Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

If the prosecutor recommended concurrent sentences, is my sentence illegal? State v. Clark

2011 UT App 344No. 20100838-CADecided Oct 14, 2011Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

A sentence that does not follow the sentencing recommendations in a plea agreement is not an illegal sentence under rule 22(e), because the district court may impose a different sentence so long as it is authorized by statute.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld the denial of Clark’s motion to correct an illegal sentence.

  • A sentence that does not follow the sentencing recommendations in a plea agreement is not, for that reason alone, an “illegal sentence.”
  • A judge may impose a sentence different from the recommendations in a plea agreement, as long as a statute authorizes it.
  • Because Clark did not move to withdraw his plea before sentencing, the court said any challenge to the plea itself would have to go through the Post-Conviction Remedies Act.

What happened?

Robert Michael Clark pleaded guilty on September 26, 2006, and was sentenced on February 12, 2007. He did not ask to withdraw his guilty plea before he was sentenced. The district court ordered his sentences to run consecutively, meaning one after another rather than at the same time.

Much later, Clark filed a motion under rule 22(e) of the Utah Rules of Criminal Procedure. That rule lets a court “correct an illegal sentence” at any time. The district court denied his motion on August 19, 2010, and Clark appealed.

What did Clark argue?

Clark argued that the State had recommended that his sentences run concurrently, meaning at the same time. He said that because the judge ordered consecutive sentences instead, his sentences were illegal. He also argued that the district court should have held an evidentiary hearing, a hearing where witnesses testify, to take evidence on whether the State made that recommendation.

He also argued briefly that the district court did not explain well enough why it chose consecutive sentences.

What did the court decide?

The Court of Appeals held that Clark was wrong. A sentence that does not follow the sentencing recommendations in a plea agreement is not an illegal sentence. A judge keeps the power to impose a sentence different from those recommendations, as long as the sentence is allowed by statute.

The court quoted an earlier case saying that “any recommendations of the prosecutor or any other party are not binding” on the sentencing court.

On Clark’s short argument about the reasons for consecutive sentences, the court said the record showed the district court considered the proper factors under Utah Code section 76-3-401(2), including a review of the presentence investigation report. That report is prepared to help the judge decide a sentence.

What about challenges to the guilty plea itself?

Utah law requires a defendant to ask to withdraw a guilty plea before the sentence is announced. Clark did not. The court agreed with the district court that any challenge to whether his plea or conviction was valid would have to be brought under the Post-Conviction Remedies Act, a separate law for challenging convictions after the fact.

What happens now?

Nothing changes. The district court’s order denying Clark’s motion stands, and so do his consecutive sentences.

What should people take from this?

A prosecutor’s sentencing recommendation in a plea deal does not bind the judge. If the judge chooses a different sentence that the law allows, the sentence is not “illegal” under rule 22(e) for that reason.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Orme, Thorne, and Christiansen, JJ.). Clark pleaded guilty, did not move to withdraw the plea before sentencing, and later filed a rule 22(e) motion arguing that his consecutive sentences were illegal because the State had recommended concurrent sentences (¶¶ 2–3). A sentence that does not follow plea-agreement recommendations is not an illegal sentence (¶ 4).

Issue 1: Denial of the rule 22(e) motion (none stated, ¶¶ 3–5): affirmed (no error)

The district court properly denied Clark’s rule 22(e) motion, including without the evidentiary hearing he sought on whether the State recommended concurrent sentences. An illegal sentence is one that is ambiguous, internally contradictory, omits a statutorily required term, is uncertain in substance, or is not authorized by the judgment of conviction (¶ 2, quoting State v. Yazzie, 2009 UT 14, ¶ 13, 203 P.3d 984). A sentence that departs from plea-agreement recommendations is not illegal, and the court keeps discretion to vary from those recommendations if the sentence is statutorily authorized (¶ 4, see State v. Kragh, 2011 UT App 108, ¶ 10, 255 P.3d 685; see also State v. Thurston, 781 P.2d 1296, 1300 (Utah Ct. App. 1989), prosecutor’s recommendations “are not binding”).

Clark’s cursory argument that the court did not adequately articulate its basis for consecutive sentences also failed: the record showed the court considered the factors under Utah Code section 76-3-401(2), including the presentence investigation report (¶ 3 n.2, see State v. Thorkelson, 2004 UT App 9, ¶ 13, 84 P.3d 854).

Plea challenges

The court noted that, absent a timely motion to withdraw under Utah Code section 77-13-6, it lacks jurisdiction over a direct appeal challenging a plea’s validity (¶ 2 n.1, see State v. Merrill, 2005 UT 34, ¶¶ 13-20, 114 P.3d 585), and that the district court properly ruled any challenge to the plea or conviction must proceed under the Post-Conviction Remedies Act (¶ 5 n.3).

Takeaways

  • Departure from a plea-agreement sentencing recommendation does not make a sentence “illegal” under rule 22(e) if a statute authorizes it (¶ 4).
  • Rule 22(e) is not a route to attack the plea itself when no timely motion to withdraw was filed; that goes through the PCRA (¶ 5 n.3).
  • A record showing the court reviewed the presentence report and the section 76-3-401(2) factors answered a cursory articulation challenge (¶ 3 n.2).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
State v. Clark
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 344
Case no.
20100838-CA
Filed
2010
Decided
October 14, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Clark
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Whether consecutive sentences imposed after a guilty plea were illegal because the State had recommended concurrent sentences

The panel

Michele M. Christiansen ForsterPer curiam
William A. Thorne Jr.Per curiam
Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Robin W. Reese

Parties & counsel

Clark — AppellantIndividual(s)Taylor C. Hartley
State — AppelleeState of UtahMark L. ShurtleffAndrew F. Peterson

Practice Tip

A rule 22(e) motion cannot rest on the court's departure from the State's plea-agreement recommendation alone; the sentence must fall within a recognized category of illegality (State v. Clark, 2011 UT App 344, ¶¶ 2, 4).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.