Utah Supreme Court · Published Opinion

Can landowners added late to a new town’s map stop the vote? McCaffrey v. Anderson

2026 UT 14No. 20251357Decided Jul 2, 2026Administrative & GovernmentReversed

Holding

The incorporation code’s scheme denying exclusion rights to specified landowners added to a proposed municipality’s boundaries after the first public hearing does not violate the Uniform Operation of Laws Clause under its modern formulation, because ending opt-outs to prevent endless boundary modifications is a reasonable basis for the classification.

Key takeaways

The Utah Supreme Court sided with Derek Anderson, the sponsor of the proposed town of West Hills, and reinstated the incorporation measure for the 2026 general election.

  • Under the incorporation code version applied here, landowners added to a proposed town’s map after the first public hearing had no right to opt out, and the court held that this does not violate the Utah Constitution’s uniform operation clause under the test it applied.
  • A time-based cutoff can be reasonable even if it seems arbitrary for people near the line.
  • The court did not decide whether the law violates the original meaning of the uniform operation clause, leaving that question for another case.

What happened?

Derek Anderson wanted to form a new town called West Hills in Summit County, between Hideout and Kamas. Under the incorporation code, the law for forming new towns, a sponsor like Anderson draws a proposed map, the Lieutenant Governor orders a feasibility study, and public hearings follow.

Certain larger landowners, called “specified landowners,” get two chances to opt out of the proposed town. The second chance comes after the first public hearing. After that, the map can be redrawn again, but landowners added at that stage get no chance to opt out.

About fifty specified landowners opted out after the first hearing. Anderson then redrew the map. The Lieutenant Governor certified the incorporation for the November 2025 ballot.

Who sued, and why?

A group of landowners (the appellees here) sued to stop the election. Some of their properties were added to the map after the opt-out deadline had passed. They argued the code violates the Utah Constitution’s Uniform Operation of Laws Clause, which says “All laws of a general nature shall have uniform operation,” because it lets some landowners opt out but not others in the same position.

The district court agreed and granted summary judgment, a ruling without a trial, for the landowners. Anderson appealed.

What did the Supreme Court decide?

It reversed. Both sides agreed no “fundamental right” or “suspect class” was involved, so the court used rational basis review. That is a low bar: a law stands if there is any reasonable basis for treating the groups differently.

The court found one. Opt-outs have to end at some point, or the early stages of forming a town could go on without end. Locking the boundaries after the first hearing moves the process toward an election and gives both sides time to prepare.

The court said a time-based line always looks somewhat arbitrary near the cutoff, but that does not make it unreasonable. It acknowledged a sponsor could try to game the map, though the district court found no evidence Anderson did. Other safeguards limit that risk, including population, density and contiguity rules, and the election itself, where voters make the final call.

Did the court decide everything the parties raised?

No. The landowners also argued that the law violates the original meaning of the clause, as first understood. The court declined to decide that. The argument was raised for the first time on appeal, the district court never ruled on it, the briefing focused on other points, and the law in this area is unsettled. The court said it would welcome that question “in an appropriate case.”

It also did not decide whether four appellees whose property lies outside the town’s boundaries had standing (the right to bring the claim), or Anderson’s other arguments about the type of challenge the landowners brought.

What happens now?

The Lieutenant Governor’s certification of the West Hills incorporation petition is reinstated for the 2026 general election, where voters will decide.

What should people take from this?

Under the test the court applied, the legislature may cut off opt-out rights at a set point in the incorporation process, even though some landowners end up without the choice their neighbors had.

Bottom line

Reversed (Nielsen, J., joined by Petersen, J., and Judges Christiansen Forster, Orme, Chiara, Fonnesbeck and Larsen). Chief Justice Durrant and Associate Chief Justice Pohlman recused; Judge Orme substituted for Justice Hagen; Justices Jorgensen and Dent joined the court after argument and did not participate. Applying the 2022 incorporation code, Utah Code §§ 10-2a-201 to -220 (¶ 2 n.1), the court held that denying exclusion rights to specified landowners added after the first public hearing does not violate Utah Const. art. I, § 24, and reinstated the Lieutenant Governor’s certification for the 2026 general election (¶¶ 9–10, 48).

Issue 2: Uniform operation, modern formulation (mixed, ¶ 23): reversed

The Court held that the grant of summary judgment to Landowners was error because the exclusion-rights scheme is reasonably related to legitimate legislative objectives and passes rational basis review.

