Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I appeal while the other side’s counterclaim is still pending? Tomlinson v. Rudd

2011 UT App 243No. 20110311-CADecided Jul 29, 2011otherDismissed

Holding

Because Rudd’s counterclaim remained unresolved, neither the order granting summary judgment nor the order denying reconsideration was a final, appealable order, so the court lacked jurisdiction and dismissed the appeal without prejudice (Tomlinson v. Rudd, 2011 UT App 243, ¶¶ 3–4).

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals dismissed Tomlinson’s appeal because the case was not finished in the district court, but he can appeal again once it is.

  • An order that leaves a claim, such as a counterclaim, undecided is generally not a final order that can be appealed.
  • Without a final order (or an exception to that rule), the Court of Appeals must dismiss the appeal.
  • The dismissal was without prejudice, so Tomlinson may file a timely appeal after the district court enters a final, appealable order.

What happened?

Mitch Tomlinson sued Dr. Mitchell Rudd in district court. Rudd filed a counterclaim, which is a claim a defendant brings back against the person who sued him.

On November 15, 2010, the district court granted Rudd’s motion for summary judgment, which is a ruling that decides claims without a trial. Tomlinson asked the court to reconsider, and the court denied that request in a February 23, 2011 minute entry. Tomlinson, who represented himself, appealed.

What did each side argue?

Rudd asked the Court of Appeals to dismiss the appeal because, he argued, Tomlinson’s notice of appeal was filed too late. But Rudd’s own motion admitted that his counterclaim was still pending, and he recognized the district court’s order might not be final.

The Court of Appeals then raised the problem on its own motion: it asked whether there was a final, appealable order at all.

What did the court decide?

It dismissed the appeal. The court explained that it can hear an appeal only from a final judgment or order, unless an exception applies. An order is final only if it resolves the case for all parties and fully decides the subject of the lawsuit.

Utah Rule of Civil Procedure 54(b) says an order that decides fewer than all the claims does not end the case, and it can still be changed before the final judgment.

Here, Rudd’s counterclaim had not been decided. So neither the summary judgment order nor the order denying reconsideration resolved everything. The court said that when it lacks jurisdiction, meaning the legal power to hear the case, it must dismiss the appeal.

The court did not decide whether the summary judgment was right, and it did not rule on Rudd’s argument that the appeal was late.

What happens now?

The case continues in the district court, where Rudd’s counterclaim remains to be decided. The dismissal is “without prejudice,” which means Tomlinson is not barred from appealing later. He may file a timely appeal once the district court enters a final, appealable order.

What should people take from this?

Winning or losing one part of a lawsuit does not always open the door to an appeal. If a counterclaim or other claim is still undecided, the order is usually not final, and the Court of Appeals will dismiss an appeal from it, even if neither side asks it to on that ground.

Bottom line

Dismissed without prejudice (per curiam; Orme, Thorne, and Voros, JJ.). The court acted on its own motion for summary disposition for lack of a final, appealable order (¶ 1). Rudd’s counterclaim was still pending, so the orders appealed from did not dispose of all issues, and the court lacked jurisdiction (¶ 3). The dismissal is without prejudice to a timely appeal after entry of a final, appealable order (¶ 4).

Issue 1: Appeal from the summary judgment and denial of reconsideration (none stated, ¶¶ 2–3): not reached

The court did not reach Tomlinson’s challenges because, on its own motion, it held it lacked jurisdiction over a non-final order. The court has jurisdiction only over an appeal from a final judgment or order or one that qualifies for an exception to the final judgment rule (¶ 2, citing Loffredo v. Holt, 2001 UT 97, ¶¶ 10, 15, 37 P.3d 1070). An order is final only if it disposes of the case as to all parties and “finally dispose[s] of the subject‐matter of the litigation” (¶ 2, quoting Bradbury v. Valencia, 2000 UT 50, ¶ 9, 5 P.3d 649); see also Utah R. Civ. P. 54(b). Because Rudd’s counterclaim was unresolved, neither the November 15, 2010 summary judgment order nor the February 23, 2011 order denying reconsideration resolved all issues (¶ 3). When the court lacks jurisdiction, it must dismiss (¶ 3, citing Loffredo v. Holt, 2001 UT 97, ¶ 11).

Not reached

Rudd had moved for summary disposition on the ground that the notice of appeal was untimely, while acknowledging his counterclaim was pending and that the order might not be final (¶ 1 n.1). The court did not decide timeliness; it dismissed on its own motion for lack of a final order (¶¶ 1, 3). The merits of the summary judgment were not addressed.

Disposition

Appeal dismissed without prejudice to the filing of a timely appeal after the district court enters a final, appealable order (¶ 4).

Takeaways

  • A pending counterclaim defeats finality; an order granting summary judgment on the plaintiff’s claims is not appealable while it remains (¶ 3).
  • An order denying reconsideration is not final either when claims remain unresolved (¶ 3).
  • The court will raise finality on its own motion and must dismiss when it lacks jurisdiction (¶¶ 1, 3).
  • Dismissal for lack of a final order was without prejudice to a timely appeal after final judgment (¶ 4).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Tomlinson v. Rudd
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2011 UT App 243
Case no.
20110311-CA
Filed
2011
Decided
July 29, 2011
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Tomlinson
Disposition
Dismissed
At stake
Tomlinson's appeal from a summary judgment for Rudd and the denial of reconsideration, while Rudd's counterclaim remained pending

The panel

J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
William A. Thorne Jr.Per curiam
Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Anthony B. Quinn

Parties & counsel

Tomlinson — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Rudd — AppelleeIndividual(s)David G. WilliamsTerence L. RooneyChristopher W. Droubay

Practice Tip

Before appealing a summary judgment, confirm that every claim, including any counterclaim, has been resolved; otherwise the court of appeals will dismiss for lack of a final order (¶ 3).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.