Utah Supreme Court · Published Opinion

Does “mineral extraction” zoning allow a gravel pit? Carrier v. Salt Lake County

2004 UT 98No. 20020946Decided Nov 23, 2004Real Property & Land UseAffirmed

Holding

Reviewing a local board’s interpretation of a zoning ordinance for correctness with some non-binding deference, the court held that “mineral extraction and processing” in the FR-20 Zone does not encompass gravel pit operations, so the Board acted illegally under CLUDMA in upholding the expansion.

Key takeaways

The Utah Supreme Court sided with Save Our Canyons and upheld the ruling voiding the County’s approval of the gravel pit expansion, though it denied the group’s own requests.

  • In Salt Lake County’s FR-20 Zone, “mineral extraction and processing” does not include gravel pit operations.
  • Courts decide what a zoning ordinance means, giving a local board’s reading some respect but not treating it as binding.
  • A request for attorney fees that was never raised in the district court, and was not fully argued on appeal, was rejected.

What happened?

A gravel pit in Parley’s Canyon has operated on and off since 1886. It was shut down in 1985, reclaimed, then reopened in 1992 under a permit from the Salt Lake County Planning Commission. In October 2000, the current owner, Harper Contracting Inc., asked to expand the pit from 11.5 to about 62.2 acres.

The Planning Commission approved the expansion, and the County Board of Adjustments upheld it. David Carrier and Save Our Canyons (together, “SOC”) then asked the district court to review the decision. That court granted summary judgment (a ruling without a trial) for SOC and declared the approvals void. The County appealed.

Why did the zoning matter?

The land sits in the Forestry and Recreation Zone, called the FR-20 Zone. That zone allows “mineral extraction and processing” as a conditional use, meaning a use allowed only with a permit. It does not mention gravel pits. The County argued that gravel pits count as mineral extraction. SOC argued they do not.

How much weight did the County’s own reading get?

The court said a court, not the local board, has the final word on what an ordinance means. But it gives the board’s reading some respect, which can tip a close case. This was not a close case.

The court also gave the County’s reading little weight here. The County had admitted it treated the application as an “amendment” to avoid limits on new development. The court said the County’s position seemed driven by the result it wanted, not by its expertise.

What did the court decide about gravel pits?

Gravel pits are not “mineral extraction” in the FR-20 Zone. The word “mineral” can include gravel, but its meaning depends on context.

Here, other County zones list “gravel pits” by name, so leaving them out of the FR-20 Zone was treated as deliberate. A gravel pit would also clash with the zone’s purpose of protecting natural and scenic resources. And Utah’s Mined Land Reclamation Act leaves sand, gravel and rock aggregate out of its definitions of “mineral deposit” and “mining operation.”

So the Board acted illegally when it upheld the approval. Because of that, the court did not need to decide SOC’s second challenge, about waivers of the Foothills and Canyon Overlay Zone’s development standards.

Did SOC get everything it asked for?

No. SOC asked the court to strike the County’s brief for misstating facts and citing the record incorrectly. The court disapproved of some of the County’s citations but declined to strike the brief. Instead, it set aside the few points the County made without legal support.

SOC also asked for attorney fees under the “private attorney general” doctrine, which can allow fees for people who vindicate an important public policy. The court rejected the request because SOC never raised it in the district court and did not fully argue it on appeal.

What happens now?

The district court’s ruling stands, and the approval of the expansion remains void. All five justices agreed.

What should people take from this?

A use listed in one zone but left out of another will likely be read as left out on purpose. Courts will make up their own minds about what a zoning ordinance means.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Durrant, J., joined by Durham, C.J., Wilkins, A.C.J., and Parrish and Nehring, JJ.). The district court granted summary judgment to David Carrier and Save Our Canyons (“SOC”), voiding the County’s approval of a Parley’s Canyon gravel pit expansion. The Supreme Court held that “mineral extraction and processing” in the FR-20 Zone does not encompass gravel pits, so the Board’s approval was illegal under CLUDMA (¶¶ 41, 44).

