Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I challenge a finding that I took money from my employer? Pender v. WFSV

2011 UT App 79No. 20101039-CADecided Mar 17, 2011Employment & Workers' CompensationAffirmed

Holding

Substantial evidence supported the ALJ’s finding that Pender unlawfully took money from her employer, and given the ALJ’s superior position to assess conflicting evidence, the Workforce Board of Appeals did not err in adopting that finding.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the Department of Workforce Services and left the Workforce Board of Appeals’ decision in place.

  • The court treated Pender’s challenge as an argument that the evidence did not support the finding against her.
  • An agency’s factual findings stand if substantial evidence supports them, even if the evidence could support another conclusion.
  • When the testimony conflicts, the court defers to the administrative law judge, who heard the witnesses.

What happened?

An administrative law judge (a hearing officer who decides agency cases) found that Sharon L. Pender unlawfully took funds from her employer. The Workforce Board of Appeals adopted that finding and affirmed the judge’s decision.

The Board explained that the judge was in the best position to weigh conflicting testimony and decide whom to believe. It said it would not replace the judge’s credibility finding with its own unless there was a showing of clear error, so long as evidence in the record supported the finding.

Pender, who represented herself, asked the Utah Court of Appeals to review the Board’s decision. The Department of Workforce Services was on the other side.

How did the case get decided?

The court took the case up on its own motion for summary disposition, a short way of deciding a case without full proceedings. It did not hear oral argument, so far as the opinion says.

What did Pender argue?

Pender challenged the finding that she unlawfully took money from her employer. The court read this as a challenge to the “sufficiency of the evidence,” meaning a claim that the evidence was not enough to support the finding.

What did the court decide?

The court affirmed the Board’s decision. It explained that an agency’s findings of fact get a lot of respect on appeal. They will not be overturned if “substantial evidence” supports them, meaning enough evidence that a reasonable person could rely on it, even if the evidence would also allow a different conclusion.

The court also said it defers to the administrative law judge when the evidence conflicts, because that judge saw the witnesses and is best placed to decide who is telling the truth.

Applying those rules, the court found substantial evidence in the record supporting the finding that Pender unlawfully took money from her employer. Given that evidence and the judge’s ability to weigh the conflicting testimony, the court could not say the Board erred.

What happens now?

Nothing goes back to the agency. The Board’s decision stands.

What should people take from this?

A person challenging an agency’s factual finding faces a high bar. Pointing out that the evidence could have been read differently is not enough when the record contains substantial evidence for the finding, and the court will generally not second-guess the hearing judge’s view of conflicting testimony.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Davis, P.J., and Voros and Roth, JJ.). Pender, pro se, sought review of the Workforce Board of Appeals’ November 3, 2010 decision, which the court took up on a sua sponte motion for summary disposition (¶ 1). The record contains substantial evidence supporting the ALJ’s finding that Pender unlawfully took money from her employer, so the Board did not err in adopting it (¶ 4).

Issue 1: Evidence supporting the finding that Pender took funds (substantial evidence, ¶ 3): affirmed (no error)

Substantial evidence supported the ALJ’s finding, and the Board did not err in adopting it. The court construed Pender’s challenge to the Board’s adoption of the finding as a challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence (¶ 2). Agency findings “will not be overturned if based on substantial evidence, even if another conclusion from the evidence is permissible” (¶ 3, see Hurley v. Board of Review of Indus. Comm’n, 767 P.2d 524, 526-27 (Utah 1988)). Where evidence conflicts, the court defers to the ALJ as best positioned to judge credibility (¶ 3, see Albertsons, Inc. v. Department of Emp’t Sec., 854 P.2d 570, 575 (Utah Ct. App. 1993)), and it will not disturb the Board’s application of law to facts unless it exceeds the bounds of reasonableness and rationality (¶ 3, see Johnson v. Department of Emp’t Sec., 782 P.2d 965, 968 (Utah Ct. App. 1989)). Given the substantial evidence and the ALJ’s ability to assess conflicting evidence, the court could not say the Board erred (¶ 4).

The Board had likewise deferred to the ALJ, declining to substitute its judgment on a supported credibility finding absent clear error (¶ 2).

Takeaways

  • A challenge to an agency’s finding of wrongdoing may be construed as a sufficiency-of-the-evidence challenge and reviewed for substantial evidence (¶¶ 2–3).
  • That another conclusion is permissible from the evidence does not defeat a finding supported by substantial evidence (¶ 3).
  • Credibility calls on conflicting testimony receive deference to the ALJ at both the Board and the Court of Appeals (¶¶ 2–4).

Utah cases relied on

  • Albertsons, Inc. v. Department of Emp't Sec.854 P.2d 570, 575 (Utah Ct. App. 1993)

Case details

Case name
Pender v. WFSV
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 79
Case no.
20101039-CA
Filed
2010
Decided
March 17, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
The Workforce Board of Appeals' decision adopting an ALJ's finding that Pender unlawfully took funds from her employer.

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Stephen L. RothPer curiam
Trial court
Workforce Board of Appeals

Parties & counsel

Appellant — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Appellee — AppelleeGovernment agencyJaceson R. Maughan

Practice Tip

When challenging an agency's factual finding, show the record lacks substantial evidence for it; arguing that the evidence also permits another conclusion, or that conflicting testimony should have been credited, will not succeed (¶¶ 3–4).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.