Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Is it a crime to carry a stranger’s social security card? Salt Lake City v. Carrera

2013 UT App 181No. 20120323-CADecided Jul 18, 2013Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

Evidence that a social security card bearing another person’s name was in the defendant’s wallet, and that he told police he did not know that person, supported a reasonable inference that he knew he was not entitled to possess it under Utah Code section 76-6-1105(2)(a)(i).

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with Salt Lake City and upheld Carrera’s conviction.

  • The crime requires more than having someone else’s identification document: the person must know he is not entitled to have it.
  • Here, the court held a jury could reasonably infer that knowledge from a stranger’s social security card in the defendant’s wallet plus his statement that he did not know the person.
  • One judge disagreed, calling that inference speculation rather than evidence.

What happened?

Police found what appeared to be a valid social security card in Ricardo Enrique Carrera’s wallet. The card had a name on it other than his. Carrera told police he did not know the person whose name was on the card.

Salt Lake City, which brought the charge, prosecuted him for unlawful possession of another’s identification document. A jury convicted him, and Carrera appealed.

What does the law require?

Under the Utah statute, a person is guilty if he “obtains or possesses an identifying document with knowledge that he is not entitled to obtain or possess” it. So having the card is not enough by itself. The person must also know he is not entitled to have it.

What did Carrera argue?

Carrera argued that there was not enough evidence that he knew he was not entitled to possess the card.

What did the court decide?

The Court of Appeals affirmed the conviction. When a defendant says the evidence was too thin, the court looks at the evidence in the light most favorable to the jury’s verdict. If there is some evidence, including reasonable inferences (logical conclusions drawn from the facts), that supports each part of the crime, the conviction stands.

The court held that Carrera’s admission that he did not know the person on the card created a reasonable inference that he knew he was not entitled to have it. The court noted there are “few plausible scenarios” that would explain lawfully having a social security card belonging to someone he did not even claim to know.

Did all the judges agree?

No. Judge McHugh dissented. In her view, the jury had to speculate, not infer, about what Carrera knew. She pointed out that the City presented no evidence the card was forged or stolen, and no evidence Carrera tried to use it. She noted that the Legislature did not make possession alone a crime, and that the knowledge requirement protects, for example, a good samaritan who picks up a stranger’s lost card intending to return it. She would have reversed the conviction.

What happens now?

The conviction stands. The court affirmed and did not send the case back.

What should people take from this?

In this case, the court allowed a jury to infer knowledge from where the card was found and what the defendant told police about it. The decision is short and rests on these specific facts. The dissent shows that judges can disagree about where a reasonable inference ends and speculation begins.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Orme and Roth, JJ.; McHugh, J., dissenting). The evidence supported the jury’s finding that Carrera knew he was not entitled to possess the social security card found in his wallet (¶ 3).

Issue 1: Sufficiency of evidence of knowledge (sufficiency of the evidence, ¶ 2): affirmed (no error)

The jury had sufficient evidence that Carrera knew he was not entitled to possess the card. The statute requires possession “with knowledge that he is not entitled to obtain or possess” the document (¶ 3). Police found what appeared to be a valid social security card bearing another name in his wallet, and Carrera said he did not know that person. That admission created a plausible inference of knowledge, “especially given that there are few plausible scenarios” explaining lawful possession of a stranger’s card (¶ 3). The court reviewed the evidence in the light most favorable to the verdict, under State v. Shumway, 2002 UT 124, ¶ 15, 63 P.3d 94, and State v. Boyd, 2001 UT 30, ¶ 16, 25 P.3d 985 (¶ 2).

Separate opinion

Judge McHugh dissented (¶¶ 5–13). She would hold the jury was asked to speculate, not infer, about knowledge (¶ 6), relying on State v. Workman, 852 P.2d 981, 985 (Utah 1993), and State v. Hester, 2000 UT App 159, 3 P.3d 725, abrogated on other grounds by State v. Clark, 2001 UT 9, ¶ 14, 20 P.3d 300 (¶ 7). She distinguished State v. Kihlstrom, 1999 UT App 289, 988 P.2d 949, where there was evidence of a forgery and an attempt to use the check; here the City showed no forgery, no evidence the card was stolen and no attempted use (¶¶ 9–11). Commingling the card with one’s own property is not the crime, and the Legislature did not make possession a strict liability offense (¶ 12; n.1 noting the good-samaritan concern). She would have reversed (¶ 13).

Takeaways

  • For section 76-6-1105(2)(a)(i), the majority accepted a defendant’s admission that he did not know the cardholder, combined with the card in his wallet, as enough to infer knowledge (¶ 3).
  • The majority’s reasoning turned on the lack of “plausible scenarios” for lawful possession of a stranger’s card (¶ 3).
  • The dissent’s line between inference and speculation, and its reading of Kihlstrom, offer a framework for defending knowledge-element cases on thin records (¶¶ 7–12).

Case details

Case name
Salt Lake City v. Carrera
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2013 UT App 181
Case no.
20120323-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
July 18, 2013
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Carrera
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A conviction for unlawful possession of another's identification document, a social security card found in the defendant's wallet

The panel

Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Elizabeth A. Hruby‐Mills

Parties & counsel

Carrera — AppellantIndividual(s)Richard G. Sorenson
Salt Lake City — AppelleeState of UtahPadma Veeru‐Collings

Practice Tip

In a knowledge-element sufficiency challenge, address what the defendant told police: here the majority treated the defendant's statement that he did not know the cardholder as the key fact supporting the inference of knowledge (¶ 3).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.