Utah Supreme Court · Published Opinion

Can I enforce a buy-back option if the price can’t be figured out? Carter v. Sorensen

2004 UT 33No. 20020688Decided Apr 20, 2004Contracts & Business DisputesAffirmed

Holding

An option to repurchase all or part of a property for the same price the buyer paid for the whole is unenforceable as to a partial purchase when nothing allows the price of that part to be ascertained, because a contract without a definite price term cannot be enforced (Carter v. Sorensen, 2004 UT 33, ¶¶ 7–11, citing Nielsen v. Gold’s Gym, 2003 UT 37, ¶ 11, 78 P.3d 600).

Key takeaways

The Utah Supreme Court sided with Sorensen, the buyer, and upheld the dismissal of Carter’s lawsuit, though for a different reason than the trial court gave.

  • An option to buy, like any contract, needs a definite price term before a court will enforce it.
  • Here, “the same price” paid for a whole property gave no way to work out the price of only part of it, such as the water shares.
  • The court upheld the dismissal on that ground, even though the trial court had relied on a different reason.

What happened?

Keith Carter was a farmer and rancher. The Farmers Home Administration (FHA) foreclosed on his property, which included water rights. D. Stephen Sorensen, a possible buyer, agreed that if he bought the property he would give Carter an option, meaning a right to buy, to repurchase all or part of it for the same price Sorensen paid.

Sorensen bought the property in March 1996 for $355,000, a price based on an FHA appraisal. Before the option ran out on May 31, 1999, Carter bought part of the property back at a price the two agreed on. That part included some, but not all, of the water shares.

Why did they end up in court?

Carter wanted the remaining twenty-six water shares. He asked Eric Johnson, who had prepared the FHA appraisal, to work out what each share had cost. Johnson estimated $800 per share. Sorensen refused that price and said he had paid $47,000 for the shares.

Ten days before the option expired, Carter put $20,800 into an escrow account, a neutral account holding money for a deal. Sorensen still refused to transfer the shares, and Carter sued. During the case, Johnson testified that his $800 figure contained a math error and the right figure would have been $1,800 per share.

The trial court refused to enforce the option. It ruled that Carter missed the deadline because he did not offer Sorensen’s $47,000 price in time, and it noted that it could not determine the price for the water shares.

What did the Utah Supreme Court decide?

It upheld the dismissal, but for a different reason. A contract, including an option, must have definite terms, including the price, or a court cannot enforce it.

The court said the parties clearly meant to create an option. But “the same price” Sorensen paid worked only for the whole property. The appraisal gave three different values under three methods, and the final $355,000 figure came with no breakdown by part and no explanation of how it was reached. So all that was known was that Sorensen paid $355,000 for everything. There was no way to tell what he paid for the water shares or any other part.

Because the price of a partial purchase could not be worked out, the option was unenforceable for that purchase.

What about Carter’s other arguments?

Carter also argued that he did exercise the option in time and that the trial court was wrong that it could not set a price. Because the court decided the case on the missing price term, it said it did not need to address his other points.

What should people take from this?

A promise to sell “at the same price” may not be enforceable for only part of a property if nothing shows how the total price breaks down. Parties who want an option to buy back part of a property should state how the price for each part will be set.

Did all the justices agree?

Yes. All five justices joined Justice Wilkins’s opinion.

Bottom line

Affirmed on other grounds (Wilkins, J., joined by Durham, C.J., Durrant, A.C.J., and Parrish and Nehring, JJ.). The trial court refused to enforce the option because Carter did not tender Sorensen’s claimed $47,000 price before the option expired (¶ 5). The Supreme Court held instead that there was no enforceable option for a partial purchase, because the agreement had no ascertainable price term for less than the entire property (¶¶ 7–8, 11–12).

Issue 1: Enforceability of the option (correctness, ¶ 6): affirmed on other grounds

The purported option to buy back any portion of the property was unenforceable because it contained no ascertainable price term for a partial purchase. The existence of a contract is a question of law reviewed without deference (¶ 6). An option must have definite terms, including the price, or a court cannot enforce it, following Nielsen v. Gold’s Gym, 2003 UT 37, ¶ 11, 78 P.3d 600 (¶ 7). The parties “clearly intended” an option, but “the same price [Sorensen paid] to the FHA” was elusive for anything less than the whole (¶ 8).

The FHA appraisal did not fill the gap. It valued the property at $369,300 (cost), $319,000 (income) and $358,000 (sales comparison), adopted none of those approaches, and reached $355,000 with no itemized values or explanation of methodology (¶¶ 9–10). The itemized values within each approach were therefore “of no utility” in valuing the water shares or any other fraction (¶ 10). What remained was only that Sorensen paid $355,000 for the entire property, and there was no mechanism to find the price of any part (¶ 11). The court agreed with the trial court that the water-share price was not ascertainable, and the legal consequence of a missing price term is unenforceability (¶ 11, citing Nielsen v. Gold’s Gym, 2003 UT 37, 78 P.3d 600, ¶¶ 11–12). Although the trial court’s ruling rested on Carter’s failure to exercise the option, the court affirmed on the missing price term (¶ 11, see, e.g., State v. Topanotes, 2003 UT 30, ¶ 9, 76 P.3d 1159).

Not reached

Given this disposition, the court said it need not address Carter’s other points, including his challenges to the ruling that he failed to exercise the option and to the finding that the price could not be determined (¶ 1).

Takeaways

  • An option to purchase “all or part” of a property at the price paid for the whole needs a way to allocate that price among parts; without one, a partial-purchase option has no ascertainable price and is unenforceable (¶¶ 8, 11).
  • An appraisal that gives competing values under different methods and a final figure without itemization or methodology cannot supply the missing price for a portion (¶¶ 9–10).
  • The court will affirm on the alternative ground of contract unenforceability even when the trial court ruled on the timeliness of exercise (¶ 11).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Carter v. Sorensen
Court
Utah Supreme Court
Citation
2004 UT 33
Case no.
20020688
Filed
2002
Decided
April 20, 2004
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Carter
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Carter's attempt to enforce an option to buy back twenty-six water shares from Sorensen, which Sorensen said cost $47,000 and Carter offered $20,800 for

The panel

Michael J. WilkinsAuthor
Christine M. DurhamConcurred
Matthew B. DurrantConcurred
Ronald E. NehringConcurred
Jill N. ParrishConcurred

Parties & counsel

Carter — AppellantIndividual(s)
Sorensen — AppelleeIndividual(s)

Practice Tip

When drafting an option covering "all or part" of a property, include a way to set the price of each part; a lump-sum purchase price, or an appraisal without itemized final values, may leave a partial-purchase option without an ascertainable price term (¶¶ 8–11).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.