Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can the parole board make me serve my full sentence? Alvillar v. Board of Pardons and Parole

2014 UT App 61No. 20131041-CADecided Mar 20, 2014Administrative & GovernmentAffirmed

Holding

The Board’s decision that an inmate serve the maximum of his indeterminate term is not a resentencing, the Board’s guidelines are not binding, withholding sensitive documents while providing summaries did not show a due process violation, and the Board’s weighing of personal characteristics is not subject to judicial review.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the Board of Pardons and Parole and rejected all of the inmate’s challenges to its parole decision.

  • When a judge imposes an indeterminate sentence, the Board decides how much of it is actually served; setting the maximum is not a resentencing.
  • The Board’s sentencing guidelines are not binding law.
  • The Board may withhold sensitive documents if it gives the inmate summaries, and courts review only the fairness of its process, not the result.

What happened?

In April 2012, Guido Alvillar was sentenced to three concurrent indeterminate terms of zero to five years in prison. An indeterminate term is a range, not a fixed number of years. His convictions were for one count of unlawful acquisition, possession, or transfer of a financial transaction card and two counts of theft by deception, all third degree felonies.

In July 2012 he had his first parole hearing before a hearing officer of the Board of Pardons and Parole (the Board). On August 2, 2012, the Board decided he would not get parole and should serve the full five years.

How did the case reach the Court of Appeals?

Alvillar filed a petition for extraordinary relief, a request asking a court to step in against a government body’s action. The district court granted summary judgment for the Board, meaning it ruled without a trial. Alvillar, who represented himself, appealed. The Court of Appeals took the case up on its own motion for summary disposition, a quick way of deciding an appeal.

What can a court review about a parole decision?

Very little. Utah law says the Board’s parole decisions “are final and are not subject to judicial review.” Courts can look only at whether the Board’s process was fair, not at the result.

Was Alvillar resentenced without a hearing?

No. Alvillar pointed to comments by the hearing officer suggesting she would not recommend going over the guidelines. But the district court, not the Board, sentenced him. The Board only decided how much of that sentence he would actually serve, which is its job. Because five years was within his sentence range, the decision could not be called arbitrary absent unusual circumstances. The Board also did not have to follow the twenty-month guideline, because its guidelines are not binding law.

Was it unfair that he did not see his whole file?

No. An inmate must know what information the Board will consider in time to respond. But the Board may withhold sensitive material if it provides summaries. The Board showed that some documents were withheld for safety and security reasons and that Alvillar got summaries of them. The hearing officer’s recommendation, written after the hearing, was protected under the state’s public records law. Alvillar’s claim that he did not get every document was not enough to show a due process violation, meaning a denial of fair procedures.

Could the Board consider his personal characteristics?

Yes. The Board may weigh any factors it considers relevant to parole, and that is not something courts review.

What happens now?

Nothing further. The court affirmed, so the Board’s decision stands.

What should people take from this?

Challenges to a parole decision in Utah court have to focus on unfair procedure, not on whether the Board reached the right result.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Orme, McHugh and Roth, JJ.; Judge McHugh voted but resigned before the decision issued). On the court’s sua sponte motion for summary disposition, the court upheld summary judgment against Alvillar’s petition for extraordinary relief challenging the Board’s decision that he serve his full five-year term (¶¶ 1–2, 7). Under Utah Code § 77-27-5(3), parole decisions “are final and are not subject to judicial review”; review reaches only the fairness of the process (¶ 3, citing Lancaster v. Board of Pardons, 869 P.2d 945, 947 (Utah 1994)).

Issue 1: Resentencing and the guidelines (none stated, ¶ 4): affirmed (no error)

The Board’s decision that Alvillar serve the maximum term was not a resentencing. The district court imposed the zero-to-five terms; the Board, exercising its statutory authority, decided the time actually served (¶¶ 3–4, citing Preece v. House, 886 P.2d 508, 512 (Utah 1994)). A term within the indeterminate range, “absent unusual circumstances, cannot be arbitrary and capricious” (¶ 4, quoting Monson v. Carver, 928 P.2d 1017, 1023 (Utah 1996)). The twenty-month matrix guideline did not bind the Board because the guidelines “do not have the force and effect of law” (¶ 4, quoting Preece v. House, 886 P.2d 508, 511 (Utah 1994)).

Issue 2: Nondisclosure of file documents (none stated, ¶ 5): affirmed (no error)

Alvillar’s claim that he did not receive every document did not create a material fact issue or show a procedural due process violation. Under Labrum v. Board of Pardons, 870 P.2d 902 (Utah 1993), the inmate must know in advance what the Board will consider, but the Board may withhold sources and provide summaries where confidentiality is required (¶ 5). The Board’s affidavit showed summaries were provided for documents withheld for safety and security reasons, and the hearing officer’s post-hearing recommendation was protected under Utah Code § 63G-2-305(34) of GRAMA. Alvillar did not show that this procedure denied due process (¶ 5).

Issue 3: Reliance on personal characteristics (none stated, ¶ 6): affirmed (no error)

The district court correctly rejected this claim because the Board may weigh any factors it deems relevant to parole, “precisely the kind of issue [that is] not subject to judicial review” (¶ 6, quoting Northern v. Barnes, 825 P.2d 696, 699 (Utah Ct. App. 1992)).

Takeaways

  • Frame a challenge to a parole denial as a process defect; the result itself is not reviewable (¶ 3).
  • A term within the indeterminate range set by the court is not a resentencing, and the guidelines create at most a “tenuous” expectation of release (¶ 4).
  • An inmate’s bare assertion that some file documents were withheld does not defeat summary judgment where the Board shows its basis for withholding and that summaries were provided (¶ 5).
Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Alvillar v. Board of Pardons and Parole
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2014 UT App 61
Case no.
20131041-CA
Filed
2013
Decided
March 20, 2014
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Alvillar
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
An inmate's challenge to the Board of Pardons and Parole's decision denying parole and requiring him to serve the maximum five-year sentence

The panel

Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Stephen L. RothPer curiam
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge L.A. Dever

Parties & counsel

Alvillar — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Board of Pardons and Parole — AppelleeGovernment agencySean D. ReyesAmanda N. MontagueBridget K. Romano

Practice Tip

In a petition challenging a parole denial, show specifically how the Board's disclosure procedure was unfair; asserting only that some documents were withheld will not defeat summary judgment when the Board shows it gave summaries (¶ 5).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.