Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Must a parole board delay my hearing if records are missing? Peterson v. Utah Board of Pardons

931 P.2d 147No. 960247-CADecided Jan 16, 1997Administrative & GovernmentReversed

Holding

Due process under article I, section 7 of the Utah Constitution did not require the Board of Pardons to insist on continuing a parole rehearing when the inmate noted that his therapist’s records were missing but declined more time and never requested a continuance, because the inmate bears the burden of requesting more time.

Practice areaCivil AppealsTopicsDue Process

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the Utah Board of Pardons, which appealed, and reversed the order giving Peterson another hearing.

  • At a parole hearing, the inmate has the burden of asking for more time when the file is missing information the Board should consider.
  • The Board did not violate due process here, because Peterson had a chance to review his file, point out errors and ask for a continuance, and he said he did not need more time.
  • One judge dissented. He would have upheld the order giving Peterson a new hearing.

What happened?

Stacy Ray Peterson pleaded guilty in 1989 to second degree murder. He was sentenced to five years to life, plus a five-year firearm enhancement. After his first parole hearing, he got a date for a rehearing rather than a parole date.

At the rehearing in May 1994, Peterson was handed some new documents. The hearing officer asked whether he wanted more time to review them. Peterson said he did not.

Later in the hearing, Peterson said his file had nothing from Tom Felton, a therapist he said he had been seeing for two years. He said the file wrongly suggested he had not seen Felton. The hearing officer thanked him and moved on. Peterson did not ask for more time to get the records. At the end, when invited to make any other comments, he did not mention Felton.

The Board scheduled his next rehearing for April 2008. Peterson’s lawyer later got an affidavit from Felton. The Board reviewed it at a special attention hearing, which Peterson was not invited to attend, and did not change its decision.

What did each side ask for?

Peterson filed a petition for extraordinary relief, a request for a court to correct an official body’s action. He argued that due process (the constitutional right to fair procedures) required the Board to give him more time to get the Felton records. He also asked for a plenary hearing, meaning a full new hearing on everything.

The trial court agreed in part. It ruled that the Board should have given Peterson more time, and it ordered a new hearing where he could address the Felton information in person. It said it did not have power to order a full new hearing. The Board appealed, and Peterson cross-appealed (filed his own appeal) on the full hearing.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It reversed. Under the Utah Constitution, an inmate at a parole hearing must get adequate notice and must get copies or a summary of the information the Board will rely on. Peterson did not dispute that he got both.

The court found that he also had a fair chance to point out errors. He did point out the missing Felton information, and he could have asked for a continuance (a delay of the hearing) to bring documents or affidavits. He did not.

The court said the Board is a neutral body. Making it insist on a delay that the inmate did not ask for would put it in the role of the inmate’s advocate, and the Board would be left guessing what inmates want.

What about Peterson’s request for a full new hearing?

The court did not decide it. That request depended on a due process violation, and the court found none.

Did all the judges agree?

No. Presiding Judge Davis dissented. He agreed that the Board has no constitutional duty to continue a hearing. But he believed Peterson never waived (gave up) his right to have the Felton records considered, because the hearing officer never asked whether he wanted to go ahead without them. He would have upheld the trial court’s order in full, including its refusal to order a full new hearing.

What happens now?

The order giving Peterson a new hearing is reversed, so the Board’s decision stands.

Bottom line

Reversed (Wilkins, Associate P.J., joined by Bench, J.; Davis, P.J., dissenting). The trial court partially granted Peterson’s petition for extraordinary relief and ordered a new hearing, ruling the Board “should have provided additional time” for him to get his therapist’s records. The Court of Appeals held that the Board met both due process requirements set by Labrum v. Utah State Bd. of Pardons, 870 P.2d 902 (Utah 1993), and that the inmate, not the Board, bears the burden of requesting more time. The opinion has no paragraph numbers.

Issue 1: Duty to continue the parole rehearing (correctness): reversed

The Board was not constitutionally obligated to insist on continuing the rehearing until Peterson could retrieve the missing Felton counseling records. Due process under article I, section 7 applies to parole grant hearings, including one that sets only another hearing date, and requires (1) adequate notice and (2) copies or a summary of the information the Board will rely on, citing Labrum v. Utah State Bd. of Pardons, 870 P.2d 902, 909 (Utah 1993), and Neel v. Holden, 886 P.2d 1097, 1101 (Utah 1994). Peterson conceded both. The court treated his claim as an argument that the second requirement’s functions, accuracy and legitimacy, were not served. It held they were: he reviewed his file before the hearing, declined the hearing officer’s offer to reschedule over the new documents, pointed out the Felton inaccuracy, could have sought a continuance under Utah Admin. Code R671-303-1, and did not raise Felton when invited to make final comments. The procedure “adequately safeguard[ed] against serious risks of error,” quoting Greenholtz v. Inmates of Nebraska Penal & Correctional Complex, 442 U.S. 1, 15, 99 S.Ct. 2100, 2108 (1979). Shifting the burden to the Board would compromise its neutrality (citing R671-309-1) and produce inconsistent results, since the Board would have to interpret inmates’ wishes rather than act on clear requests. In a footnote, the court said its decision rests on due process, not administrative burden.

Not reached

Peterson’s cross-appeal of the denial of a plenary hearing. The court did not need to decide it because it rested on the premise that his due process rights were violated.

Separate opinion

Presiding Judge Davis dissented. He agreed the Board has no constitutional duty to continue a hearing, but he framed the question as waiver, relying on State v. Rawlings, 893 P.2d 1063 (Utah App.1995). In his view, Peterson’s remarks about Felton were at best ambiguous and not a knowing and intelligent waiver, and the hearing officer could have asked whether he wished to proceed. He said the special attention review held without Peterson did not cure the violation. He would have affirmed in full, including the denial of a plenary hearing, because Peterson did not show why a hearing on the Felton evidence alone would not remedy the violation.

Takeaways

  • An inmate who discovers missing or inaccurate information at a parole hearing should ask for a continuance on the record; the majority puts the burden of requesting more time on the inmate.
  • Declining an offer of more time, and staying silent when invited to make final comments, weighed against the due process claim.
  • The majority grounded its burden allocation in the Board’s neutrality and in the accuracy and legitimacy functions described in Labrum v. Utah State Bd. of Pardons, 870 P.2d 902, 909-10 (Utah 1993).
Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Peterson v. Utah Board of Pardons
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
931 P.2d 147
Case no.
960247-CA
Filed
1996
Decided
January 16, 1997
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Utah Board of Pardons · cross-appeal by Peterson
Disposition
Reversed
At stake
Whether an inmate whose parole rehearing was set for April 2008 was entitled to a new hearing to present missing counseling records in person

The panel

Michael J. WilkinsAuthor
James Z. DavisDissented
Russell W. BenchConcurred

Parties & counsel

Utah Board of Pardons — Appellant / Cross-appelleeGovernment agencyJan GrahamBrent A. Burnett
Peterson — Appellee / Cross-appellantIndividual(s)David L. ArringtonEric E. Vernon

Practice Tip

If an inmate's parole file is missing information the Board should consider, request a continuance on the record. The majority placed the burden of asking for more time on the inmate, not the Board (Peterson v. Utah Board of Pardons, 931 P.2d 147 (Utah Ct. App. 1997); the opinion has no paragraph numbers).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.