Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can a child claim workers’ comp death benefits after the deadline? Bonneville Asphalt v. Labor Comm'n

2004 UT App 137No. 20030463-CADecided Apr 29, 2004Employment & Workers' CompensationAffirmed

Holding

The general tolling statute, Utah Code Ann. § 78-12-36 (1996), applies to death benefits claims under the Workers’ Compensation Act, and its “without a legal guardian” clause applies only to mentally incompetent individuals, so a minor dependent’s late-filed claim was tolled.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the deceased worker’s son and upheld the order requiring the employer and its insurer to pay death benefits.

  • Utah’s general tolling statute, which pauses filing deadlines while a person is a minor, applies to workers’ compensation death benefits claims under the law in effect in this case.
  • The words “without a legal guardian” in that statute apply only to mentally incompetent people, so a minor’s claim is paused whether or not the minor has a guardian.
  • The order requiring the employer and its insurer to pay death benefits to the son stands.

What happened?

Cody Mair was killed on September 28, 1998, while working for Bonneville Asphalt. He left one dependent, his two-year-old son, Dakota Cameron. Dakota’s mother, who was never married to Mair, filed a claim for death benefits for Dakota under the Workers’ Compensation Act nearly three years after the death.

Bonneville Asphalt and its insurer, Liberty Mutual Insurance Company, argued the claim was barred. The Act says a death benefits claim must be filed within one year of the employee’s death.

What did the Labor Commission decide?

An administrative law judge (a hearing officer for the agency) ruled the claim was not too late. Utah’s general tolling statute “tolls,” or pauses, a filing deadline while the person entitled to sue is a minor. The judge ordered the employer and insurer to pay death benefits. The Labor Commission denied their request for review, and they asked the Court of Appeals to review that order.

What did the employer and insurer argue?

They made two arguments. First, they said the Act’s own rule, that a guardian or “next friend” must file for a minor within one year, was a specific exception to the tolling statute. Second, they said the tolling statute pauses the deadline for a minor only if the minor has no legal guardian.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It rejected both arguments. On the first, the court explained that the tolling statute protects minors’ claims unless the Legislature writes a specific exemption. The Act has no such language. When the Legislature wants to exempt a deadline, it says so plainly, as it did for malpractice claims against health care providers. Reading the Act this way also fits the rule that the Act is read broadly in favor of coverage.

The court also answered the worry that employers could face old claims years later. A party that wants such a claim resolved can ask a court to appoint a legal guardian for the minor and then bring a declaratory judgment action (a lawsuit asking the court to declare the parties’ rights).

On the second argument, the court followed its own earlier decision in Sulzen v. Williams, 1999 UT App 76, 977 P.2d 497, which read “without a legal guardian” to apply only to mentally incompetent people. The Utah Supreme Court had read the phrase differently in Jensen v. IHC Hosps., Inc., 944 P.2d 327 (Utah 1997), but the Court of Appeals called that reading dicta, meaning a remark not needed for that decision. It said it was bound to follow its own prior decisions.

What happens now?

The Labor Commission’s order stands. Bonneville Asphalt and Liberty Mutual must pay death benefits to Dakota. Because Dakota is a minor, the deadline was paused whether or not his mother counted as his legal guardian.

What should people take from this?

Under the statutes in this case, a one-year deadline in the Workers’ Compensation Act did not cut off a minor dependent’s death benefits claim. An employer or insurer that wants such a claim settled sooner has a route the court described: seek appointment of a guardian and a declaration of the minor’s rights.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Davis, J., joined by Bench, A.P.J., and Orme, J.). The general tolling statute, Utah Code Ann. § 78-12-36 (1996), tolled a minor dependent’s death benefits claim despite the Act’s one-year limitation in Utah Code Ann. § 34A-2-417(3) (1997), and the “without a legal guardian” clause reaches only mentally incompetent persons (¶¶ 11, 17–18).

