Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Must a jury agree on which act supports each abuse count? State v. Hall

2026 UT App 121No. 20250089-CADecided Aug 6, 2026Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

The Unanimous Verdict Clause was satisfied where the State elected a distinct act for each of two similar counts and the jury was specifically instructed to agree on the act for each count, and an unpreserved Allen-charge challenge will not be reviewed when no preservation exception is invoked in the opening brief.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld Michael Hall’s two convictions.

  • When the State links each count to a specific act and the jury is told it must agree on the act for each count, the unanimity requirement was met in this case.
  • A problem not raised in the trial court usually will not be reviewed on appeal unless the opening brief argues a recognized exception.
  • An exception raised for the first time in a reply brief comes too late.

What happened?

Hall was charged with one count of sodomy upon a child and six counts of aggravated sexual abuse of a child. The child, called “Molly” in the opinion (a made-up name), testified about two separate incidents of touching: one in the TV room and one in Hall’s bedroom.

After a seven-day trial, the jury convicted Hall of the two counts based on those incidents and acquitted him of the other five.

How was the jury told to handle the two counts?

While the lawyers and judge worked out the jury instructions, the prosecutor proposed tying one count to the TV room and the other to the bedroom. Hall’s lawyer said, “I think that’s appropriate.” The instructions told jurors they had to agree unanimously on “which occasion and which act” supported each count.

What did Hall argue?

He made two arguments. First, he said the two counts could not be told apart, so the jury might not have agreed on which act supported each one. Second, he challenged the judge’s answer to a jury note. That note said the jury could not agree on one count. Without calling in the lawyers, the judge told the jurors to keep deliberating until all agreed guilty or not guilty. Hall said this answer, a kind of “Allen charge” (an instruction urging a stuck jury to keep trying), pressured the jury into a verdict.

Did the convictions stand?

Yes. Utah’s constitution requires a unanimous verdict. Here the State clearly chose which act went with which count, and the jury was told twice that it had to agree on the specific act for each count. The court saw no reversible error.

Why didn’t the court decide the jury-note issue?

Because it was not “preserved,” meaning it was not raised in the trial court. When the judge told the lawyers what had happened, Hall’s lawyer did not object or ask for anything. Appeals courts usually will not decide such an issue unless the appellant argues a recognized exception.

Hall’s opening brief argued no exception. It even said one exception, plain error (an obvious mistake the judge should have caught), was unavailable. He tried to rely on another exception only in his reply brief, which was too late. The court stressed that it was not deciding whether any exception would have worked.

Did all the judges agree?

Yes. Judge Mortensen, joined by the other two judges, wrote separately. He noted that the State conceded the judge’s answer to the note “was unbalanced.” He urged trial judges to consult the lawyers before answering notes from a deliberating jury.

What happens now?

Hall’s two convictions stand.

What should people take from this?

On appeal, timing and form matter. An objection not made at trial, and an exception not argued in the first brief, can keep an appeals court from looking at a claimed error at all.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Tenney, J., joined by Mortensen and Luthy, JJ.; Mortensen, J., concurring, joined by Tenney and Luthy, JJ.). No unanimity error where the State elected a distinct act for each count and the jury was specifically instructed on unanimity (¶¶ 20–23). The Allen-charge challenge was unpreserved and no exception was timely invoked (¶¶ 27–30).

Issue 1: Jury unanimity (correctness, ¶ 15): affirmed (no error)

The jury instructions and the State’s election satisfied the Unanimous Verdict Clause, Utah Const. art. I, § 10. A unanimity problem can be cured by prosecutorial election, State v. Baugh, 2024 UT 33, ¶ 36, 556 P.3d 35, or by instructing the jury that it must be unanimous on the conduct supporting each count, State v. Chadwick, 2024 UT 34, ¶ 45, 554 P.3d 1098 (¶ 20). Both happened: the State tied Count 2 to the TV room and Count 3 to the bedroom, defense counsel called that “appropriate,” and closing argument tracked the split (¶ 21). Instructions 34 and 35 required unanimity on “which occasion and which act,” and Instructions 40 and 45 drew the same line (¶ 22). The State argued the claim was unpreserved, but the court reached it because the merits were “easily resolved in the State’s favor” (¶ 19 n.5, citing State v. Kitches, 2021 UT App 24, ¶ 28, 484 P.3d 415).

Issue 2: Allen charge (none stated, ¶¶ 24–29): not reached

The court declined to reach whether the supplemental instruction was coercive because the claim was unpreserved and no exception was properly invoked. The court answered the jury’s deadlock note without calling counsel, but when it disclosed its answer before the verdict was read, counsel did not object, request another instruction, or move for a mistrial, and said “None from the defense” (¶¶ 25, 27). Hall’s opening brief argued no ineffective assistance, exceptional circumstances or futility, and affirmatively said plain error review was unavailable (¶ 28). His exceptional-circumstances argument came first in the reply brief and was waived (¶ 28 n.6, citing State v. Johnson, 2017 UT 76, ¶ 16, 416 P.3d 443, and R4 Constructors LLC v. InBalance Yoga Corp., 2020 UT App 169, ¶ 29, 480 P.3d 1075). The court expressly did not decide whether any exception would have applied (n.7).

Separate opinion

Judge Mortensen, joined by Judges Tenney and Luthy, concurred fully but wrote to criticize answering the jury note without counsel (¶ 31). The State conceded the Allen charge “was unbalanced” and did not defend it (¶ 32). He quoted State v. Maestas, 2012 UT 46, ¶ 94, 299 P.3d 892, that judges “should inform counsel of each note they receive from the jury” (¶ 35), and noted that consulting counsel guards against retrial through doctrines like waiver and invited error (¶ 37).

Takeaways

  • A clear prosecutorial election tied to distinct locations, plus specific unanimity instructions, defeated the unanimity claim (¶¶ 21–22).
  • An appellant must assert a preservation exception in the opening brief; raising it in reply is waiver (¶¶ 28–29, n.6).
  • Learning of a jury-note response only after deliberations does not excuse the absence of an objection when counsel is asked for input before the verdict is taken (¶ 27).
  • The concurrence urges trial courts to put jury notes and proposed answers on the record with counsel (¶¶ 35, 38).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State v. Hall
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 121
Case no.
20250089-CA
Filed
2025
Decided
August 6, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Hall
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Two jury convictions for aggravated sexual abuse of a child, after acquittal on five other counts

The panel

Ryan D. TenneyAuthor
John D. LuthyConcurred
David N. MortensenConcurred
Trial court
Second District Court, Farmington Department · Judge Rita M. Cornish

Parties & counsel

Hall — AppellantIndividual(s)Edwin S. Wall
State — AppelleeState of UtahDerek E. BrownDavid A. SimpsonTerry M. Crist III

Practice Tip

If an Allen-charge or other claim was not objected to below, argue a preservation exception such as plain error or ineffective assistance in the opening brief; an exception first raised in the reply brief is waived (¶¶ 28–29 and n.6).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.