Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I appeal a water rate hike if I never joined the case? Uhlig v. PSC

2014 UT App 232No. 20140635-CADecided Oct 2, 2014Administrative & GovernmentDismissed

Holding

A person who neither sought nor obtained intervention in a Public Service Commission proceeding is not a party entitled to seek agency review under Utah Code section 63G-4-301(1)(a), and, like the ratepayers in Ball v. Public Service Commission, 2007 UT 79, 175 P.3d 545, falls outside the classes granted standing for judicial review by Utah Code section 54-7-15.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the Public Service Commission and dismissed Werner Uhlig’s petition because he lacked standing.

  • Speaking at a public comment hearing did not make Uhlig a party to the Commission’s rate case.
  • Because he never asked to intervene before the deadline, he could not ask the Commission to review its order.
  • He also did not fall within the group of people the statute allows to seek court review of Commission orders, so his petition was dismissed.

What happened?

In July 2013, Hi-Country Estates Homeowners Association applied to the Public Service Commission, the state agency that oversees utility rates, for approval of water service schedules and rates. The Commission set December 27, 2013, as the deadline for anyone who wanted to intervene, meaning formally join the case as a party.

Werner Uhlig did not ask to intervene. He did testify at a separate hearing the Commission held to take statements from the public. He objected to a proposed standby fee increase as a resident of Hi-Country Estates and as a private well owner not connected to its water system.

In May 2014, the Commission approved the rates. Uhlig then asked the Commission to review or rehear its decision. The Commission refused, ruling that only a party could make that request. Uhlig then asked the Court of Appeals to review that ruling.

What did each side argue?

Uhlig, who represented himself, claimed the Commission did not give enough information about how to ask to intervene. The Commission asked the court to decide the case quickly in its favor, a request called summary disposition. Hi-Country Estates joined that request.

What did the court decide?

First, the court let Hi-Country Estates intervene in the court case.

Second, it agreed with the Commission. Under Utah’s Administrative Procedures Act, only parties can ask an agency to review its own order. A “party” includes people the agency allows to intervene. Uhlig never asked to intervene, and the deadline passed. The court said his claim about missing information on how to intervene “lacks merit.”

Third, the court held that Uhlig had no standing, meaning no legal right, to bring his challenge to court. Usually a person who was not a party before the agency cannot seek court review. A statute does allow certain people to challenge Commission orders, including any “party, stockholder, bondholder, or other person pecuniarily interested in the public utility,” meaning someone with a financial stake in the utility itself. The court relied on Ball v. Public Service Commission, 2007 UT 79, 175 P.3d 545, where the Utah Supreme Court held that ratepayers, though harmed by higher bills, have no financial stake in the utility and so lack standing. The court said it follows that Uhlig is not in that group either.

What happens now?

The petition is dismissed. The Commission’s order approving the rates is not disturbed by this case.

What should people take from this?

Testifying at a public hearing is not the same as being a party. In this case, the person who did not formally ask to intervene by the agency’s deadline lost the ability to ask the agency, and then a court, to review the result.

Bottom line

Commission’s decision affirmed; petition for review dismissed (per curiam; Orme and Christiansen, JJ., and Bench, Sr. J.). A resident who testified at a public-comment hearing but never moved to intervene was not a party and could not seek agency review (¶ 5), and as a ratepayer-type objector he lacked statutory standing to seek judicial review (¶ 6). The case came before the court on the Commission’s motion for summary disposition, which Hi-Country Estates joined (¶¶ 1, 3).

Issue 1: Hi-Country Estates’ motion to intervene (none stated, ¶ 1): Hi-Country Estates’ motion to intervene granted

The court granted Hi-Country Estates Homeowners Association’s motion to intervene in the judicial review proceeding. The opinion gives no separate analysis (¶ 1).

Issue 2: Standing to seek agency review and judicial review (none stated, ¶¶ 4–7): affirmed (no error)

The court affirmed the Commission’s decision that Uhlig lacked standing to seek agency review, and dismissed the petition for judicial review because Uhlig also lacked standing to seek judicial review (¶ 7).

Part 1: Standing to seek agency review (¶¶ 4–5)

Following Ball v. Public Service Commission, 2007 UT 79, 175 P.3d 545, the court first decided whether the Commission correctly resolved standing below, since standing on judicial review depends on that answer (¶ 4). Utah Code section 63G-4-301(1)(a) permits only “parties” to seek agency review, and section 63G-4-103(1)(f) defines parties to include persons permitted to intervene (¶ 5). It was undisputed that Uhlig never sought intervention before the scheduling order’s deadline, and his claim that the Commission did not adequately explain how to intervene “lacks merit” (¶ 5).

Part 2: Standing to seek judicial review (¶¶ 6–7)

The court dismissed the petition for lack of standing without reaching Uhlig’s challenge to the rate order. A nonparty to the agency proceeding generally lacks standing to seek judicial review (¶ 6, citing Ball, 2007 UT 79, ¶ 44). Utah Code section 54-7-15 grants standing to a “party, stockholder, bondholder, or other person pecuniarily interested in the public utility,” and Ball, 2007 UT 79, ¶ 57, held ratepayers lack appellate standing because they have no pecuniary interest in the utility (¶ 6). “It follows” that Uhlig is outside the statutory classes (¶¶ 6–7).

Takeaways

  • Giving public-comment testimony did not make the objector a party under UAPA; intervention under the scheduling order was required to seek agency review (¶¶ 2, 5).
  • Standing on judicial review followed from the standing ruling below: the court decided agency-level standing first, as Ball, 2007 UT 79, 175 P.3d 545, directs (¶ 4).
  • Under section 54-7-15 as read in Ball, a nonparty objector harmed only by rates was not “pecuniarily interested in the public utility” (¶ 6).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Uhlig v. PSC
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2014 UT App 232
Case no.
20140635-CA
Filed
2014
Decided
October 2, 2014
Opinion type
Per curiam
Disposition
Dismissed
At stake
A resident's challenge to a Commission order approving Hi-Country Estates' proposed water service schedules and rates, including a standby fee rate increase

The panel

Russell W. BenchPer curiam
Michele M. Christiansen ForsterPer curiam
Gregory K. OrmePer curiam
Trial court
Public Service Commission of Utah

Parties & counsel

Appellant — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
Appellee — AppelleeGovernment agencyMelanie A. Reif

Practice Tip

A client who wants to preserve a challenge to a Public Service Commission order should move to intervene before the scheduling order's deadline; testifying at a public-comment hearing did not confer party status (¶¶ 2, 5).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.