Issue 1: Tolling statute and the Act (correctness, ¶ 4): affirmed (no error)

The court held that the tolling statute applies to Dakota’s death benefits claim and that its “without a legal guardian” clause applies only to mentally incompetent persons, so the Labor Commission’s order to pay death benefits was affirmed (¶¶ 11, 17-18).

Part 1: Whether the tolling statute applies to death benefits claims under the Act (yes, ¶¶ 5-11)

The tolling statute applies to claims for death benefits under the Act (¶ 11). Under Blum v. Stone, 752 P.2d 898, 900 (Utah 1988), all limitation periods are tolled during minority “unless the legislature enacts a specific exemption” (¶ 5). The Act’s one-year bar and its requirement that a guardian or next friend give notice for minor dependents, §§ 34A-2-414(3)(b), -417(3), are not that exemption (¶ 6). Following Cole v. Jordan Sch. Dist., 899 P.2d 776, 778 (Utah 1995), which held the Governmental Immunity Act’s notice and extension provisions did not displace the tolling statute, the court contrasted § 78-14-4(2), which expressly applies “regardless of minority” (¶¶ 7-8). The result fits the liberal construction of the Act, Vigos v. Mountainland Builders, Inc., 2000 UT 2, ¶ 24, 993 P.2d 207 (¶ 9). Answering the concern about dormant claims, the court noted a party may seek a guardian’s appointment and a declaratory judgment under § 78-33-4 (¶ 10).

Part 2: Whether “without a legal guardian” applies only to mentally incompetent persons (yes, ¶¶ 12-17)

The clause applies only to mentally incompetent individuals, so Dakota’s claim was tolled regardless of whether his mother was his legal guardian (¶ 17). Petitioners relied on Jensen v. IHC Hosps., Inc., 944 P.2d 327, 335 (Utah 1997), which read the clause to cover minors too; the court treated that reading as dicta and the issues as distinct (¶¶ 13, 16 & n.3). It followed Sulzen v. Williams, 1999 UT App 76, ¶ 22, 977 P.2d 497, which found the statute ambiguous and, on legislative history and policy, limited the clause to the incompetent (¶¶ 14-16). Horizontal stare decisis requires each panel to follow the court’s prior decisions, citing State v. Menzies, 889 P.2d 393, 399 n.3 (Utah 1994), and see State v. Thurman, 846 P.2d 1256, 1269 (Utah 1993) (¶ 16). The court framed its holding “in the context of filing a claim for death benefits under the Act” (¶ 17).

Takeaways

  • A limitation period with a guardian-or-next-friend filing provision is not, without more, a specific exemption from minority tolling (¶¶ 6–8).
  • The Legislature’s express “regardless of minority” language in § 78-14-4(2) is the kind of exemption the court looked for (¶ 8).
  • Employers or insurers facing a potential minor’s claim may petition for a guardian and seek a declaratory judgment under § 78-33-4 (¶ 10).
  • The Court of Appeals followed its own precedent in Sulzen v. Williams, 1999 UT App 76, 977 P.2d 497, over Supreme Court dicta in Jensen v. IHC Hosps., Inc., 944 P.2d 327 (Utah 1997) (¶ 16).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Bonneville Asphalt v. Labor Comm'n
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2004 UT App 137
Case no.
20030463-CA
Filed
2003
Decided
April 29, 2004
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Labor Comm'n
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Workers' compensation death benefits for the sole dependent, a minor son, of an employee killed on the job, claimed nearly three years after the death.

The panel

James Z. DavisAuthor
Russell W. BenchConcurred
Gregory K. OrmeConcurred
Trial court
Labor Commission

Parties & counsel

Labor Comm'n — AppellantBusiness
Bonneville Asphalt — AppelleeOther

Practice Tip

For an employer or insurer facing a possible minor dependent's death benefits claim, the court pointed to seeking appointment of a guardian and a declaratory judgment under Utah Code Ann. § 78-33-4 as a way to get the claim resolved promptly (¶ 10).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.