Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can a parent call slapping and insults discipline? M.R. v. State of Utah

2011 UT App 180No. 20110156-CADecided Jun 3, 2011Juvenile & Child WelfareAffirmed

Holding

The juvenile court did not err in finding that Father’s pattern of slapping in anger, vile name-calling and degrading sexual accusations was not reasonable discipline under Utah Code § 78A-6-105(1)(b)(i) and emotionally abused J.R., which also supported the finding that D.R. was neglected as a sibling at risk.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld the juvenile court’s ruling that the father abused J.R. and that D.R. was neglected.

  • Under Utah law, reasonable discipline is not abuse, but whether discipline was reasonable depends on the facts of each case.
  • Emotional harm alone can be enough to support a finding of abuse.
  • Once one child is found abused, a sibling can be found neglected as a sibling at risk.

What happened?

A juvenile court found that M.R., called “Father” in the opinion, abused his child J.R. It also found that J.R.’s sibling, D.R., was neglected. Father appealed. The State of Utah was the other side on appeal.

Several witnesses testified that Father slapped J.R. and called her, her mother and her sisters vile names. They also testified that he accused J.R. of sexual activity and threatened her with an exam to prove or disprove her virginity.

What did Father argue?

Utah law says that reasonable discipline is not abuse. Father argued that his conduct was reasonable discipline, so the juvenile court should not have found that he abused J.R.

What did the court decide?

The Court of Appeals upheld the juvenile court’s order. It noted that whether discipline was reasonable depends on all the circumstances of the particular case.

Utah law defines abuse to include harm to a child that is not accidental, and harm includes emotional injury. The juvenile court found both physical and emotional abuse. Because emotional harm alone is enough to support a finding of abuse, the appeals court looked only at the emotional abuse finding.

The juvenile court found that Father’s slapping was done in anger, not as a “good faith effort to maintain discipline.” As a long-term pattern, it was not a reasonable way to discipline. The accusations and name-calling were not reasonable discipline either. In a footnote, the court said it is hard to argue such conduct is related to discipline at all.

The juvenile court also found that the ongoing degrading accusations and name-calling caused J.R. emotional damage over time, to the point that she had begun to harm herself. The appeals court held that this finding was well supported by the evidence. An appeals court will not overturn a juvenile court’s factual findings unless they are clearly wrong, and it will not weigh the evidence again when the evidence supports the decision.

What about D.R.?

Because the finding that J.R. was abused stood, the finding that D.R. was neglected as a “sibling at risk” was also supported. The court cited the Utah statute on siblings at risk for this point.

What happens now?

Nothing goes back to the juvenile court. The order finding J.R. abused and D.R. neglected stands.

What should people take from this?

A parent who claims “discipline” will be judged on the whole pattern and context of the conduct. Here, the court looked at repeated slapping in anger and ongoing degrading insults and accusations, and held the evidence supported a finding that this was emotional abuse, not reasonable discipline.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Davis, P.J., Orme and Roth, JJ.). The juvenile court did not err in finding that Father’s conduct was not reasonable discipline and that J.R. was abused (¶ 3). The emotional abuse finding was well supported by the evidence (¶ 5), and the sibling-at-risk neglect finding as to D.R. follows (¶ 6).

Issue 1: Reasonable-discipline exception and the abuse/neglect adjudication (clearly erroneous, ¶¶ 3–6): affirmed (no error)

The juvenile court did not err in finding that Father’s conduct was not reasonable discipline, so its findings that J.R. was abused and D.R. was neglected stand.

Whether discipline was reasonable “is a fact-dependent analysis,” following K.Y. v. Division of Child and Family Serv., 2010 UT App 335, ¶ 25, 244 P.3d 399 (¶ 3). Abuse includes nonaccidental or threatened harm, and harm includes emotional injury, Utah Code § 78A-6-105(1)(a)(i)-(ii), (19)(a). Because emotional harm alone supports an abuse adjudication, the court reviewed only the emotional abuse finding and did not address the physical abuse finding (¶ 4).

Witnesses described slapping, vile name-calling of J.R., her mother and sisters, accusations of sexual activity, and a threatened virginity exam. The juvenile court found the slapping was done in anger, not as a “good faith effort to maintain discipline,” citing In re L.P., 1999 UT App 157, ¶ 8, 981 P.2d 848, and that as a long-term pattern it was not reasonable (¶ 5). The accusations and name-calling were not reasonable discipline, and in footnote 1 the court remarked it is “difficult to argue that such conduct is related to discipline at all.” The conduct caused emotional damage over time to the point that J.R. had begun to harm herself (¶ 5).

With the abuse finding upheld, D.R. was properly found neglected as a sibling at risk under Utah Code § 78A-6-105(25)(a)(iv) (¶ 6).

The court applied its deferential review: it will not reweigh evidence where a foundation for the decision exists, quoting In re B.R., 2007 UT 82, ¶ 12, 171 P.3d 435 (¶ 2).

Takeaways

  • Reasonableness of discipline is a fact-dependent question; here the juvenile court properly looked at the pattern and context of the conduct (¶¶ 3, 5).
  • Emotional harm alone can sustain an abuse adjudication, so the court may affirm on that finding without reaching physical abuse (¶ 4).
  • A sibling-at-risk neglect finding rises or falls with the underlying abuse finding (¶ 6).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
M.R. v. State of Utah
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 180
Case no.
20110156-CA
Filed
2011
Decided
June 3, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
State of Utah
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A juvenile court adjudication that the father abused J.R. and that D.R. was neglected as a sibling at risk

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Stephen L. RothPer curiam
Trial court
Third Juvenile Court, Tooele Department · Judge Mark W. May

Parties & counsel

State of Utah — AppellantState of UtahJacob L. Linares
M.R. — AppelleeGovernment agencyMark L. ShurtleffJohn M. Peterson

Practice Tip

A reasonable-discipline defense is judged on the full pattern and context of the conduct, and an appellate court will not reweigh the evidence behind the juvenile court's finding; because emotional harm alone supports an abuse adjudication, the court may affirm on that finding alone (¶¶ 2–5).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.