Can landowners added late to a new town’s map stop the vote? McCaffrey v. Anderson
Holding
The incorporation code’s scheme denying exclusion rights to specified landowners added to a proposed municipality’s boundaries after the first public hearing does not violate the Uniform Operation of Laws Clause under its modern formulation, because ending opt-outs to prevent endless boundary modifications is a reasonable basis for the classification.
Key takeaways
The Utah Supreme Court sided with Derek Anderson, the sponsor of the proposed town of West Hills, and reinstated the incorporation measure for the 2026 general election.
- Under the incorporation code version applied here, landowners added to a proposed town’s map after the first public hearing had no right to opt out, and the court held that this does not violate the Utah Constitution’s uniform operation clause under the test it applied.
- A time-based cutoff can be reasonable even if it seems arbitrary for people near the line.
- The court did not decide whether the law violates the original meaning of the uniform operation clause, leaving that question for another case.
Utah cases relied on
- State v. Outzen2017 UT 30
- State v. Angilau2011 UT 3
- Taylorsville City v. Mitchell2020 UT 26
- Tischmak v. Utah State Tax Comm'n2025 UT 24
- DIRECTV v. Utah State Tax Comm'n2015 UT 93
- Bingham v. Gourley2024 UT 38
- Spencer v. Utah State Bar2012 UT 92
- VCS, Inc. v. Utah Cmty. Bank2012 UT 89
- State v. Robinson2011 UT 30
- Merrill v. Utah Lab. Comm'n2009 UT 26
- Scott v. Scott2020 UT 54
- Kay v. Barnes Bullets2022 UT 3
Case details
- Case name
- McCaffrey v. Anderson
- Court
- Utah Supreme Court
- Citation
- 2026 UT 14
- Case no.
- 20251357
- Filed
- 2025
- Decided
- July 2, 2026
- Opinion type
- Authored
- Heard
- Argued
- Who appealed
- Anderson
- Disposition
- Reversed
The panel
Parties & counsel
Practice Tip
If you intend to rely on the original meaning of the Uniform Operation of Laws Clause, raise and develop it in the district court; the court declined to reach it as an alternative ground first raised on appeal, in an unsettled area, with less than full briefing (¶¶ 44–47).
Need appellate counsel?
Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.
About these Decision Summaries
Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.