Issue 1: Motion to strike the County’s brief (none stated, ¶¶ 18–22): SOC’s request to strike the brief and for fees and costs denied

The court declined to strike the County’s brief or award SOC fees and costs. The County “arguably stretches certain facts,” but the brief as a whole is supported by the record and makes good-faith arguments, unlike the frivolous appeal in Hunt v. Hurst, 785 P.2d 414 (Utah 1990) (¶ 19). The County’s citations to the independently paginated administrative record drew disapproval, but the court could follow the record (¶ 21). For unsupported legal assertions, the remedy is to disregard them, not to strike the brief (¶ 22).

Issue 2: “Mineral extraction” and gravel pits (correctness, ¶¶ 25–41): affirmed (no error)

Gravel pit operations are not “mineral extraction and processing” under the FR-20 Zone ordinance.

Standard. CLUDMA review asks whether a decision is arbitrary, capricious or illegal, and illegality means the decision violates a statute or ordinance (¶¶ 25–26). The court rejected the court of appeals’ no-deference rule in Brown v. Sandy City Board of Adjustment, 957 P.2d 207 (Utah Ct.App.1998), and the County’s arbitrary-and-capricious approach drawn from Associated General Contractors v. Board of Oil, Gas & Mining, 2001 UT 112, 38 P.3d 291 (¶¶ 26–27). Local boards lack state agencies’ technical expertise, so courts review their interpretations for correctness while affording “some level of non-binding deference” (¶ 28).

Merits. “Mineral” is contextual (¶¶ 32–34). Gravel pits are expressly listed in the S-1-G and M-2 Zones but omitted from FR-20, and the omission is presumed purposeful under Biddle v. Wash. Terrace City, 1999 UT 110, ¶ 14, 993 P.2d 875 (¶ 35). A gravel pit conflicts with the zone’s purpose of protecting natural and scenic resources (¶ 36). The ordinance’s dust, noise and grading conditions fit underground mining too (¶ 37). The Mined Land Reclamation Act excludes sand, gravel and rock aggregate from “mineral deposit” and “mining operation” (¶ 38). The Planning Commission’s reading got little weight because it appeared outcome-driven: the County admitted structuring the application as an amendment “to avoid the current restrictions on new development” (¶¶ 39–40).

Issue 3: Private attorney general fees (none stated, ¶¶ 42–43): not reached

SOC’s fee request was rejected without deciding whether the case meets Stewart v. Utah Pub. Serv. Comm’n, 885 P.2d 759, 788 (Utah 1994). SOC did not raise it in the district court, citing Crank v. Utah Judicial Council, 2001 UT 8, ¶ 43 n.17, 20 P.3d 307, and did not adequately brief it, citing State v. Thomas, 961 P.2d 299, 304 (Utah 1998) (¶ 43).

Not reached

Given the County’s concession at oral argument that even an amended permit must comply with current zoning, the court did not decide whether the Planning Commission may amend conditional use permits or must follow new-permit procedures (¶ 24). It did not decide whether the FCOZ waiver requirements were met (¶ 41).

Takeaways

  • A local board’s ordinance interpretation gets correctness review with non-binding deference that may decide close cases (¶¶ 28, 39).
  • Deference shrinks when the interpretation appears driven by a desired outcome rather than expertise (¶ 40).
  • A use expressly listed in other zones but omitted from one is presumed deliberately excluded (¶ 35).
  • Incorrect record citations drew disapproval but no striking; unsupported assertions are disregarded (¶¶ 21–22).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Carrier v. Salt Lake County
Court
Utah Supreme Court
Citation
2004 UT 98
Case no.
20020946
Filed
2002
Decided
November 23, 2004
Opinion type
Authored
Heard
Argued
Who appealed
Salt Lake County
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
County approval to expand a Parley's Canyon gravel pit from 11.5 to approximately 62.2 acres in the FR-20 Zone

The panel

Matthew B. DurrantAuthor
Christine M. DurhamConcurred
Ronald E. NehringConcurred
Jill N. ParrishConcurred
Michael J. WilkinsConcurred

Parties & counsel

Salt Lake County — AppellantGovernment agency
Carrier — AppelleeOther

Practice Tip

When defending a local board's reading of an ordinance, show that it rests on the board's expertise; the court gave little weight to a reading it saw as shaped by the result the County wanted (¶¶ 39–40).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.