Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can a court set damages without a hearing after discovery sanctions? BACT Limited Partnership v. Binks

2013 UT App 197No. 20120706-CADecided Aug 1, 2013Personal Injury & TortsAffirmed

Holding

Rule 55(b)(2) makes a damages hearing discretionary, so the trial court did not abuse its discretion by awarding, without a hearing, damages equal to the undisputed prior judgment the defendants’ fraudulent transfers and conspiracy kept the creditor from collecting, and the complaint adequately pleaded civil conspiracy under Pohl v. Webelhuth, 2008 UT 89, ¶ 29, 201 P.3d 944.

Practice areaCivil Appeals

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with BACT Limited Partnership, the creditor, and left the judgment against the Binkses in place.

  • Under rule 55(b)(2), a hearing on damages after a default is up to the trial court, not required.
  • Here the damages were the undisputed amount of an earlier judgment, so the court could award that sum without a hearing.
  • The complaint alleged facts meeting each of the five elements of civil conspiracy.

What happened?

In 2010, BACT Limited Partnership (BACT) won a judgment of about $211,000 against Mary Ann Binks. While trying to collect, BACT learned she had transferred substantially all of her assets to companies managed by her son, Austin. The transfers happened after the court announced its decision but before the formal judgment was entered.

BACT filed a new lawsuit against Mary Ann Binks, Craig Binks, Austin Binks, Freedom Independent, LLC, and Arrowwood Properties, LLC (the court calls them “the Binkses”). It claimed fraudulent transfer and civil conspiracy, meaning the Binkses worked together to hide assets and block collection.

How did the Binkses lose in the trial court?

BACT sent them discovery requests, which are formal requests for information. They did not fully respond, even after two court orders. The trial court then imposed sanctions (penalties) under rule 37(e)(2) of the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure. It treated the complaint’s allegations as proven and barred the Binkses from contesting the claims.

The court then entered judgment against all of them, jointly and severally (meaning each can be made to pay the full amount), for the amount of the earlier judgment. The Binkses did not challenge the sanctions themselves on appeal.

What did the Binkses argue?

They made two arguments. First, they said there was no proof of damages, so the court should have held a hearing on damages under rule 55 before entering judgment. Second, they said the complaint did not properly plead a civil conspiracy claim.

What did the court decide about damages?

The Court of Appeals disagreed with the Binkses. Rule 55(b)(2) says the court “may” hold hearings when needed to figure out damages. That makes a hearing a matter of the trial court’s judgment, not a requirement.

Here, the complaint asked for the amount of the earlier judgment, which was undisputed. Taking the allegations as true, the hidden transfers and the conspiracy kept BACT from collecting that fixed sum. So the trial court could award that amount without a hearing.

What about the civil conspiracy claim?

The court held the complaint was good enough. Civil conspiracy has five parts: two or more people, a goal, an agreement on that goal, at least one unlawful act, and resulting damages. The complaint alleged that the Binkses worked together to hide assets from a creditor through fraudulent transfers, that property was actually transferred, and that BACT could not collect its judgment as a result.

What happens now?

The judgment against the Binkses stands. The case was affirmed and is not going back to the trial court.

What should people take from this?

Ignoring discovery requests and court orders can lead a court to treat the other side’s claims as proven. When the damages are a fixed, known amount, like an earlier judgment, the court does not have to hold a separate hearing before awarding them.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Orme, Davis and McHugh, JJ.). BACT Limited Partnership (BACT, plaintiff and appellee) sued the Binkses (defendants and appellants) for fraudulent transfer and civil conspiracy after Mary Ann Binks moved substantially all of her assets to companies managed by her son following an adverse ruling of approximately $211,000 (¶¶ 2–3). After repeated discovery failures, the trial court imposed rule 37(e)(2) sanctions deeming the allegations established and entered joint and several judgment in the amount of the prior judgment (¶¶ 4–5). The Binkses did not challenge the sanctions, so the complaint’s allegations supplied the undisputed facts (¶ 5 n.1).

Issue 1: Damages without an evidentiary hearing (abuse of discretion, ¶ 7): affirmed (no error)

The trial court did not abuse its discretion by entering damages without a hearing. Under the plain language of Utah R. Civ. P. 55(b)(2), the court “may conduct such hearings” as it deems necessary; a hearing is discretionary and fits cases where damages are not easily ascertained without more evidence (¶ 6). Taking the allegations as true, the fraudulent conveyances and conspiracy prevented BACT from collecting an established sum, the undisputed prior judgment identified in the complaint, so the court could award that amount without a hearing (¶ 7).

Issue 2: Sufficiency of the civil conspiracy pleading (none stated, ¶ 8): affirmed (no error)

The complaint sufficiently pleaded civil conspiracy. The court applied the five elements from Pohl v. Webelhuth, 2008 UT 89, ¶ 29, 201 P.3d 944: a combination of two or more persons, an object, a meeting of the minds, one or more unlawful overt acts, and proximately caused damages (¶ 8). The complaint alleged the Binkses combined to conceal assets from a creditor through fraudulent transfers, the properties were actually transferred, and BACT was damaged because it could not collect its judgment, “an amount certain” (¶ 8).

Takeaways

  • Rule 55(b)(2) does not require a damages hearing after default; it is discretionary where damages are readily ascertainable (¶ 6).
  • When the claimed damages are the undisputed amount of a prior judgment that the concealment prevented the creditor from collecting, a court may award that sum without a hearing (¶ 7).
  • Unchallenged rule 37(e)(2) sanctions leave the complaint’s allegations as the undisputed factual basis on appeal (¶ 5 n.1).
  • Pleading civil conspiracy in a fraudulent-transfer case requires allegations on each Pohl v. Webelhuth, 2008 UT 89, ¶ 29, 201 P.3d 944 element (¶ 8).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
BACT Limited Partnership v. Binks
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2013 UT App 197
Case no.
20120706-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
August 1, 2013
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Binks
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A joint and several judgment, in the amount of BACT's prior judgment of approximately $211,000 against Mary Ann Binks, entered on fraudulent transfer and civil conspiracy claims after discovery sanctions

The panel

Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Paul G. Maughan

Parties & counsel

Binks — AppellantOtherDavid O. Black
BACT Limited Partnership — AppelleeBusinessRichard F. EnsorMichael C. Barnhill

Practice Tip

Where a default or rule 37(e)(2) sanction establishes liability and the damages are a fixed sum such as a prior judgment, rule 55(b)(2) leaves any hearing to the trial court's discretion, so arguing that a hearing was required will face that standard on appeal (¶¶ 6–7).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.