Utah Supreme Court · Published Opinion

Am I protected if my seller had no recorded title? Salt Lake County v. Metro West Ready Mix, Inc.

2004 UT 23No. 20020701Decided Mar 23, 2004Real Property & Land UseReversed & Remanded

Holding

A purchaser whose chain of title is founded on a wild deed is charged with notice that the grantor lacks record title and therefore cannot be a good faith, bona fide purchaser under Utah Code section 57-3-103, though the purchaser may still prevail if the grantor held valid title independent of the recording statutes.

Key takeaways

The Utah Supreme Court sided with Salt Lake County, reversing the ruling for Metro West and sending the case back for more proceedings.

  • A buyer who takes land from someone with no recorded title is treated as being on notice of that problem, so Utah’s Recording Statute does not protect the buyer against an earlier unrecorded owner.
  • Such a buyer can still win if the seller actually had valid title some other way, such as adverse possession.
  • Metro West’s adverse possession claim could not be decided on summary judgment because the facts about continuous use and tax payments were disputed.

What happened?

In 1878, William Turner conveyed a fifteen-acre parcel to Salt Lake County (the County) by warranty deed. The land sits in Utah County, but the County recorded its deed only in Salt Lake County. It did not record the deed in Utah County until 1998.

In 1989, Darhl and Roena Tingey said their family had used the land since the turn of the century. They sold it to Lamona Farms by quitclaim deed for $25,000. A search of the Utah County records showed nothing conflicting with the Tingeys’ claim, but the records also never listed the Tingeys as owners. The land later passed to Metro West Ready Mix, Inc. (Metro West), which the opinion treats as including its predecessors.

How did the case get to the Utah Supreme Court?

In 1999, the County sued to “quiet title,” which means asking a court to declare who owns the land. The trial court granted summary judgment, a ruling without a trial, for Metro West. It found Metro West was a “bona fide purchaser,” meaning a buyer who paid value in good faith and recorded first.

The Court of Appeals agreed, using a new “apparent title rule.” The County then asked the Supreme Court to review that decision.

What did the court decide about the recording statute?

It reversed. Utah’s Recording Statute protects a later buyer against an earlier unrecorded deed only if the buyer bought in good faith. Good faith means buying without notice of any problem in the seller’s title.

The Tingeys’ deed was a “wild deed,” a deed from someone with no recorded title. A buyer is charged with knowing what the county records show, and also what they should show but do not. So anyone taking a wild deed is on notice that the seller has no record title. That buyer cannot be a good faith buyer under the statute.

This does not mean a wild deed buyer can never own the land. If the Tingeys actually held valid title by some other route, such as adverse possession, Metro West could still win. The record was not enough to decide that.

What about Metro West’s adverse possession claim?

Adverse possession lets someone gain title by occupying and claiming land continuously for seven years while meeting other requirements, such as paying the taxes. Metro West argued it owned the land this way, as another reason to uphold the ruling.

The court disagreed that this could be decided without a trial. Witnesses could not say when or how often the land was used between 1990 and 1995. The tax receipts gave descriptions and acreage that changed from year to year, so the court could not tell whether the taxes were for this parcel.

What happens now?

The case returns to the trial court. Metro West may still try to show that the Tingeys had valid title or that Metro West gained title by adverse possession. The court did not decide the County’s argument that the land was set aside for public use, which would bar adverse possession.

What should people take from this?

Recording a deed first does not protect a buyer whose seller has no title on record. The ownership fight then turns on whether the seller had real title by some other means.

Bottom line

Reversed and remanded (Durrant, A.C.J., joined by Durham, C.J., and Wilkins, Parrish and Nehring, JJ.). The court rejected the “apparent title rule” adopted in Salt Lake County v. Metro West Ready Mix, Inc., 2002 UT App 257, 53 P.3d 499, and held that “a purchaser whose chain of title is founded on a wild deed cannot be a bona fide purchaser under Utah’s Recording Statute” (¶ 17). Metro West can still prevail if the Tingeys held valid title by other means, or by its own adverse possession, but neither can be decided on summary judgment (¶¶ 19, 27–28).

