Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I get unemployment if I quit over a hostile job but refused a transfer? Nave v. WFSV

2012 UT App 156No. 20120134-CADecided Jun 1, 2012Employment & Workers' CompensationAffirmed

Holding

The Workforce Appeals Board’s findings were supported by substantial evidence and its determination that the claimant quit without good cause, after refusing a transfer at the same pay and rank, was reasonable and rational; claims first raised after the ALJ hearing were not reviewed.

Key takeaways

The Department of Workforce Services won, and the Court of Appeals left in place the decision denying Nave unemployment benefits.

  • A worker who quits must show good cause, which includes showing that quitting right away was necessary.
  • Here, turning down an offered transfer to a less stressful location at the same pay and rank weighed against good cause.
  • The court did not consider evidence and claims that Nave first raised after the hearing before the administrative law judge.

What happened?

Rodger D. Nave left his job on October 5, 2011, and applied for unemployment benefits the same day. At a hearing before an administrative law judge (ALJ), a hearing officer for the agency, he testified that the workplace had been hostile for over a year.

The ALJ asked him several times to describe specific incidents. Nave had complained about stress and workload, and his employer had offered him a transfer to another location doing the same work at the same pay and rank, with a lighter workload. He turned it down because the same managers would be over both locations.

What did the Board decide?

The Workforce Appeals Board denied benefits. Under Utah law, a worker who quits without “good cause” cannot get benefits. Good cause means continuing the job would have caused harm the worker could not control or prevent, and that leaving right away was necessary.

The Board found Nave’s complaints too old or too vague. The one specific example of belittling had happened six months before he quit, two of the three people involved no longer worked there, and his employer took his complaints seriously. The Board also found he did not act reasonably when he refused the transfer.

Was the hearing unfair to Nave?

Nave said the ALJ would not let his witness testify and kept cutting him off. The court disagreed. The witness was a former employee with no firsthand knowledge of what led to Nave’s decision to quit. The court said the ALJ was trying to steer Nave toward the facts that mattered, and Nave was not harmed in presenting his case.

Could Nave raise new points on appeal?

No. Before the Board and the Court of Appeals, Nave raised new claims, including that the hearing transcript had gaps, that he had acted on the carbon dioxide problem himself, and that his pay would have dropped at the other location. He had been told several times that all evidence had to come in at the hearing. The court would not consider claims and evidence raised for the first time on appeal.

Did the denial of benefits stand?

Yes. The court does not weigh which witnesses to believe. It asks whether enough evidence in the whole record supports the Board’s findings, and whether the Board applied the law reasonably. Both were true here, including the Board’s conclusion that denying benefits was not contrary to “equity and good conscience.” The Board’s decision stands.

What should people take from this?

In an unemployment hearing, the hearing before the ALJ is the time to present every reason and every piece of evidence. In this case, refusing a reasonable transfer offer counted against the claim that quitting was necessary.

Bottom line

Affirmed: the court “do[es] not disturb the Board’s decision” (per curiam; Davis, Thorne, and Roth, JJ.). Nave, the claimant, quit and was denied benefits for leaving without good cause under Utah Code Ann. § 35A-4-405(1) and Utah Admin. Code R994-405-102 (¶ 1). The Board’s findings rest on substantial evidence, and its good-cause and equity-and-good-conscience determinations are reasonable and rational (¶ 6).

Issue 1: Conduct of the ALJ hearing (none stated, ¶ 4): affirmed (no error)

The ALJ’s handling of the hearing did not prejudice Nave in presenting his case. The excluded witness was a former employee with no firsthand knowledge of the events that led to the October 2011 quit. The interruptions and topic changes Nave complained about were the ALJ’s attempts to direct him to relevant facts and evidence (¶ 4).

Issue 2: New claims and evidence (none stated, ¶ 5): not reached

The court refused to consider claims and evidence raised for the first time after the ALJ hearing. These included alleged transcript omissions, Nave’s own efforts on carbon dioxide levels, and lower wages at the transfer location. Nave had been told in the hearing brochure, in the notice of hearing and by the ALJ that all evidence had to come in at the hearing (¶ 5). The court relied on Brown & Root Indust. Serv. v. Industrial Comm’n, 947 P.2d 671, 677 (Utah 1997): issues not raised before the agency are not reviewed “except in exceptional circumstances.” No exception was applied.

Issue 3: Good cause (mixed, ¶ 6): affirmed (no error)

The denial of benefits stands. Findings are reviewed for substantial evidence under Utah Code Ann. § 63G-4-403(4)(g), and the application of law to fact is upheld if “within the realm of reasonableness and rationality” (¶ 6). The Board found the only specific incident was six months old, two of three participants had left, the employer treated complaints seriously, and Nave did not give the employer a chance to address them (¶ 3). He refused a transfer at the same pay and rank with less workload and no contact with the co-workers in question, which the Board found unreasonable (¶¶ 2–3). The court found those findings supported and the conclusions reasonable (¶ 6).

Takeaways

  • Good cause requires showing an adverse effect the claimant could not control or prevent and that immediate severance was necessary (¶ 1).
  • The Board permissibly weighed a refused transfer offer at the same pay and rank against good cause (¶¶ 3, 6).
  • Evidence and claims must be presented at the ALJ hearing; the court did not consider those raised later (¶ 5).
  • An ALJ’s redirection of a pro se claimant toward relevant facts was not prejudicial on this record (¶ 4).

Utah cases relied on

  • Brown & Root Indus. Service v. Industrial Comm'n947 P.2d 671, 677 (Utah 1997)

Case details

Case name
Nave v. WFSV
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2012 UT App 156
Case no.
20120134-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
June 1, 2012
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Nave
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Unemployment benefits denied because the claimant voluntarily quit his job without good cause

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
William A. Thorne Jr.Per curiam
Stephen L. RothPer curiam
Trial court
Workforce Appeals Board (Department of Workforce Services)

Parties & counsel

Nave — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
WFSV — AppelleeGovernment agencySuzan Pixton

Practice Tip

In unemployment appeals, put every reason for quitting and all supporting evidence before the ALJ; the court will not consider claims and evidence first raised before the Board or on judicial review (¶ 5).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.