Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I appeal a workers’ comp ruling before the case is over? Employers' Reinsurance Fund v. Labor Commission

2013 UT App 139No. 20130174-CADecided May 31, 2013Employment & Workers' CompensationDismissed

Holding

A Labor Commission order denying a motion to dismiss a permanent total disability claim as time-barred and remanding to the ALJ for further proceedings is not final agency action, and absent a statute authorizing it, the Court of Appeals lacks jurisdiction to review it as an interlocutory appeal.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals dismissed the Employers’ Reinsurance Fund’s petition because the Labor Commission’s decision was not yet final.

  • A Labor Commission order denying a motion to dismiss and sending the case back for more proceedings is not a final agency action that the Court of Appeals can review.
  • The court would not treat the petition as an interlocutory appeal (an appeal before the case ends), because no statute gives it that power over agency orders.
  • The dismissal did not decide whether Koch’s claim was filed in time, and ERF may file a timely petition once the agency proceedings end.

What happened?

In 2008, Frank Koch applied for permanent total disability benefits for an industrial accident on December 20, 1991. The Employers’ Reinsurance Fund (ERF), the party opposing his claim, asked to have it dismissed. ERF argued the claim was barred by the six-year deadline in the Utah Workers’ Compensation Act.

An administrative law judge (ALJ), the agency’s hearing judge, denied the motion and made a tentative finding that Koch was permanently and totally disabled. ERF asked the Utah Labor Commission to review that. The Commission decided Koch had met the six-year filing requirement, affirmed the tentative finding, and sent the case back to the ALJ “to complete the adjudicative process.”

ERF then asked the Court of Appeals to review the denial of its motion to dismiss.

Why did the court raise a problem on its own?

The Court of Appeals can review only “final agency action.” The court raised, on its own motion, whether it had jurisdiction, meaning the power to hear the case. The court said it is a court’s first duty to decide that question.

What did ERF argue?

ERF argued the Commission’s decision was final because the Commission had reviewed the ALJ’s interim order, even though proceedings before the ALJ were still going. ERF said that after the remand it chose not to file a reemployment plan and had asked the Commission to review the ALJ’s final order. ERF also asked the court to treat its petition as an interlocutory appeal, which is an appeal taken before a case is finished.

What did the court decide?

The court dismissed the petition. Under earlier Utah cases, an order denying a motion to dismiss lets the agency case go on, so it is not final. An order sending a case back for more proceedings is not final either. The court had already held that a tentative finding of permanent total disability is not final until the reemployment or rehabilitation steps the statute requires are done.

The court also refused to treat the petition as an interlocutory appeal. It had earlier declined to allow review of agency orders before they are final, explaining that any exception to the final-action rule must come from the Legislature.

What happens now?

The court did not decide whether Koch’s claim was filed too late. The dismissal is “without prejudice,” meaning ERF may file a timely petition once the agency proceedings end.

What should people take from this?

In a workers’ compensation case, a party who loses a motion to dismiss before the Labor Commission generally has to wait until the agency finishes the case before asking the Court of Appeals to review it.

Bottom line

Petition for review dismissed for lack of jurisdiction (per curiam; Davis, Thorne, and Voros, JJ.). The Commission’s order denying ERF’s motion to dismiss Koch’s permanent total disability claim as time-barred, and remanding to the ALJ “to complete the adjudicative process,” is not final agency action under Utah Code § 63G‐4‐401(1) (¶¶ 3–4). The dismissal does not reach the merits and is without prejudice to a timely petition after the agency proceedings end (¶ 6).

Issue 1: Review of the denial of ERF’s motion to dismiss (none stated, ¶¶ 3–6): not reached

On its own sua sponte motion for summary dismissal, the court held it lacked jurisdiction because the denial of a motion to dismiss is not final agency action (¶ 4). Relying on Barker v. Utah Pub. Servs. Comm’n, 970 P.2d 702, 705 (Utah 1998), Barney v. Division of Occupational & Professional Licensing, 828 P.2d 542 (Utah Ct. App. 1992) (per curiam), and Sloan v. Board of Review, 781 P.2d 463 (Utah Ct. App. 1989) (per curiam), the court noted that neither a remand for further proceedings nor a denial of a motion to dismiss is final, and that an order “is not final so long as it reserves something for the agency for further decision” (¶ 3).

ERF argued the Commission’s decision was final because the Commission had reviewed the ALJ’s interim order, and that it had waived filing a reemployment plan after remand. The court rejected that argument, following Target Trucking v. Labor Commission, 2005 UT App 70, 108 P.3d 128 (per curiam): a tentative permanent total disability determination is not final until the statutory reemployment or rehabilitation requirements are met (¶ 4).

The court also declined to treat the petition as an interlocutory appeal. Under Merit Electrical & Instrumentation v. Utah Department of Commerce, 902 P.2d 151 (Utah Ct. App. 1995), which refused to adopt the collateral order doctrine for nonfinal agency orders, any deviation from the final-action requirement “must also come from the Legislature” (¶ 5). Absent a statute granting jurisdiction over interlocutory agency orders, the court could not consider the petition (¶ 5). Having no jurisdiction, the court “retains only the authority to dismiss,” citing Varian‐Eimac, Inc. v. Lamoreaux, 767 P.2d 569, 570 (Utah Ct. App. 1989) (¶ 6).

Not reached

Whether Koch’s claim was timely under the six-year limitation in Utah Code § 34A‐2‐417(2)(a)(i). The court dismissed for lack of jurisdiction and expressly did not decide the merits (¶ 6).

Takeaways

  • A Commission order denying a motion to dismiss and remanding to the ALJ is not final agency action, even after Commission review of the ALJ’s interim order (¶ 4).
  • The court would not apply an interlocutory or collateral order exception to agency orders without legislative authorization (¶ 5).
  • A jurisdictional dismissal here is without prejudice to a timely petition at the end of the agency proceedings (¶ 6).

Utah cases relied on

Case details

Case name
Employers' Reinsurance Fund v. Labor Commission
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2013 UT App 139
Case no.
20130174-CA
Filed
2013
Decided
May 31, 2013
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Labor Commission
Disposition
Dismissed
At stake
Frank Koch's claim for permanent total disability benefits from a December 20, 1991 industrial accident, which ERF argued was time-barred

The panel

Trial court
Labor Commission

Parties & counsel

Labor Commission — AppellantEdwin C. BarnesRobert D. Andreasen
Employers' Reinsurance Fund — AppelleeOtherAaron J. Prisbey

Practice Tip

Before petitioning for review of a Labor Commission order, confirm that nothing remains for the agency to decide; the court held that a denial of a motion to dismiss with a remand to the ALJ is not final and will not be reviewed as an interlocutory appeal (¶¶ 4–5).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.