Issue 1: Wild deed and bona fide purchaser status (correctness, ¶¶ 12–19): reversed

A grantee of a wild deed is on notice of a defect in the grantor’s title and cannot be a good faith purchaser under Utah Code section 57-3-103 (¶ 17). Good faith requires taking without notice of a prior unrecorded interest and “without notice of any infirmity in his grantor’s title,” quoting Pender v. Bird, 119 Utah 91, 96, 224 P.2d 1057, 1059 (1950) (¶ 13). Because a purchaser is charged with what the county records show, citing Crompton v. Jenson, 78 Utah 55, 70, 1 P.2d 242, 247 (1931), the court held that by implication the purchaser is charged with what the records should show but do not (¶ 17). The court agreed with the County that Metro West had notice, but rested on actual and constructive record notice rather than the County’s inquiry notice theory (¶¶ 14–15). It followed the majority of courts on the point (¶ 16). The holding is limited: recording does not pass title, and a wild deed is effective if the grantor held valid title independent of the recording statutes, such as by adverse possession (¶¶ 18–19). Because the record was insufficient on that question, the court remanded (¶ 19).

Issue 2: Adverse possession as an alternative ground to affirm (correctness, ¶¶ 20–27): reversed

Metro West’s own adverse possession claim cannot support summary judgment because material facts are disputed. An appellate court may affirm on any proper ground only if the record supports it, citing DeBry v. Noble, 889 P.2d 428, 444 (Utah 1995) (¶ 21). The claimant must affirmatively show every statutory element (¶ 23). Continuous use over seven years was disputed: witnesses could not say when roads were built on the parcel or when exploration occurred between 1990 and 1995 (¶¶ 24–25). Tax payments were disputed: the receipts’ descriptions and acreage changed from year to year (¶ 26). In a footnote, the court found the County’s failure to follow rule 4-501(2)(B)’s format for disputed facts harmless, because the facts were set out with record cites in the body of its memorandum (¶ 23 n.4).

Not reached

Having found disputes on continuous use and taxes, the court did not need to address the remaining elements under section 78-12-9 or the County’s argument that section 78-12-13’s “designated for public use” exception bars adverse possession (¶ 27).

Takeaways

  • Recording first does not protect a purchaser who takes from a stranger to the record title; the absence of record title is itself notice (¶ 17).
  • A wild deed purchaser can still prevail by proving the grantor held valid title independent of the recording statutes (¶¶ 18–19).
  • Tax receipts with varying property descriptions and acreage may fail to establish the tax element of adverse possession on summary judgment (¶ 26).
  • Noncompliance with rule 4-501(2)(B)’s format was harmless where disputed facts appeared in the memorandum’s body with record cites (¶ 23 n.4).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Salt Lake County v. Metro West Ready Mix, Inc.
Court
Utah Supreme Court
Citation
2004 UT 23
Case no.
20020701
Filed
2002
Decided
March 23, 2004
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Salt Lake County
Disposition
Reversed and Remanded
At stake
Ownership of Parcel G, a fifteen-acre property in Utah County, claimed by Salt Lake County under an 1878 deed and by Metro West under a 1989 quitclaim deed.

The panel

Matthew B. DurrantAuthor
Christine M. DurhamConcurred
Ronald E. NehringConcurred
Jill N. ParrishConcurred
Michael J. WilkinsConcurred

Parties & counsel

Salt Lake County — AppellantGovernment agency
Metro West Ready Mix, Inc. — AppelleeBusiness

Practice Tip

When a client's chain of title runs through a grantor with no record title, do not rely on the recording statute; be ready to prove that the grantor held title some other way, such as adverse possession, with specific evidence of continuous use and tax payments tied to the parcel (¶¶ 17–19, 24–26).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.