Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Does a settlement of “all claims” cover someone who missed mediation? Tolbert v. Kelly

2013 UT App 149No. 20120777-CADecided Jun 13, 2013Contracts & Business DisputesAffirmed

Holding

Because the settlement between Randall J. Tolbert and the Kellys unambiguously dismissed, with prejudice and without reservation, all claims arising under the case, it covered the Kellys’ claim against Kay E. Tolbert regardless of whether she was a party to the agreement, and the Kellys did not carry their burden of persuasion.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with Kay E. Tolbert and upheld the dismissal of the Kellys’ claim against her.

  • A settlement that dismisses all claims in a case can cover a claim against a party who was not at the mediation.
  • Here, the agreement’s words were clear, so the court read them as written.
  • The Kellys did not analyze the agreement’s language, and the court held they had not met their burden on appeal.

What happened?

Randall J. Tolbert sued David and Judy Kelly. The Kellys brought their own claim, called a counterclaim, against Kay E. Tolbert.

In October 2008, Mr. Tolbert and the Kellys reached a settlement at a mediation, a meeting where a neutral person helps the sides try to resolve the case. Mrs. Tolbert did not attend. The trial court later dismissed the Kellys’ claim against Mrs. Tolbert under that settlement, and the Kellys appealed.

What did the Kellys argue?

They argued there was no “meeting of the minds” with Mrs. Tolbert. That phrase means the parties actually agreed on the key terms of a deal. Because she was not at the mediation, they said, the settlement did not reach their claim against her.

What did the court decide?

The Court of Appeals affirmed. The decision was issued “per curiam,” meaning by the panel as a whole without a named author.

The court said settlement agreements follow the same rules as other contracts. When an agreement’s words are clear, a court can interpret it as a matter of law, just by reading it.

Here, even if there was no agreement with Mrs. Tolbert herself, the deal between Mr. Tolbert and the Kellys released every claim in the case. It said the parties “agree to dismiss, with prejudice, all claims arising under” the case. “With prejudice” means the claims cannot be brought again. The agreement also said it was “intended to resolve all claims relating to the legal proceedings.”

The claim against Mrs. Tolbert was a claim arising under that case. So whether she personally agreed to anything did not matter, given how broad the release was.

Why did the Kellys lose?

The Kellys did not show that there was no meeting of the minds between the people who did sign the deal, Mr. Tolbert and the Kellys. They also did not analyze the agreement’s words to show they meant something else.

On appeal, the party challenging the ruling has the “burden of persuasion,” meaning it is up to that party to convince the court there was an error. The court held the Kellys did not carry that burden.

What happens now?

Nothing further. The dismissal of the Kellys’ claim against Mrs. Tolbert stands, and the case was not sent back.

What should people take from this?

A settlement’s words matter. If an agreement dismisses “all claims” in a lawsuit, a court may read it to cover claims involving people who were not at the table. Anyone who wants to keep a claim alive should say so in the agreement. The court noted this release had no reservation.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Davis, Thorne, and Voros, JJ.). The Kellys, defendants and counterclaim plaintiffs, appealed the trial court’s order dismissing their claim against Kay E. Tolbert, the counterclaim defendant, under an October 2008 settlement agreement (¶ 1). The agreement between Randall J. Tolbert and the Kellys unambiguously dismissed all claims in the case, so the claim against Mrs. Tolbert fell within it (¶¶ 4–5).

Issue 1: Scope of the settlement release (mixed, ¶ 3): affirmed (no error)

The Kellys’ claim against Mrs. Tolbert fell within the settlement’s unambiguous release of all claims, and the Kellys did not carry their burden of persuasion (¶¶ 5–6).

Standards. Settlement agreements are governed by general contract principles, and a meeting of the minds on integral terms is essential to formation. Whether one existed is a question of fact reviewed for clear error (¶ 3, citing LD III, LLC v. BBRD, LC, 2009 UT App 301, ¶ 14, 221 P.3d 867). An unambiguous agreement may be interpreted as a matter of law (¶ 3, citing Green River Canal Co. v. Thayn, 2003 UT 50, ¶ 17, 84 P.3d 1134).

Application. The Kellys argued there was no meeting of the minds because Mrs. Tolbert did not attend the mediation (¶ 2). The court held that even if there was no agreement with Mrs. Tolbert specifically, the agreement between Mr. Tolbert and the Kellys contained “a broad release of all claims in the underlying case without reservation” (¶ 4). The parties agreed “to dismiss, with prejudice, all claims arising under . . . Case No. 030600303,” and the agreement was “intended to resolve all claims relating to the legal proceedings” (¶ 4). The Kellys did not show a lack of meeting of the minds between the actual parties and undertook no analysis of the agreement’s language; the claim against Mrs. Tolbert “is certainly a claim ‘arising under’ the case below” (¶ 5). The assertion that there was no agreement with her was “simply irrelevant” given the release’s scope (¶ 5). The burden of persuasion falls on the appellant, see State v. Robison, 2006 UT 65, ¶ 21, 147 P.3d 448, and the Kellys did not carry it (¶ 6).

Takeaways

  • A broad, unreserved release of “all claims arising under” a case can reach a claim against a party who was not at the mediation, without regard to whether that party agreed (¶¶ 4–5).
  • An argument that there was no meeting of the minds must address the parties who actually made the agreement and the agreement’s language (¶ 5).
  • An appellant who offers no textual analysis of an unambiguous settlement risks failing the burden of persuasion (¶¶ 5–6).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Tolbert v. Kelly
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2013 UT App 149
Case no.
20120777-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
June 13, 2013
Opinion type
Per curiam
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Whether the Kellys' counterclaim against Kay E. Tolbert was dismissed under an October 2008 settlement agreement releasing all claims in the case

The panel

Trial court
Sixth District Court, Manti Department · Judge Wallace A. Lee

Parties & counsel

Appellant — AppellantIndividual(s)Douglas T. Hall
Appellee — AppelleeIndividual(s)Douglas L. Stowell

Practice Tip

When settling with fewer than all parties, carve out any claim you mean to preserve; here an unreserved release of "all claims arising under" the case reached a claim against a nonattending party (¶¶ 4–5).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.