Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I seek custody after a court ruled I’m not the father? Mackley v. Barney

2014 UT App 202No. 20140311-CADecided Aug 21, 2014Family LawAffirmed

Holding

Claim preclusion barred Mackley’s petition for custody and support because the same parties litigated two prior actions that ended in final judgments resolving paternity, and his new claims arose from the same operative facts.

Practice areaFamily Law Appeals

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with Adrienne Barney and upheld the dismissal of Adam Mackley’s custody petition.

  • A custody request that depends on being the child’s parent can be barred when earlier cases already decided who the parent is.
  • Adding new requests, such as custody or support, does not avoid the bar if they rest on the same facts as the earlier cases.
  • A judgment is final for this purpose unless it is reversed on appeal or set aside.

What happened?

Adam Mackley and Adrienne Barney had been in court twice before over a child. In 2011, Mackley brought a paternity action, a case asking the court to decide who a child’s father is. In 2013, Barney’s husband filed a petition for declaratory relief, which asks a court to declare the parties’ legal rights.

On November 26, 2013, the district court resolved both cases. It dismissed Mackley’s paternity petition and declared Barney’s husband the father of the child.

Mackley then filed a new petition, the one involved in this appeal. He asked for custody of the child and for the court to sort out support obligations based on the custody change he wanted. Barney moved to dismiss it, and the district court granted her motion based on res judicata.

What is res judicata?

Res judicata is a set of rules that keeps people from going back to court over a dispute that has already been decided. One branch, called claim preclusion, bars a new case when three things are true: the same parties were in the earlier case, the new claims were raised or could and should have been raised earlier, and the earlier case ended in a final judgment on the merits.

What did Mackley argue?

Mackley argued that he was raising new issues that were not part of the earlier cases. He also pointed to matters such as DNA testing, a voluntary denial of paternity, and what he said was fraud on the court by Barney’s husband. He argued none of these had been decided before.

What did the court decide?

The Court of Appeals agreed with the district court. Barney asked the court to decide the appeal quickly on the ground that it raised no substantial question, and the court affirmed.

All three parts of claim preclusion were met. Mackley and Barney were both parties to the two earlier cases. His custody and support requests all depended on his being the child’s parent, which had already been decided. Even looking past his petition, which did not raise the DNA, denial and fraud issues, those matters came from the same facts as the earlier cases, so they could have been raised there.

Finally, the November 26, 2013 rulings were final judgments. A judgment stays final for this purpose until it is reversed on appeal or set aside.

What happens now?

The dismissal of Mackley’s petition stands. Nothing goes back to the district court.

What should people take from this?

When a court has already decided who a child’s parent is, a later request for custody or support that depends on a different answer is likely to run into the same bar. Arguments about the earlier decision belong in that earlier case or its appeal, not in a new lawsuit built on the same facts.

Bottom line

Affirmed, per curiam (Orme, Voros and Greenwood, JJ.; Senior Judge Greenwood sitting by special appointment). The court decided the case on appellee Adrienne Barney’s motion for summary disposition under Utah R. App. P. 10(a)(2)(A), on the ground that the issues were too insubstantial to merit further proceedings (¶ 1). Appellant Adam Mackley, who was pro se, had petitioned for custody and support. All three elements of claim preclusion were met, so the district court correctly dismissed on res judicata grounds (¶¶ 3–6).

Issue 1: Res judicata (correctness, ¶ 2): affirmed (no error)

The district court correctly held Mackley’s claims barred by claim preclusion. The court applied the three-part test from Snyder v. Murray City Corp., 2003 UT 13, ¶ 34, 73 P.3d 325: same parties or privies, claims that were or could and should have been raised, and a final judgment on the merits (¶ 2).

Same parties: Mackley and Barney were both parties to Mackley’s 2011 paternity action and to a 2013 declaratory relief petition brought by Barney’s husband (¶ 3).

Same claims: custody and support “can only come into play” if Mackley is adjudicated a parent, and paternity was resolved in the prior actions. So the added requests all rested on the claimed inaccuracy of the earlier decisions (¶ 4). Mackley’s issues not pleaded in his petition (DNA testing, a voluntary denial of paternity, and alleged fraud on the court by Barney’s husband) arose from the same operative facts. Under Mack v. Division of Sec., 2009 UT 47, ¶ 30, 221 P.3d 194, they were claims that could have been brought in the first action (¶ 5).

Final judgment: on November 26, 2013, the district court dismissed Mackley’s paternity petition and declared Barney’s husband the father. Those were final judgments, following Copper State Thrift & Loan v. Bruno, 735 P.2d 387, 390 (Utah Ct. App. 1987): a judgment is final for res judicata purposes “until reversed on appeal or modified or set aside” (¶ 6).

Takeaways

  • Custody and support claims that depend on parentage are precluded when a prior final judgment has resolved parentage against the claimant (¶ 4).
  • Adding new theories (DNA testing, a voluntary denial of paternity, fraud on the court) does not avoid preclusion if they arise from the same operative facts (¶ 5).
  • A prior order counts as final for res judicata until it is reversed, modified or set aside (¶ 6).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Mackley v. Barney
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2014 UT App 202
Case no.
20140311-CA
Filed
2014
Decided
August 21, 2014
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
Mackley
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Mackley's petition for custody of the child and for related support orders, dismissed as barred by res judicata after earlier cases declared Barney's husband the child's father

The panel

Pamela T. GreenwoodPer curiam
J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Fourth District Court, Provo Department · Judge David N. Mortensen

Parties & counsel

Mackley — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Barney — AppelleeIndividual(s)Lorie D. FowlkeMichael S. Glassford

Practice Tip

Before filing a custody or support petition after an adverse paternity judgment, note that claims depending on parentage, and theories such as DNA testing or fraud arising from the same facts, may be precluded unless the earlier judgment is reversed or set aside (¶¶ 4–6).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.