Case no.
20100797-CA
Filed
2010
Decided
December 22, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Bates
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A jury conviction resting on nonaccidental injuries to the defendant's son.

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Stephen L. RothPer curiam
Trial court
Second District Court, Ogden Department · Judge Michael D. Lyon

Parties & counsel

Bates — AppellantIndividual(s)Randall W. Richards
State — AppelleeState of UtahDee SmithTeral L. Tree

Practice Tip

Before claiming on appeal that a sufficiency issue was preserved, confirm the record actually contains the motion and cite its page and line; the court found no matching document here (¶ 3).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.