Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can police take my blood after a crash without a warrant? State v. Rodriguez

2004 UT App 198No. 20030006-CADecided Jun 10, 2004Criminal AppealsReversed & Remanded

Holding

A warrantless blood draw is justified by exigent circumstances only when the totality of the circumstances shows the officer reasonably believed the delay to obtain a warrant threatened destruction of evidence; the evanescence of blood alcohol alone is insufficient, and a routine draw “as we do in accidents” did not meet the State’s burden.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with Rodriguez, the driver, reversing her conviction and ordering the blood-test evidence suppressed.

  • The fact that alcohol leaves the blood over time does not, on its own, excuse police from getting a warrant before drawing blood.
  • The State must show an actual emergency based on all the circumstances, such as how long a warrant would take.
  • A blood draw done “as we do in accidents,” as a routine, did not meet that test here.

What happened?

On May 9, 2001, Heather Jo Rodriguez turned left into oncoming traffic in Salt Lake City, in front of a school bus. The bus hit the passenger side of her car. Her passenger, Terry Stewart, was badly hurt and later died.

At the scene, someone who appeared to be a paramedic told officers the car’s occupants smelled of alcohol, and officers found a partly empty vodka bottle in Stewart’s purse. The supervising officer asked dispatch to send an officer to get a blood sample from Rodriguez.

An officer found her at LDS Hospital, noticed signs of drinking, and waited 20 to 25 minutes for a blood technician. He told her they “were going to draw blood from her just as we do in accidents.” No one got a warrant. The test showed a blood-alcohol level of .39.

How did the case reach the Court of Appeals?

Rodriguez was charged with automobile homicide. She asked the trial court to suppress, meaning throw out, the blood evidence. The court first granted that request, then reversed itself after the State asked it to reconsider.

Rodriguez then pleaded guilty but kept her right to appeal the suppression ruling.

What did each side argue?

Rodriguez argued the State had not shown the police had an emergency that excused getting a warrant. The State argued that because alcohol in the blood fades over time, a crash investigation involving alcohol always counts as an emergency.

What did the court decide?

The court sided with Rodriguez. It read the leading U.S. Supreme Court case, Schmerber v. California, 384 U.S. 757, 86 S.Ct. 1826, 16 L.Ed.2d 908 (1966), as requiring a look at all the circumstances, not an automatic rule.

The fading of alcohol matters, but by itself it is not enough. Courts should also consider things like how close a judge was, whether a warrant could be obtained by phone, and how long getting one would take.

Here, the decision to draw blood was made within about 25 minutes of the crash, on a weekday afternoon when courts were open. Neither officer tried to get a warrant or asked whether a judge was available, and no one estimated how long a warrant would take. The officer’s words “as we do in accidents” suggested the draw was routine. The court said “exigency is the opposite of routine.”

What happens now?

Rodriguez’s conviction is reversed. The case goes back to the trial court with instructions to suppress all evidence from the blood draw.

The State does not get a second chance to offer more evidence of an emergency. Under State v. Topanotes, 2003 UT 30, ¶ 11, 76 P.3d 1159, when the State carries the burden and the record does not support it, it is not entitled to a new hearing.

The court did not decide whether the police had enough reason to suspect drunk driving, because the emergency question settled the case.

What should people take from this?

When police draw blood without a warrant and rely on an emergency, the State must prove a real emergency in that situation. A department’s routine practice is not enough.

Bottom line

Reversed and remanded with instructions to grant the motion to suppress (Thorne, J., joined by Davis and Jackson, JJ.). Exigent circumstances for a warrantless blood draw exist only when the totality of the circumstances shows the officer faced an emergency in which the delay to obtain a warrant threatened destruction of evidence; the evanescence of blood alcohol, “although important to the equation, is insufficient” by itself (¶ 14).

Issue 1: Exigent circumstances for the warrantless blood draw (mixed, ¶ 7): reversed

The State failed to carry its burden of proving exigency, so the blood evidence must be suppressed (¶¶ 20–21). Findings get deference and the ultimate legal conclusion is reviewed for correctness (¶ 7).

Rule. The court declined the State’s proposed per se rule, which several other jurisdictions had drawn from Schmerber v. California, 384 U.S. 757, 86 S.Ct. 1826, 16 L.Ed.2d 908 (1966) (¶ 10). It read Schmerber as resting on the time lost to the hospital trip and scene investigation, and on magistrate availability, and as expressly limited to its facts (¶¶ 12–13). Later Supreme Court references suggesting evanescence alone may suffice were treated as dicta (¶ 13 n.2). The court applied the totality test of City of Orem v. Henrie, 868 P.2d 1384, 1388 (Utah Ct.App.1994), including its factors: distance to a magistrate, telephonic warrants, seriousness of the offense, the investigation’s course, and officer conduct (¶¶ 14–16; ¶ 15 n.3).

Findings. The trial court rested on dissipation, the seriousness of the accident and probable cause, but left open timing, proximity of a magistrate, alternatives considered, estimated warrant delay, and when the decision was made; that omission was “fatal,” and the appellate court cannot supplement findings, citing Bailey v. Bayles, 2002 UT 58, ¶¶ 19-20, 52 P.3d 1158 (¶¶ 15, 17).

Application. The draw was ordered within about 25 minutes of a weekday afternoon accident, when warrants could be requested in person or by phone (¶¶ 18–19, citing State v. Northrup, 756 P.2d 1288, 1292 (Utah Ct.App.1988)). No officer sought a warrant or assessed the delay, and the draw was done “as we do in accidents” (¶¶ 19–20). “[E]xigency is the opposite of routine” (¶ 20).

Remand. Because the State had the burden and the record supports no theory of admissibility, it gets no remand to present new evidence or for further findings, under State v. Topanotes, 2003 UT 30, ¶ 11, 76 P.3d 1159 (¶ 22 n.4).

Not reached

Whether the officers had probable cause; the exigency question was dispositive (¶ 9).

Takeaways

  • Evanescence of blood alcohol does not make every alcohol-related blood draw an emergency; the State must show a reasonable belief in an emergency under the particular circumstances (¶¶ 14, 21).
  • Record evidence on warrant availability and expected delay is central; absent it, the State’s exigency claim failed (¶¶ 19–20).
  • Trial court findings must address the Henrie factors; the appellate court will not fill gaps (¶¶ 15, 17).
  • When the State fails its burden on suppression, it may not get a remand to try again (¶ 22 n.4).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State v. Rodriguez
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2004 UT App 198
Case no.
20030006-CA
Filed
2003
Decided
June 10, 2004
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Rodriguez
Disposition
Reversed and Remanded
At stake
A conviction entered on a conditional guilty plea to automobile homicide, resting on a warrantless blood draw showing a .39 blood-alcohol level

The panel

William A. Thorne Jr.Author
James Z. DavisConcurred
Norman H. JacksonConcurred

Parties & counsel

Rodriguez — AppellantIndividual(s)
State — AppelleeState of Utah

Practice Tip

In challenging a warrantless blood draw, press the State for evidence of magistrate availability, telephonic warrants and the expected delay; in State v. Rodriguez, 2004 UT App 198, the absence of any such evidence defeated exigency and barred a remand (¶¶ 19–20, 22 n.4).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.