Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I undo the dismissal of my malpractice case? Mehio v. Smart Dental Care, LC

2012 UT App 335No. 20120573-CADecided Nov 29, 2012Personal Injury & TortsAffirmed

Holding

The district court did not abuse its discretion in denying a rule 60(b) motion to set aside the dismissal of a medical malpractice complaint, because the plaintiff alleged no meritorious defense to the argument that he failed to comply with the 90-day notice provision of the Utah Health Care Malpractice Act, as required under Judson v. Wheeler RV Las Vegas, LLC, 2012 UT 6, ¶ 14, 270 P.3d 456.

Practice areaCivil Appeals

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with Smart Dental Care and left the dismissal of Mehio’s malpractice complaint in place.

  • To set aside a judgment under rule 60(b), a party generally must show a basis for relief under the rule and must also allege a meritorious defense, meaning a real answer to the ruling against them.
  • Mehio’s motion said the court ruled without seeing his response, but it never said how he would have defeated the motion to dismiss.
  • The dismissal of his complaint stands.

What happened?

Farouk Mehio, the plaintiff, sued Smart Dental Care LC, the defendant, for medical malpractice. Smart Dental asked the district court to dismiss the case. It argued that Mehio had not followed the 90-day notice requirement of the Utah Health Care Malpractice Act, so the court lacked subject matter jurisdiction, meaning the power to hear the case at all.

The district court dismissed the complaint. Mehio then filed a motion under rule 60(b) of the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure, the rule that lets a party ask a court to undo a judgment or order.

What did Mehio argue?

Mehio said he had asked for more time to respond to the motion to dismiss and the court never ruled on that request. So, he argued, the court dismissed his case without ever seeing his response.

His motion did not say he had any meritorious defense to the motion to dismiss. In other words, it did not explain how he would have won against Smart Dental’s notice argument.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It affirmed the district court. The court explained that rule 60(b) relief is generally available only when a party shows an explicit basis for relief under one of the rule’s subsections and also alleges a meritorious defense, citing Judson v. Wheeler RV Las Vegas, LLC, 2012 UT 6, ¶ 14, 270 P.3d 456.

The district court has broad discretion, or leeway, on these motions. Because Mehio never tried to show he had a defense to the argument that he failed to give the notice the Act requires, the district court did not abuse its discretion in denying his motion.

The appeals court also noted that even in his filing on appeal, Mehio argued the merits of his case but did not mention whether he had complied with the Act’s notice provisions.

How was this decided?

The Court of Appeals raised the case on its own motion for summary disposition, a quick ruling without full proceedings, because it saw the issues as too insubstantial to need more. The three-judge panel issued the decision together, without a named author.

What happens now?

Nothing more happens in this appeal. The order dismissing Mehio’s complaint stands, and the court did not send the case back.

What should people take from this?

A request to undo a dismissal must do more than point to a procedural problem, such as an unanswered request for more time. Under the standard the court applied, the request should also say why the person would have won against the ruling that ended the case.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Davis, McHugh, and Voros, JJ.). The court took the case up on its own motion for summary disposition, finding the issues too insubstantial to merit further proceedings (¶ 1). Because Mehio’s rule 60(b) motion alleged no meritorious defense to the motion to dismiss, the district court did not abuse its discretion in denying it (¶ 3).

Issue 1: Denial of rule 60(b) motion (abuse of discretion, ¶ 3): affirmed (no error)

The district court acted within its discretion in denying Mehio’s rule 60(b) motion because he did not allege a meritorious defense. Rule 60(b) relief generally requires “(1) a showing that there is an explicit basis for granting relief under one of the subsections of 60(b); and (2) an allegation of a meritorious defense” (¶ 3, quoting Judson v. Wheeler RV Las Vegas, LLC, 2012 UT 6, ¶ 14, 270 P.3d 456). See Menzies v. Galetka, 2006 UT 81, ¶ 54, 150 P.3d 480 (broad discretion under rule 60(b)) (¶ 3).

Mehio’s motion argued only that the court never ruled on his request for an extension to respond to the motion to dismiss and so dismissed without seeing his response (¶ 2). Smart Dental’s motion rested on his failure to comply with the 90-day notice provision of the Utah Health Care Malpractice Act, Utah Code Ann. § 78B‐3‐412(1), which it argued deprived the court of subject matter jurisdiction (¶ 3). Mehio therefore had to show a meritorious defense to that jurisdictional argument and made no attempt to do so (¶ 3). Even his memorandum responding to the court’s sua sponte motion argued the merits without mentioning compliance with the notice provisions (¶ 3 n.1).

Disposition

Affirmed; nothing remanded (¶ 4).

Takeaways

  • A procedural complaint, such as an unruled extension request, does not alone support rule 60(b) relief; the movant must also allege a meritorious defense (¶¶ 2–3).
  • When dismissal rests on the Utah Health Care Malpractice Act’s 90-day notice provision, the meritorious defense must answer that notice argument (¶ 3).
  • Arguing the underlying merits on appeal did not cure the failure to address notice compliance (¶ 3 n.1).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Mehio v. Smart Dental Care, LC
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2012 UT App 335
Case no.
20120573-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
November 29, 2012
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Mehio
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Whether to set aside the dismissal of a medical malpractice complaint against Smart Dental Care LC

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Sandra N. Peuler

Parties & counsel

Mehio — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Smart Dental Care, LC — AppelleeBusinessTerence L. RooneyChristopher W. Droubay

Practice Tip

A rule 60(b) motion should allege a meritorious defense aimed at the actual ground for the ruling being challenged, here notice compliance under the Health Care Malpractice Act, not just a procedural irregularity (¶ 3).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.