Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I get benefits if I was fired just before I got hurt? Flemal v. Labor Commission, et al.

2012 UT App 41No. 20110022-CADecided Feb 16, 2012Employment & Workers' CompensationAffirmed

Holding

The Labor Commission’s finding that Flemal’s employment ended before his accident, based largely on a disinterested coworker’s testimony amid conflicting accounts, was not clearly erroneous, so the denial of benefits stands.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the employer and the Uninsured Employers Fund and left the Labor Commission’s denial of benefits in place.

  • The Labor Commission found that Flemal’s job had ended before the accident, so his injury did not arise in the course of his employment.
  • When witnesses tell different stories, the appeals court gives the Commission’s choice of whom to believe a lot of weight.
  • Testimony from a witness with no personal stake in the case carried significant weight here.

What happened?

Todd Flemal worked for Chad Ewing, who did business as Italian Drywall. Flemal was hurt in what he said was a workplace accident and asked for benefits. The Labor Commission, the state agency that decided his claim, denied them.

The Commission ruled that Flemal’s injury did not happen in the course of his job because his job had already ended before the accident.

What did each side say?

Ewing said he fired Flemal before the accident and told him not to do anything until Ewing came back to the site. Flemal said Ewing never fired him and that he was hurt while doing the work he had been assigned.

The Commission found credibility problems with both men. So it looked to a third witness, Nicholas Bassett, another of Ewing’s employees, who was there for much of the conversation.

Why did the coworker matter?

The Commission noted that Bassett had no direct personal interest in the case and that his testimony was direct and consistent. Bassett said he heard Ewing tell Flemal he was not needed anymore, that he was not to do any more work, and that Ewing would come back to pick him up after picking up his kids.

Based largely on that testimony, the Commission found that Flemal was not employed when the accident happened.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

Flemal asked the Court of Appeals to review the Commission’s decision. The court explained that it will overturn the Commission’s findings of fact only if they are “clearly erroneous,” meaning clearly wrong.

The court gives the Commission this room because the Commission is in a better position to weigh the evidence and judge whether witnesses are believable. Because the Commission’s finding rested on its view of who was credible and how to weigh conflicting testimony, the court could not say the finding was clearly wrong.

What happens now?

Nothing more. The court declined to disturb the Commission’s final order, so the denial of benefits stands. The case was not sent back.

What should people take from this?

When the outcome depends on whose version of events is believed, the Commission’s decision is very hard to overturn on appeal. Here the deciding evidence came from a witness the Commission saw as having no stake in the outcome. The decision was issued “per curiam,” meaning by the three-judge panel as a whole, with no single judge named as author.

Bottom line

The Commission’s final order stands (per curiam; Orme, Thorne, and Christiansen, JJ.). Flemal sought review of the Labor Commission’s decision that his injury did not arise in the course of his employment because his employment had ended before the accident (¶ 1). Given the deference owed to the Commission’s credibility findings and weighing of conflicting evidence, the finding was not clearly erroneous (¶¶ 3–4).

Issue 1: Finding that employment had ended before the accident (clearly erroneous, ¶ 2): affirmed (no error)

The Commission’s finding that Flemal was not employed at the time of the accident was not clearly erroneous. The court disturbs the Commission’s findings of fact only if clearly erroneous, Salt Lake City Corp. v. Labor Comm’n, 2007 UT 4, ¶ 13, 153 P.3d 179, because the Commission is better placed to weigh evidence and assess witness credibility (¶ 2). Ewing testified that he terminated Flemal and told him not to do anything until Ewing returned; Flemal testified that he was never terminated and was injured doing assigned work (¶ 3). The Commission found credibility problems with both, but gave significant weight to coworker Nicholas Bassett, who had no direct personal interest and whose testimony was direct and consistent. Bassett heard Ewing tell Flemal he was not needed anymore and was not to do any more work (¶ 3).

Disposition

The court declined to disturb the Labor Commission’s final order (¶ 4). No remand.

Takeaways

  • A challenge to the Commission’s resolution of conflicting testimony faces the clearly erroneous standard, and credibility calls get deference (¶¶ 2–3).
  • Where both principal witnesses have credibility problems, the Commission may rely largely on a disinterested witness whose testimony is direct and consistent (¶ 3).
  • Whether an injury arose in the course of employment can turn on a factual finding that employment ended before the accident (¶¶ 1, 3).

Case details

Case name
Flemal v. Labor Commission, et al.
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2012 UT App 41
Case no.
20110022-CA
Filed
2011
Decided
February 16, 2012
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Flemal
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Benefits for an alleged workplace accident, denied because the Labor Commission found Flemal's employment had ended before the accident

The panel

Michele M. Christiansen ForsterPer curiam
William A. Thorne Jr.Per curiam
Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Utah Labor Commission

Parties & counsel

Flemal — AppellantIndividual(s)
Labor Commission, et al. — AppelleeOtherMark L. ShurtleffBrent A. BurnettTheodore E. KanellDaniel E. Young

Practice Tip

When a benefits claim turns on conflicting accounts of whether employment had ended, expect the Commission's credibility findings, especially reliance on a disinterested witness, to be reviewed only for clear error (¶¶ 2–3).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.