Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I be paid for work I did in exchange for free rent? Bowen v. Hart

2012 UT App 351No. 20110447-CADecided Dec 13, 2012Contracts & Business DisputesAffirmed

Holding

Because the trial court found that Bowen’s heavy equipment work fell within an enforceable oral agreement to maintain the property in exchange for rent-free living, unjust enrichment did not apply, and Bowen’s unmarshaled challenge to the backhoe transfer finding failed.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with the Harts, the property owners, and left the trial court’s judgment against Bowen in place.

  • When an enforceable agreement covers the work done, a claim for unjust enrichment based on that work does not apply.
  • Bowen could not challenge the trial court’s handling of his post-trial motion because he filed no new or amended notice of appeal after it was decided.
  • The Harts’ request for attorney fees on appeal was denied.

What happened?

Elmer Bowen sued Kenneth Hart, Clara Hart, and their family living trust (the property owners). The parties agreed at trial that Bowen could live in an apartment on the property for the rest of his life without paying rent if he maintained and cleaned up the property.

Bowen did heavy equipment work on the property. He claimed the Harts were unjustly enriched by it. Unjust enrichment is a claim for payment when someone gets a benefit it would be unfair to keep without paying. He also disputed Kenneth Hart’s fifty-percent interest in a backhoe, which Bowen had transferred to him in 2007 with a bill of sale.

The trial court granted a declaratory judgment, which is a ruling that states the parties’ rights. It dismissed the unjust enrichment claims. Bowen appealed.

Why was the heavy equipment work not paid for?

Unjust enrichment is available only when no enforceable contract exists. The trial court found the work was part of the original deal to clean up the property in exchange for free rent. Kenneth Hart testified that the work was discussed as part of that deal, that he turned down another bid after reaching it, and that he would not have let Bowen do the work if he thought he would have to pay.

Bowen offered competing evidence. But weighing evidence and deciding who to believe is the trial court’s job, so the finding stood.

What about the backhoe?

Bowen lost this part too. Some of his complaints, about how much detail the findings gave and what the transfer terms were, had not been raised in the trial court. He never objected to the form of the order in time, so the trial court had no chance to fix it.

For his challenge to the evidence, Bowen had to lay out the evidence supporting the finding and show it was not enough. He did not. The bill of sale showed consideration paid and a final transaction, and Hart testified that he paid the ten dollars listed.

What about Bowen’s other requests?

Bowen wanted more findings added to the judgment. The court would not consider this. His motion asking the trial court to amend its findings was decided after he filed his notice of appeal, and he never filed a new or amended notice covering that decision.

He also challenged the trial court’s refusal to consider a motion to set aside the judgment. He claimed the proposed order had not been served on him. The court held the trial court properly declined, because the motion did not state grounds for relief. In any case the trial court found the order was properly served.

What happens now?

Nothing more. The judgment for the Harts stands. The Harts asked for attorney fees on appeal, and that request was denied.

What should people take from this?

When a written or spoken agreement covers certain work, a person generally cannot also claim payment for that work under unjust enrichment. And when a post-trial motion is decided after an appeal is filed, the appeal may not reach that ruling unless a new notice of appeal is filed.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Davis, McHugh, and Voros, JJ.) (¶ 13). Unjust enrichment is unavailable because the trial court found the heavy equipment work fell within the parties’ stipulated oral agreement: rent-free living for life in exchange for maintaining and cleaning up the property (¶¶ 6–7). Bowen also failed to marshal the evidence supporting the finding that he completed a transfer of a fifty-percent interest in the backhoe (¶¶ 11–12).

Issue 1: Additional findings in the declaratory judgment (none stated, ¶¶ 2–3): not reached

The request for more findings was not properly before the court. First, Bowen conceded the final order accurately reflected the ruling and did not timely object to it (¶ 2). Second, under Utah R. App. P. 4(b)(2), a notice of appeal filed before a rule 59 motion is decided is effective only as to the underlying judgment. Bowen filed no new or amended notice after the rule 59 motion was denied, so the disposition of that motion was outside the scope of the appeal (¶ 3).

Issue 2: Rule 60(b) motion (none stated, ¶ 4): affirmed (no error)

The trial court properly declined to consider the motion under rule 60(b), because it did not specify grounds for relief and relief requested within the rule (¶ 4). Even if a bare recital of the rule’s grounds were enough, any error was harmless. The trial court found the proposed order was properly served on Bowen, so the motion had no factual support (¶ 4).

Issue 3: Unjust enrichment for heavy equipment work (none stated, ¶¶ 5–8): affirmed (no error)

Unjust enrichment does not apply because the work was within the scope of an enforceable oral agreement (¶ 7). Recovery is available only when “no enforceable written or oral contract exists,” per Wood v. Utah Farm Bureau Ins. Co., 2001 UT App 35, ¶ 10, 19 P.3d 392 (quoting Bailey‐Allen v. Kurzet, 876 P.2d 421, 425 (Utah Ct. App. 1994)) (¶ 6). Kenneth Hart’s testimony was enough to support the scope finding. He said the work was discussed as part of the deal, he declined a competing bid, and he would not have allowed the work if he had to pay. Weighing Bowen’s competing evidence was for the trial court, see Rawlings v. Rawlings, 2010 UT 52, ¶ 45, 240 P.3d 754 (¶ 8).

Issue 4: The backhoe interest (clearly erroneous, ¶¶ 9–12): affirmed (no error)

Bowen did not show error in the ruling that Hart may keep the fifty-percent interest. Any challenge to the level of detail in the findings, and the claim that the court failed to identify the transfer’s terms, were unpreserved, because there was no timely objection to the form of the order (¶¶ 9–10, citing 438 Main St. v. Easy Heat, 2004 UT 72, ¶ 51, 99 P.3d 801). On sufficiency, Bowen argued his own facts rather than marshaling the supporting evidence (¶ 11). That evidence included the bill of sale, which had no executory language, and Hart’s testimony that he paid the recited ten dollars (¶ 12). Because the transaction was a completed sale, unjust enrichment also does not apply (¶ 12 n.1).

Issue 5: Attorney fees on appeal (none stated, ¶ 13 n.2): the Harts’ request for attorney fees on appeal denied

The Harts’ rule 33 request was denied without discussion (¶ 13 n.2).

Takeaways

  • A notice of appeal filed while a rule 59 motion is pending does not bring the ruling on that motion before the court. A new or amended notice is required (¶ 3).
  • An unjust enrichment claim fails when the trial court finds the work was within the scope of an enforceable oral agreement (¶¶ 6–7).
  • Not objecting in time to the form of an order can leave challenges to the findings’ detail unpreserved (¶¶ 2, 10).
  • A sufficiency challenge that argues the appellant’s own facts, without marshaling, will not carry the burden (¶¶ 11–12).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Bowen v. Hart
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2012 UT App 351
Case no.
20110447-CA
Filed
2011
Decided
December 13, 2012
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Bowen
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Bowen's unjust enrichment claim for heavy equipment work on the Harts' property and Kenneth Hart's fifty-percent interest in a backhoe

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Trial court
Fourth District Court, Fillmore Department · Judge M. James Brady

Parties & counsel

Bowen — AppellantIndividual(s)James K. Slavens
Hart — AppelleeOtherJames W. Jensen

Practice Tip

If a rule 59 motion is decided after the notice of appeal is filed, file a new or amended notice of appeal to bring that ruling within the appeal under Utah R. App. P. 4(b)(2) (¶ 3).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.