Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I appeal again after a new trial on a justice court case? Murray City v. Timmerman

2012 UT App 110No. 20120060-CADecided Apr 12, 2012Criminal AppealsDismissed

Holding

Under Utah Code section 78A-7-118(8), a district court’s decision after a trial de novo from justice court is final and unappealable unless the district court rules on the constitutionality of a statute or ordinance, and a claim that it “impliedly” did so by denying a jurisdictional motion to dismiss does not confer appellate jurisdiction.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals dismissed Timmerman’s appeal, so Murray City’s convictions against him stand.

  • After a new trial in district court on a justice court case, there is generally no further appeal.
  • The exception applies only when the district court actually ruled on whether a statute or ordinance is constitutional.
  • Saying the district court ruled on constitutionality “impliedly” was not enough here.

What happened?

Murray City prosecuted Gerrit Timmerman, who represented himself. He was convicted in a justice court, a local court that handles minor cases and does not keep a formal record of its proceedings. He appealed to the district court, which gave him a trial de novo, meaning a brand-new trial. The district court also convicted him of multiple charged infractions.

Timmerman then tried to appeal to the Utah Court of Appeals. The court raised on its own whether it had the power to hear the appeal.

Why can’t the case be appealed again?

Utah law gives a person convicted in justice court a right to a new trial in district court. Under Utah Code section 78A-7-118(8), the district court’s decision after that new trial “is final and may not be appealed” unless the district court ruled on whether a statute or ordinance is constitutional.

The court relied on Dean v. Henriod, 1999 UT App 50, ¶ 9, 975 P.2d 946, which says the right to appeal from a court that keeps no record is satisfied by a new trial in a court that does.

What did Timmerman argue?

He argued that when the district court denied his motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction (the court’s power to hear the case), it “impliedly” ruled on whether the statutes he was charged under were constitutional.

What did the court decide?

The court disagreed. Timmerman’s motion did not ask the district court to rule on whether the statutes were constitutional. He argued only that the court lacked jurisdiction, based on his view of constitutional principles. The district court could deny that motion without deciding any constitutional question, because district courts have the power to hear appeals from justice courts. Citing Myers v. State, 2004 UT 31, ¶ 16, 94 P.3d 211, the court said a wrong ruling on the law does not take away a court’s power over the case.

An “implied” ruling was not enough. Because the district court never ruled on a statute’s constitutionality, its decision was final and the Court of Appeals had no jurisdiction. The appeal was dismissed.

The court added in footnotes that any challenge to personal jurisdiction failed because the offenses happened entirely in Utah. It also said that even if his argument had been enough, it would not raise a substantial question, because motor vehicle regulations do not unconstitutionally infringe the right to travel.

What happens now?

Nothing further happens in the Court of Appeals. The district court’s convictions stand.

What should people take from this?

In a case that starts in justice court, the new trial in district court is usually the end of the road. A further appeal is possible only if the district court actually rules on whether a statute or ordinance is constitutional.

Bottom line

Dismissed (per curiam; McHugh, P.J., Davis and Christiansen, JJ.). Timmerman, pro se, was convicted of multiple infractions after a trial de novo in district court on appeal from a Murray City justice court prosecution (¶ 1). The court took up the matter on its own motion for summary disposition and held it lacked jurisdiction because the district court did not rule on the constitutionality of a statute or ordinance (¶ 4).

Issue 1: Appellate jurisdiction over the de novo conviction (none stated, ¶¶ 2–4): not reached

On its own motion, the court dismissed for lack of jurisdiction without reaching Timmerman’s challenges to his convictions. Under Utah Code section 78A-7-118(8), a district court’s decision after a trial de novo “is final and may not be appealed unless the district court rules on the constitutionality of a statute or ordinance” (¶ 2); the right to appeal from a court not of record is satisfied by a de novo trial, Dean v. Henriod, 1999 UT App 50, ¶ 9, 975 P.2d 946 (¶ 2).

Timmerman argued the denial of his motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction was an implied constitutional ruling. The motion did not ask for a constitutionality ruling, and the court could deny it without one, because district courts have appellate jurisdiction over justice court judgments under section 78A-5-102(5), and “[a] judgment incorrectly interpreting a rule of law does not divest the court of jurisdiction,” Myers v. State, 2004 UT 31, ¶ 17, 94 P.3d 211 (¶ 3). An assertion that the court “impliedly” ruled is insufficient (¶ 4); cf. Pleasant Grove City v. Orvis, 2007 UT App 74, 157 P.3d 355 (denial of motion to dismiss not a constitutionality ruling where none was specifically sought).

In footnotes, the court noted that any personal jurisdiction challenge failed because the offenses were committed wholly within Utah, Utah Code section 76-1-201(1)(a) (¶ 3 n.1), and that even if his district court argument sufficed, he raised no substantial question, see State v. Stevens, 718 P.2d 398, 399 (Utah 1986) (motor vehicle regulations do not unconstitutionally infringe the right to travel) (¶ 4 n.2).

Takeaways

  • A district court decision after a justice court trial de novo is final unless the district court rules on the constitutionality of a statute or ordinance (¶ 2).
  • A claimed “implied” constitutionality ruling does not confer appellate jurisdiction (¶ 4).
  • A motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction, built on constitutional principles but not asking for a ruling on a statute’s constitutionality, does not produce such a ruling when denied (¶¶ 3–4).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Murray City v. Timmerman
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2012 UT App 110
Case no.
20120060-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
April 12, 2012
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Timmerman
Disposition
Dismissed
At stake
Timmerman's conviction of multiple charged infractions after a trial de novo in district court on appeal from a justice court

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
Michele M. Christiansen ForsterPer curiam
Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Trial court
Third District, Salt Lake City Department · Judge Todd M. Shaughnessy

Parties & counsel

Timmerman — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Murray City — AppelleeState of UtahFrank M. NakamuraBriant J. Farnsworth II

Practice Tip

To preserve a path to the Court of Appeals after a justice court trial de novo, the defense must obtain an actual district court ruling on the constitutionality of a statute or ordinance; an implied ruling from denial of a jurisdictional motion did not suffice (¶¶ 3–4).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.