Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

What evidence do I need to stop summary judgment on my claim? A Healthy Choice v. Brown

2013 UT App 264No. 20120647-CADecided Nov 7, 2013Personal Injury & TortsAffirmed

Holding

Where the defendants’ affidavits denied giving information to the Consumer Protection Agency and the plaintiff’s affidavits from a part-owner and an employee did not support that allegation, no genuine issue of material fact existed and summary judgment on the intentional interference with economic relations claim was proper, whether or not those affidavits were timely.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with the Browns, the defendants, and left the dismissal of A Healthy Choice’s lawsuit in place.

  • When a defendant gives sworn statements denying the main claim, the plaintiff must answer with specific facts based on personal knowledge, not the complaint’s allegations.
  • Affidavits from the business’s part-owner and employee did not help, because nothing in them showed the Browns gave information to the agency.
  • The court did not need to decide whether the affidavits were filed too late.

What happened?

A Healthy Choice, a business, sued Michelle, Kelly, and Kelsey Brown for intentional interference with economic relations. Its complaint said, “upon information and belief” (meaning based on what it believed rather than what it knew), that the Browns gave information to the Consumer Protection Agency that caused an administrative action against the business.

The Browns filed affidavits, which are sworn written statements, denying that they had reported false information to the agency.

How did the case end in the trial court?

Months after discovery (the stage where each side gathers evidence) had closed, the Browns asked the court to dismiss the case because the business had offered no facts to support its claim. Because the court looked at material beyond the complaint, it treated the request as a motion for summary judgment. Summary judgment ends a case without a trial when there is no real dispute about the important facts.

The trial court gave the business more time to present evidence. The business filed two affidavits, one from a part-owner and one from an employee. The court ruled that they did not create a real factual dispute and that they came too late anyway. It granted summary judgment for the Browns.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It affirmed. Once the Browns swore they had not given the information, the business could not rely on its complaint. It had to offer specific facts, from someone with personal knowledge, showing the Browns had in fact given the information.

At the hearing, the business’s lawyer said an employee of the Consumer Protection Agency could supply that evidence. No such affidavit was ever filed. Nothing in the two affidavits the business did file supported the claim, and most of the employee’s affidavit was about a divorce case that had nothing to do with the lawsuit.

With no real factual dispute, the Browns were entitled to win without a trial.

Did the court decide whether the affidavits were late?

No. It said that even if the trial court had not struck the affidavits as untimely, they still did not show a factual dispute. Because the summary judgment ruling was correct, the court also did not address the other issues the business raised.

What happens now?

Nothing further. The judgment for the Browns stands, and the business’s lawsuit stays dismissed.

What should people take from this?

A claim built on “information and belief” can carry a lawsuit at the start. Once the other side files sworn denials, though, the person bringing the claim needs real evidence from someone who knows the facts firsthand. Saying that such evidence exists is not enough.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Roth, Christiansen, and Billings, JJ., Senior Judge Billings sitting by special assignment). The trial court treated the Browns’ motion to dismiss as a summary judgment motion under rule 12(b) because it considered matters outside the pleadings (¶ 2). A Healthy Choice did not create a genuine issue of material fact on its intentional interference with economic relations claim, so the Browns were entitled to judgment as a matter of law (¶¶ 5–6).

Issue 1: Summary judgment on the interference claim (correctness, ¶ 4): affirmed (no error)

Summary judgment was proper because Healthy Choice’s affidavits established no specific material fact that would defeat it. When a defendant shows, with discovery materials and affidavits, that no genuine issue of material fact exists on an issue the plaintiff must prove at trial, the burden shifts to the plaintiff, who must set forth specific facts and may not rest on the complaint (¶ 4, citing Ross v. Epic Eng’g, PC, 2013 UT App 136, ¶ 13, 307 P.3d 576). Affidavits must be made on personal knowledge and set forth admissible facts under Utah R. Civ. P. 56(e) (¶ 4).

The complaint alleged “upon information and belief” that the Browns gave information to the Consumer Protection Agency. Faced with the Browns’ affidavits denying that, Healthy Choice needed personal-knowledge evidence that they had (¶ 5). Counsel said at the hearing that an agency employee could provide an affidavit, but none was filed. The affidavits from a part-owner and an employee said nothing supporting the allegation, and most of the employee’s affidavit concerned a divorce action unrelated to the complaint (¶ 5).

The court reached this conclusion “even if” the affidavits had not been struck as untimely after discovery closed, so it did not decide the timeliness ruling (¶ 5).

Not reached

Because summary judgment was proper, the court did not address the other issues in Healthy Choice’s brief (¶ 6 n.2, citing State v. Carter, 776 P.2d 886, 888 (Utah 1989)).

Takeaways

  • A complaint pleaded on information and belief does not survive sworn denials; the nonmovant must offer specific facts on personal knowledge (¶¶ 4–5).
  • A lawyer’s statement at a hearing that supporting evidence could be obtained does not substitute for an affidavit (¶ 5).
  • Affidavits on matters unrelated to the cause of action do not create a genuine issue of material fact (¶ 5).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
A Healthy Choice v. Brown
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2013 UT App 264
Case no.
20120647-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
November 7, 2013
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
A Healthy Choice
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A business's claim that three individuals intentionally interfered with its economic relations by giving information to the Consumer Protection Agency

The panel

Judith M. BillingsPer curiam
Michele M. Christiansen ForsterPer curiam
Stephen L. RothPer curiam
Trial court
Second District Court, Farmington Department · Judge David M. Connors

Parties & counsel

A Healthy Choice — AppellantBusinessM. Dirk EastmondTerry R. Spencer
Brown — AppelleeIndividual(s)J. Preston Stieff

Practice Tip

When a claim rests on allegations made on information and belief and the defense files sworn denials, file an affidavit from someone with personal knowledge of the disputed fact; a representation at the hearing that such evidence could be obtained was not enough here (¶ 5).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.