Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I owe legal fees for a late motion to undo a judgment? Livingston Financial v. Migliore

2013 UT App 58No. 20120551-CADecided Mar 7, 2013Contracts & Business DisputesAffirmed/Reversed in part

Holding

An order denying rule 60(b) relief is separately appealable and its appeal time is not extended by a later fee motion, and a fee award under Utah Code section 78B-5-825 was proper where a renewed motion to set aside a judgment lacked merit and was found to have been brought to hinder or delay collection.

Practice areaCivil AppealsTopicsAttorney Fees

Key takeaways

Livingston Financial, LLC, which sued to collect a credit card debt, won: the court dismissed most of Migliore’s appeal, upheld the fee award against him, and awarded fees on appeal.

  • A notice of appeal is due within 30 days of the order appealed; Migliore’s came too late for the 2010 judgment and the December 2011 ruling.
  • An order denying a motion to set aside a judgment is its own appealable order, and the clock on it does not wait for a later fee ruling.
  • The fee award stood because the motion lacked merit and the court found it was brought to hinder or delay collection.

What happened?

Livingston Financial, LLC, the plaintiff, sued Charles Migliore in July 2009 to collect a credit card debt. Migliore did not respond to discovery, the formal requests for information in a lawsuit, so statements in Livingston’s requests for admission were treated as admitted. In January 2010 the district court granted summary judgment, a ruling without a trial, for Livingston.

Migliore asked the court to set the judgment aside, saying among other things that he had been in a mental hospital and had misread a hearing notice. The court denied that request. In November 2011, about twenty-two months after the judgment, his new lawyer filed a “renewed motion to set aside void judgment,” saying Migliore had no notice and no fair chance to defend. The court denied it in December 2011, calling it “frivolous.”

Livingston then asked for the attorney fees it spent fighting Migliore’s post-judgment motions. The court awarded $5,035. Migliore filed a notice of appeal in June 2012.

Could Migliore still challenge the judgment?

No. A notice of appeal must be filed within 30 days after the order being appealed. Migliore never filed a timely appeal from the 2010 judgment, or a motion that would have paused that deadline, so the court had no power to review it.

What about the December 2011 ruling?

That appeal was also too late. An order denying a motion to set aside a judgment can be appealed on its own. Migliore argued it did not become final until the later fee award, but the court disagreed: the December ruling fully decided the motion in front of the court.

Why did the fee award stand?

Utah law requires fees for a winning party when the other side’s position was “without merit and not brought or asserted in good faith.” The court agreed Livingston won and the motion lacked merit. The district court found the motion was brought to hinder or delay collection, which counts as bad faith. Because Migliore filed it almost two years after a judgment he never appealed, and it delayed collection, the court held that finding was supported by enough evidence.

What about the judge’s scolding of Migliore and his lawyer?

Migliore argued that the December 2011 ruling’s admonishment of him and his counsel for “overly aggressive tactics” was a sanction that should be undone. The court did not consider it. The district court had effectively dropped its plan for a separate sanctions hearing, and the court lacked jurisdiction over the December 2011 ruling, so the claim was outside this appeal.

What happens now?

Livingston also won its request for fees on appeal, because a party awarded fees below who wins on appeal is entitled to them. The case goes back to the district court only to set that amount.

What should people take from this?

Appeal deadlines run from each appealable order, and waiting can mean losing the chance to challenge it. A motion to undo an old judgment that lacks merit and delays collection can lead to paying the other side’s legal fees.

Bottom line

Dismissed in part for lack of jurisdiction, affirmed in part, and remanded to set appellate fees (per curiam; Orme, Thorne, and Roth, JJ.). Migliore’s June 2012 notice of appeal was untimely as to the 2010 summary judgment and the December 2011 ruling denying his renewed motion to set aside the judgment (¶¶ 1–3). The $5,035 award to Livingston Financial, LLC, the plaintiff and appellee, under Utah Code section 78B-5-825 is affirmed (¶¶ 8–9).

Issue 1: Appeal from the January 2010 summary judgment (none stated, ¶ 2): not reached

The court lacked jurisdiction over the summary judgment. It was final and appealable, and Migliore filed neither a timely appeal under Utah R. App. P. 4(a) nor a tolling motion under rule 4(b) (¶ 2).

Issue 2: Appeal from the December 2011 ruling (none stated, ¶ 3): not reached

The court lacked jurisdiction over the order denying the renewed motion. A rule 60(b) motion does not toll the time to appeal the judgment, but an order denying rule 60(b) relief is itself appealable, following Amica Mut. Ins. Co. v. Schettler, 768 P.2d 950, 970 (Utah Ct. App. 1989) (¶ 3). Migliore’s argument that the ruling became final only with the later fee award was “without merit”: the ruling fully resolved the motion, and Livingston sought fees in a separate rule 73 motion to augment the judgment (¶ 3).

Issue 3: Fee award under section 78B-5-825 (mixed, ¶¶ 4–9): affirmed (no error)

The district court made the findings the statute requires and they hold up. The court reviews the award as a mixed question: lack of merit for correctness and bad faith for clear error (¶ 4). The required elements are prevailing party, lack of merit, and lack of good faith, per Hermes Assocs. v. Park’s Sportsman, 813 P.2d 1221, 1225 (Utah Ct. App. 1991) (¶ 8). The prevailing-party and lack-of-merit rulings were correct (¶ 9). Under Blum v. Dahl, 2012 UT App 198, ¶ 9, 283 P.3d 963, intent or knowledge that one’s actions will hinder or delay others is bad faith, and one factor suffices (¶ 9). The finding that the motion was brought to hinder or delay collection was not clearly erroneous, given that it came almost two years after an unappealed judgment and delayed ongoing collection efforts (¶ 9).

Issue 4: Admonishment as a sanction (none stated, ¶ 10): not reached

The court did not consider Migliore’s claim that the December 2011 admonishment of him and counsel was a sanction. The rule 11 order to show cause was not addressed in the fee order and was “effectively withdrawn,” and the court lacked jurisdiction over the December 2011 ruling, so the claim was “beyond the scope of the appeal” (¶ 10).

Issue 5: Appellate fees (none stated, ¶ 11): Livingston’s request for attorney fees on appeal granted

Livingston is entitled to fees and costs on appeal. A party awarded fees below who prevails on appeal is entitled to fees reasonably incurred on appeal, per Golden Meadows Prop., LC v. Strand, 2010 UT App 258, ¶ 13, 241 P.3d 371 (¶ 11). The district court will set the amount on remand.

Takeaways

  • An order denying rule 60(b) relief is separately appealable, and its appeal clock is not extended by a later fee motion under rule 73 (¶ 3).
  • A finding that a post-judgment motion was brought to hinder or delay collection can supply the bad-faith element of section 78B-5-825 (¶ 9).
  • A challenge tied to an order the court lacks jurisdiction over, and to a show-cause matter the trial court dropped, may fall outside the appeal (¶ 10).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Livingston Financial v. Migliore
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2013 UT App 58
Case no.
20120551-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
March 7, 2013
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Migliore
Disposition
Affirmed in part and Reversed in part
At stake
A $5,035 attorney fee award against a defendant who moved to set aside a judgment in a suit to collect a credit card debt

The panel

Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Third District Court, Tooele Department · Judge Robert W. Adkins

Parties & counsel

Migliore — AppellantIndividual(s)Ronald Ady
Livingston Financial — AppelleeBusinessChristopher J. Rogers

Practice Tip

Calendar a separate 30-day appeal deadline from any order denying rule 60(b) relief; the court held such an order final when it fully resolves the motion, even if a fee motion follows (¶ 3).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.