Part 1: Rational basis review under the modern formulation (reached; reversed)

Under State v. Outzen, 2017 UT 30, ¶ 16, 408 P.3d 334, the first two steps (classification and disparate treatment of similarly situated landowners) were largely undisputed (¶¶ 25–26). No suspect class or fundamental right was at stake, so rational basis applied (¶ 28), and “any rational or reasonable basis” suffices, Tischmak v. Utah State Tax Comm’n, 2025 UT 24, ¶ 39, 574 P.3d 63 (cleaned up).

  • Reasonable classification: a time-based line is “inherently arbitrary on some level” but not unreasonable, as with the statute of repose in Bingham v. Gourley, 2024 UT 38, ¶¶ 54–55, 556 P.3d 53 and the age line in State v. Angilau, 2011 UT 3, ¶ 28, 245 P.3d 745 (¶ 31). Gamesmanship by sponsors is checked by population, density and contiguity requirements and by the election itself (¶ 33); the district court found “no evidence” Anderson manipulated boundaries (¶ 33 n.5).
  • Legitimate objectives: promoting incorporation, finality and protecting landowners are all legitimate, and the parties’ proposed purposes are not mutually exclusive (¶¶ 35–37).
  • Reasonable relationship: a cutoff locks in boundaries and moves the process to the election (¶ 39). The legislature need not pick “the best of all alternatives” (¶ 40, quoting Angilau, ¶ 32).

Part 2: Alternative argument that the court treated a facial challenge as an as-applied challenge (not reached)

Anderson also argued, against the same summary judgment ruling, that the district court erred in treating Landowners’ facial challenge as an as-applied constitutional challenge. Because the Court reversed and held the scheme does not violate the Uniform Operation Clause, it did not address this argument (¶ 24 n.4).

Not reached

  • Issue 1: Standing of four appellees whose property lies outside the proposed boundaries; the district court ruled without resolving it because at least one landowner had standing, and the court likewise did not reach it (¶ 19 n.2).
  • Issues 3 and 4: Anderson’s alternative arguments that the district court wrongly treated a facial challenge as as-applied, and that Landowners failed their as-applied burden, were unnecessary given the reversal (¶ 24 n.4).
  • Issue 5: Landowners’ alternative ground for affirmance under the original meaning of the clause. Affirmance on alternative grounds is discretionary, Scott v. Scott, 2020 UT 54, ¶ 31, 472 P.3d 897 (¶ 43). The argument was first raised in opposing expedited briefing, the district court never ruled on it, briefing focused on the modern test, and the law is unsettled, with Taylorsville City v. Mitchell, 2020 UT 26, 466 P.3d 148, resting on “only cursory analysis” of the history (¶¶ 44–47).

Takeaways

  • Time-based cutoffs in statutory processes will generally survive rational basis review even when similarly situated people fall on either side (¶¶ 31, 34).
  • Speculative gamesmanship does not defeat a classification where other statutory safeguards and an election check it (¶ 33).
  • An originalist uniform operation argument should be raised and ruled on below; the court declined to take it up for the first time on appeal with less than full briefing (¶¶ 44–46).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
McCaffrey v. Anderson
Court
Utah Supreme Court
Citation
2026 UT 14
Case no.
20251357
Filed
2025
Decided
July 2, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Heard
Argued
Who appealed
Anderson
Disposition
Reversed
At stake
Landowners' suit to enjoin the Lieutenant Governor from certifying the incorporation of West Hills for the ballot, on the ground that the incorporation code violates the Uniform Operation of Laws Clause

The panel

NielsenAuthor
Samuel P. ChiaraConcurred
Angela F. FonnesbeckConcurred
Michele M. Christiansen ForsterConcurred
Mandy L. LarsenConcurred
Gregory K. OrmeConcurred
Paige PetersenConcurred
CHIEF JUSTICE DURRANTDid not participate
ASSOCIATE CHIEF JUSTICE POHLMANDid not participate
JUSTICE HAGENDid not participate
JUSTICE JORGENSENDid not participate
JUSTICE DENTDid not participate
Trial court
Third District Court, Summit County · Judge Matthew D. Bates

Parties & counsel

Anderson — AppellantIndividual(s)Troy L. BooherCaroline A. OlsenTaylor P. Webb
McCaffrey — AppelleeOtherJanet M. ConwayC. Michael JuddDerek E. Brown, Utah Attorney General's OfficeSarah Goldberg, Utah Attorney General's OfficeKeith W. Barlow, Utah Attorney General's Office

Practice Tip

If you intend to rely on the original meaning of the Uniform Operation of Laws Clause, raise and develop it in the district court; the court declined to reach it as an alternative ground first raised on appeal, in an unsettled area, with less than full briefing (¶¶ 44–47).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.