Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Does a later blood warrant undo my refusal of a DUI test? Assman v. Driver License Division

2013 UT App 81No. 20120270-CADecided Apr 4, 2013Administrative & GovernmentAffirmed

Holding

Because a blood warrant obtained after the driver refused a chemical test was not relevant to whether he refused, the district court did not err by not requiring its production under Utah R. Evid. 1002, and substantial evidence supported its findings that the trooper gave the required admonitions and that the driver refused.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with the Driver License Division and upheld the thirty-six-month revocation of Shane Assmann’s driver license.

  • In this license revocation case, the warrant the trooper got after Assmann refused was not relevant to whether he refused, so the Division did not have to produce it.
  • The trial judge’s choice to believe the trooper over Assmann stood, because the appeals court defers to the trial judge on who is believable.
  • The thirty-six-month revocation of Assmann’s license stands.

What happened?

A trooper stopped the vehicle Shane Assmann was driving for speeding. The trooper smelled a strong odor of alcohol, and Assmann’s speech was slurred and his eyes were bloodshot and glassy. After field sobriety tests and a preliminary breath test that was positive for alcohol, Assmann was arrested for driving under the influence.

According to the trooper, he read Assmann the required warnings from a DUI Report Form and asked him to take a breath test. Assmann said “Nope.” The trooper then read the refusal warning, which explained that his license could be revoked, and Assmann said “No.” The trooper then got a warrant, and Assmann’s blood was drawn.

The Driver License Division, the state agency that handles licenses, revoked Assmann’s license for thirty-six months. Assmann challenged that in district court, which held a fresh trial on the evidence. The judge upheld the revocation.

Why does refusing a test matter?

Utah law treats every driver as having agreed in advance to a chemical test of breath, blood, urine or oral fluids. If an arrested driver is warned and still does not agree to the test, the officer gives notice that the Division intends to revoke the license.

What did Assmann argue?

First, he argued the judge should have required the Division to produce the blood-test warrant and the application for it, under the “best evidence rule,” a rule of evidence that usually requires the original document to prove what a document says. He suggested the warrant papers might show the trooper got a warrant instead of giving the warnings. He had not raised this argument before.

Second, he argued the evidence did not show he was warned or that he refused. At trial, he said the trooper gave no warnings. But he also admitted he had earlier testified that he stopped listening after he was arrested.

What did the court decide?

The Court of Appeals rejected both arguments. The Division did not rely on the warrant to prove the refusal. It relied on the trooper’s testimony and the DUI Report Form. Because the warrant came after the refusal, what it said did not matter to whether Assmann refused, so the judge did not err by not demanding it on her own.

On the evidence, the court explained that deciding which witness to believe is the trial judge’s job. The judge found the trooper more believable than Assmann. The court also noted that Assmann had not laid out the evidence supporting the judge’s findings, which an appellant challenging findings is expected to do. The findings were supported by enough evidence and were not clearly against the weight of the evidence.

What happens now?

Nothing goes back to the district court. The thirty-six-month revocation of Assmann’s license stands.

What should people take from this?

In this case, the warrant the trooper got after the refusal did not change the question of whether Assmann refused after being warned. And when a judge has to choose between a driver’s account and an officer’s, the appeals court will usually leave that choice alone if the evidence reasonably supports it.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Thorne, Roth and Christiansen, JJ.). Shane Assmann, the petitioner below, appealed the district court’s decision after a trial de novo affirming the administrative revocation of his license for thirty-six months (¶ 1). The warrant for his blood was obtained after the refusal and was irrelevant to whether he refused, and the court’s findings on admonitions and refusal rested on credibility determinations it would not disturb (¶¶ 5–8).

Standard: review of a trial de novo on a license suspension is “deferential to the trial court’s review of the evidence” unless it misapplied the law or its findings are clearly against the weight of the evidence, Decker v. Rolfe, 2008 UT App 70, ¶ 9, 180 P.3d 778 (quoting Lopez v. Schwendiman, 720 P.2d 778, 780 (Utah 1986)); a refusal determination is a factual finding upheld if supported by substantial evidence, Lee v. Schwendiman, 722 P.2d 766, 767 (Utah 1986) (per curiam) (¶ 3).

Issue 1: Best evidence rule and the blood warrant (plain error, ¶¶ 4–5): affirmed (no error)

The district court did not err by failing to require, on its own, production of the warrant or warrant application. Assmann raised no rule 1002 challenge in the administrative proceedings or at the trial de novo, and argued plain error on appeal (¶ 4). The court found that his claim that the Division “heavily relied on the warrant” mischaracterized the record: the Division proved refusal through the trooper’s testimony that he read the admonitions verbatim and recorded Assmann’s negative responses on an admitted DUI Report Form, and it objected to warrant questions as irrelevant (¶ 4). Agreeing with the Division, the court held that proving the warrant’s content was unnecessary because the warrant was not relevant to refusal under Utah R. Evid. 1002 (¶ 5).

Issue 2: Sufficiency of the findings on admonitions and refusal (mixed, ¶¶ 6–8): affirmed (no error)

Substantial evidence supported the findings that the trooper gave the admonitions required by Utah Code § 41-6a-520(2)(a) and that Assmann refused. Assmann’s argument that the court relied solely on the warrant testimony ignored other evidence and failed to marshal the evidence supporting the findings; the court’s only reference to the warrant was in its credibility findings (¶ 6). The court deferred to the credibility determination, following Salt Lake City v. Hughes, 2011 UT App 128, ¶ 5, 253 P.3d 1118 (¶ 6). The record included the trooper’s account of reading both admonitions verbatim and Assmann’s “Nope” and “No,” plus Assmann’s admission that he had testified he stopped listening after his arrest (¶ 7). The findings were not clearly against the weight of the evidence and the court did not misapply the law (¶ 8).

Takeaways

  • An officer’s later decision to get a blood warrant does not bear on whether the driver refused, so the best evidence rule did not require producing the warrant (¶ 5).
  • The court treated the refusal as complete before the warrant, and accepted the Division’s point that the result would be the same without further testing (¶ 5).
  • A sufficiency attack on refusal findings that ignores the supporting evidence and fails to marshal it will meet deference to the trial court’s credibility calls (¶ 6).
  • A driver’s own prior testimony that he stopped listening after arrest can undercut his denial that admonitions were given (¶ 7).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Assman v. Driver License Division
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2013 UT App 81
Case no.
20120270-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
April 4, 2013
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Assman
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
The administrative revocation of Assmann's driver license for thirty-six months for refusing a chemical test

The panel

Trial court
Third District Court, Tooele Department · Judge Robert W. Adkins

Parties & counsel

Assman — AppellantIndividual(s)Linda M. JonesTroy L. BooherNoella A. Sudbury
Driver License Division — AppelleeGovernment agencyJohn E. SwallowNancy L. Kemp

Practice Tip

When challenging refusal findings after a trial de novo, marshal the evidence supporting the findings and address the court's credibility determinations directly; an argument that ignores the other evidence will not succeed (¶ 6).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.