Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I win an appeal by saying the judge believed the wrong witness? American Fork City v. Thayne

2012 UT App 134No. 20120094-CADecided May 3, 2012Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

Where the district court found the defendant’s testimony not credible and the other driver’s testimony credible and corroborated, and the defendant gave no reason to depart from deference to those findings, her sufficiency challenge to a bench-trial disorderly conduct conviction failed.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with American Fork City and upheld Susan Thayne’s disorderly conduct conviction.

  • The Court of Appeals gives great weight to a trial judge’s decision about which witnesses to believe.
  • Repeating your own version of events on appeal, without a reason to question the judge’s credibility findings, did not overturn the conviction here.
  • Thayne’s disorderly conduct conviction and sentence stand.

What happened?

Another driver let her car roll into the back of a car carrying Susan Thayne and her daughter, Jessica Thayne, while both cars were stopped at a light. Both Susan and Jessica were charged; Jessica was her co-defendant. American Fork City prosecuted the case, and Susan was convicted of disorderly conduct, an infraction (a minor offense).

The case was tried to a judge without a jury, called a bench trial. The other driver, the investigating officer, and both Thaynes testified. The judge also heard two 911 calls, one made by Jessica and one by the other driver.

What did the trial judge find?

The other driver testified that both Thaynes came to her car, yelled at her using expletives, and made her afraid for her safety. Susan Thayne said she approached smiling and laughing.

The judge found Thayne’s account did not fit the other evidence. Thayne could be heard yelling an expletive in the background of the 911 call. The judge also rejected the claim that the 911 recording had been tampered with. The judge found the other driver believable because her story matched the officer’s testimony and the recording.

What did Thayne argue on appeal?

Thayne represented herself. She said she did not yell at or threaten the other driver, that the other driver “freaked out” when Thayne asked for insurance information, and that she did not talk loudly or scream. The court treated this as a claim that the evidence did not support the conviction.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It affirmed. After a bench trial, the appeals court leaves the judgment in place unless it is against the clear weight of the evidence or the court is firmly convinced a mistake was made. The trial judge saw the witnesses in person, so the appeals court defers to the judge’s decisions about who is believable.

Thayne gave no reason to set aside those credibility decisions. She raised no other issues and did not respond to the City’s motion for summary disposition, a request to decide the appeal quickly without full proceedings.

What happens now?

Nothing further. The conviction and sentence stand, and nothing was sent back to the trial court.

What should people take from this?

On appeal, simply telling your side of the story again is generally not enough when the trial judge has already decided not to believe it. The court relied on State v. Davie, 2011 UT App 380, ¶ 25, 264 P.3d 770 (mem.), which says such a challenge fails when the appellant gives no reason to depart from that deference.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; McHugh, P.J., Voros, A.P.J., and Christiansen, J.). The case came up on American Fork City’s motion for summary disposition (¶ 1). The court read the pro se docketing statement as a sufficiency challenge (¶ 3). It deferred to the district court’s credibility findings and affirmed the judgment and sentence (¶ 5).

Issue 1: Sufficiency of the evidence after a bench trial (clearly erroneous, ¶ 4): affirmed (no error)

The evidence supported the disorderly conduct conviction because the court deferred to the district court’s credibility findings. A bench-trial judgment is sustained “unless it is against the clear weight of the evidence” or the court has a definite and firm conviction that a mistake was made (¶ 4). The court defers to the trial court’s opportunity to judge credibility and demeanor, citing State v. Goodman, 763 P.2d 786, 787 (Utah 1988). A credibility challenge fails where the defendant “has provided no reason” to depart from that deference, quoting State v. Davie, 2011 UT App 380, ¶ 25, 264 P.3d 770 (mem.) (¶ 4).

The district court found Thayne’s account of approaching the other driver smiling and laughing inconsistent with the evidence, including her yelled expletive audible on a 911 recording. It rejected the tampering claim as not credible. It credited the other driver because her testimony matched the officer’s and the 911 recording (¶ 2). Thayne’s docketing statement only denied yelling or threatening (¶ 3), and the court deferred to those findings (¶ 5).

Disposition

Thayne identified no other issue and did not respond to the motion for summary disposition. The judgment and sentence were affirmed (¶ 5).

Takeaways

  • A sufficiency challenge after a bench trial that only re-argues the defendant’s version of events will not overcome credibility findings without a reason to depart from deference (¶¶ 4–5).
  • Findings that tie a witness’s credibility to corroborating evidence, such as an officer’s testimony and a 911 recording, are well placed to survive review (¶¶ 2, 5).
  • The court will construe a pro se docketing statement’s factual denials as a sufficiency claim (¶ 3).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
American Fork City v. Thayne
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2012 UT App 134
Case no.
20120094-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
May 3, 2012
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Thayne
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A conviction for disorderly conduct, an infraction, arising from a minor traffic accident

The panel

Michele M. Christiansen ForsterPer curiam
J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Trial court
Fourth District Court, American Fork Department · Judge Christine S. Johnson

Parties & counsel

Thayne — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
American Fork City — AppelleeState of UtahJames HansenTimothy G. Merrill

Practice Tip

To challenge a bench-trial conviction that rests on credibility findings, give the court a concrete reason to depart from its deference; under State v. Davie, 2011 UT App 380, ¶ 25, 264 P.3d 770 (mem.), simply restating the defendant's account fails (¶¶ 4–5).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.