Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

If I appeal a denied motion to vacate, can I also challenge the dismissal? Card v. Card

2013 UT App 241No. 20120837-CADecided Oct 10, 2013otherAffirmed

Holding

An appeal from an order denying rule 60(b) relief does not confer jurisdiction to review the separately appealable underlying dismissal order, and an untimely “amended” notice of appeal cannot independently invoke jurisdiction over that separate order.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals ruled against Devin J. Card and let the trial court’s denial of his motion to vacate stand.

  • An order denying a motion to vacate under rule 60(b) and the original dismissal order are separate orders, and each needs its own notice of appeal.
  • Appealing the denial of a rule 60(b) motion lets the court review only whether that denial was proper, not the dismissal itself.
  • Card lost his challenge to the stricken memorandum because he did not address the trial court’s stated reason for striking it.

What happened?

Devin J. Card filed a complaint, and the trial court dismissed it in an order entered on August 29, 2012. A week later, Card asked the court to vacate, or undo, the dismissal under rule 60(b) of the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure. Rule 60(b) lets a party ask a court to set aside a final ruling for certain reasons.

Card later filed a supplemental memorandum supporting his motion. The trial court struck that memorandum because it did not comply with rule 7(c)(1), and it denied the motion to vacate on September 19, 2012.

On September 27, Card filed a notice of appeal. It named the September 19 order denying his motion to vacate. On October 18, he filed an “amended” notice trying to change the appeal to the August 29 dismissal and “the entire judgment.”

What did Card argue on appeal?

Card, who represented himself, argued that the trial court abused its discretion (made an unreasonable choice) by striking his supplemental memorandum. Most of his other arguments attacked the August 29 dismissal of his complaint.

What did the court decide about the stricken memorandum?

The court ruled against Card. The trial court had explained that it struck the memorandum because it did not follow rule 7(c)(1). Card never addressed that reason in his brief, so he did not show that the trial court made a mistake.

Could the court review the dismissal of his complaint?

No. A notice of appeal must name the order being appealed, and that requirement limits the appeals court’s power to hear the case. Card’s timely notice named only the order denying his motion to vacate.

An order denying a rule 60(b) motion is a separate order from the original dismissal. An appeal from it lets the court look only at whether denying the motion was proper, not at whether the dismissal was right.

Card’s October “amended” notice did not help. Because the two orders are separate, each needed its own notice of appeal. And even if the October filing were treated as a new notice, it came too late to appeal the August 29 order.

What happens now?

The trial court’s order denying the motion to vacate stands. The court did not decide whether the dismissal of Card’s complaint was correct, because that question was not properly before it.

What should people take from this?

When a court dismisses a case and then denies a motion to undo the dismissal, those are two separate orders. A notice of appeal that names only the second order does not bring the first one before the appeals court, and an amended notice filed later may not fix it.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Orme, Roth, and Christiansen, JJ.). Devin J. Card, the plaintiff below and appellant pro se, appealed the denial of his rule 60(b) motion to vacate the dismissal of his complaint. The court found jurisdiction over the rule 60(b) order, because the notice of appeal was timely and named that order (¶ 3). It held that Card showed no error in that order, and that his challenges to the August 29 dismissal were outside the scope of the appeal and the court’s jurisdiction (¶ 8).

Issue 1: Striking the supplemental memorandum (abuse of discretion, ¶ 4): affirmed (no error)

Card did not show that the trial court erred in striking his supplemental memorandum. The trial court struck it for noncompliance with rule 7(c)(1) of the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure. Card did not address that reason, so he did not demonstrate error (¶ 4), following Duchesne Land, LC v. Division of Consumer Prot., 2011 UT App 153, ¶ 8, 257 P.3d 441 (mem.).

Issue 2: Challenges to the August 29 dismissal order (none stated, ¶¶ 5–8): not reached

The court lacked jurisdiction to consider the challenges to the dismissal order. Under Utah R. App. P. 3(d), the notice must designate the order appealed, and “This requirement is jurisdictional” (¶ 5, quoting In re B.B., 2002 UT App 82, ¶ 9, 45 P.3d 527). Review of a rule 60(b) denial is limited to whether denial was appropriate and does not reach the merits of the underlying judgment (¶ 6, see Fisher v. Bybee, 2004 UT 92, ¶ 10, 104 P.3d 1198). The October 18 “amended” notice had no effect. The dismissal order and the rule 60(b) order are separate, final, appealable orders requiring separate notices. Even treated as a new notice, it was untimely as to the August 29 order (¶ 7, see Serrato v. Utah Transit Auth., 2000 UT App 299, ¶ 7, 13 P.3d 616).

Takeaways

  • Orders denying rule 60(b) relief are separate appealable orders, and review of them does not reach the merits of the underlying judgment (¶¶ 3, 6).
  • An amended notice of appeal from one final order cannot independently invoke jurisdiction over a separate final order (¶ 7).
  • An appellant who does not engage with the trial court’s stated reason for a ruling has not demonstrated error (¶ 4).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Card v. Card
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2013 UT App 241
Case no.
20120837-CA
Filed
2012
Decided
October 10, 2013
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Card
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Whether the trial court should have vacated its dismissal of Devin J. Card's complaint under rule 60(b).

The panel

Michele M. Christiansen ForsterPer curiam
Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Stephen L. RothPer curiam
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge L.A. Dever

Parties & counsel

Card — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Card — AppelleeIndividual(s)

Practice Tip

When a client wants to challenge both a dismissal and the denial of rule 60(b) relief, file a timely notice of appeal designating each order; amending a notice from one order to cover the other did not work here (¶ 7).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.