Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

When does the clock start to sue over a truck warranty? Bingham Livestock v. Paccar LLC

2026 UT App 136No. 20250608-CADecided Sep 11, 2026Contracts & Business DisputesAffirmed/Reversed in part

Holding

Warranties promising that tractors “will be free from defects” appearing during a stated time or mileage period explicitly extend to future performance under Utah Code § 70A-2-725(2), so the contractual one-year UCC limitations period runs from discovery, and the economic loss rule bars negligence claims against warranty repair shops that were part of the same contract-based transaction.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals revived Bingham’s warranty claims against Paccar and Peterbilt but agreed that its negligence claims against the repair shops were properly thrown out.

  • A one-year deadline to sue on these tractor warranties applied, because the deal was mainly a sale of goods.
  • Because the warranties promised the tractors “will be free from defects” for a set time, the deadline runs from when each problem was or should have been discovered, not from delivery.
  • The buyer could not sue the warranty repair shops for negligence; its remedy is a contract claim against the companies that gave the warranties.

What happened?

Bingham Livestock Transportation Inc. bought three new tractors from Peterbilt Motors Company in late 2013, for a combined price of a little over $460,000. The tractors had Paccar engines. Each sale came with a Peterbilt warranty and a Paccar warranty, and Bingham paid $8,200 per tractor to extend the Paccar warranty to four years or 500,000 miles.

The tractors kept shutting down and losing power. Bingham took them to two repair shops, The Jackson Group of Salt Lake and Kenworth Sales of Ogden, dozens of times. Bingham says the mechanics would not show it invoices or repair sheets. In 2017 Bingham traded the tractors back and later received a service report on all the work.

Bingham sued in February 2018. It claimed Paccar and Peterbilt broke their warranties and the repair shops did negligent work. The warranties said any lawsuit had to be filed within 12 months after the claim arose.

What did the district court do?

It first said the timing question depended on facts. Shortly before trial, it changed course, ruled that all of the contract claims were too late, and canceled the trial. It also dismissed the negligence claims under the “economic loss rule,” a rule that generally keeps parties to a contract-based deal from suing each other in negligence for money losses.

Was a one-year deadline the right one?

Yes. Bingham argued for Utah’s general six-year deadline for written contracts. The court held the deals were mainly sales of goods, so the Uniform Commercial Code (Utah’s statutes on sales of goods) applied. That law allows parties to shorten the deadline to one year, and they did.

When did the one-year clock start?

Usually, a warranty claim starts the clock on delivery. But there is an exception when a warranty “explicitly extends to future performance of the goods.” The court held these warranties did, because they promised the tractors “will be free from defects” during the warranty period. So the clock started when Bingham discovered, or should have discovered, each problem.

Were the contract claims too late?

The court said that could not be decided all at once. Bingham’s owner swore that Bingham did not get repair information until August 16, 2017. The court held those facts mattered and the district court had not explained why it disregarded them. Some claims may turn out to be late, but each must be looked at separately.

What about the repair shops?

Bingham lost on this part. Even without a direct contract with the shops, Bingham, Paccar, Peterbilt, and the shops were all part of one contract-based arrangement. The duties Bingham pointed to came from those contracts, so its remedy is a contract claim against Paccar and Peterbilt.

What happens now?

The contract claims go back to the district court. The court also said any claim of hidden facts should be weighed in deciding when Bingham should have discovered its claims, not as a separate reason to extend the deadline.

What should people take from this?

The exact wording of a warranty can decide when the time to sue begins. And a buyer under a warranty may be limited to suing the company that gave it, not the shop that did the repairs.

Bottom line

Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded (Harris, J., joined by Christiansen Forster and Mortensen, JJ.). The one-year contractual UCC limitations period applies, but the Paccar and Peterbilt warranties explicitly extend to future performance, so Utah Code § 70A-2-725(2)’s discovery rule governs accrual, and the district court erred by holding as a matter of law that all contract-based claims were time-barred (¶¶ 59, 72). The economic loss rule bars the negligence claims against the Repair Shops (¶ 71).

Issue 1: Which limitations period (correctness, ¶ 20): affirmed (no error)

The UCC limitations period in § 70A-2-725(1), shortened by agreement to one year, applies rather than the six-year period in § 78B-2-309(1)(b) (¶ 30). Assuming the agreements were hybrid contracts, the predominant purpose was the sale of tractors, shown by the “Vehicle Purchase Agreement” title and warranty remedies premised on purchase (¶¶ 27–28, applying Val Peterson Inc. v. Tennant Metals Pty. Ltd., 2023 UT App 115, ¶ 27, 537 P.3d 660). The court read the warranties and purchase agreements together (¶ 26), and applied the 2013 statutes, not the amended hybrid-transaction provisions (¶ 25 n.3). Bingham pointed to no written service promises in the record (¶ 29).

Issue 2: Future-performance warranty (correctness, ¶ 20): reversed

The warranties explicitly extend to future performance, so a discovery rule applies to all contract-based claims (¶ 49). Repair-or-replace promises plainly concern future performance, and denying a discovery rule would make the purchased extended warranties illusory (¶¶ 38–39). For the lemon claims, the “will be free from defects” language, covering defects “appearing under normal commercial use and service” during the warranty period, and the limitations clause’s reference to “use,” make the warranty forward-looking (¶¶ 41–42), following Kenworth of Indianapolis, Inc. v. Seventy-Seven Ltd., 134 N.E.3d 370, 380 (Ind. 2019) (¶¶ 43–44). The court distinguished Voth v. Chrysler Motor Corp., 545 P.2d 371 (Kan. 1976), whose warranty lacked future-tense language about the vehicle’s performance (¶¶ 46–47 & n.4).

Issue 3: Fact questions on discovery (correctness, ¶ 20): reversed

The blanket ruling that Bingham “was or should have been aware” of all contract claims within a year of delivery was error (¶ 56). Discovery is “intensely fact-dependent” (¶ 51, quoting Russell Packard Dev., Inc. v. Carson, 2005 UT 14, ¶ 22, 108 P.3d 741). The oil-rag claim is likely timely, and on any renewed motion the court should assess each failure-to-repair claim against the February 28, 2017 cutoff (¶ 53 & n.5). The owner’s sworn statement that no service information arrived until August 16, 2017 is material and record-supported for the lemon claims (¶¶ 54–55).

Issue 4: Fraudulent concealment (correctness, ¶ 20): remand guidance

Bingham’s equitable-tolling theory is “on the wrong track” (¶ 57). Where a statutory discovery rule applies, equitable discovery rules do not; alleged concealment bears only on when Bingham discovered or should have discovered its claims (¶ 58, citing Russell Packard Dev., Inc. v. Carson, 2005 UT 14, ¶ 25, 108 P.3d 741).

Issue 5: Economic loss rule without privity (correctness, ¶ 20): affirmed (no error)

The rule bars the negligence claims against the Repair Shops despite no direct contract (¶ 67). All parties were part of one contract-based transaction, each able to allocate risk by contract, as in SME Indus., Inc. v. Thompson, Ventulett, Stainback and Assocs., Inc., 2001 UT 54, 28 P.3d 669 and Davencourt at Pilgrims Landing Homeowners Ass’n v. Davencourt at Pilgrims Landing, LC, 2009 UT 65, 221 P.3d 234 (¶¶ 63–67). Bingham did not challenge dismissal of negligence claims against Paccar and Peterbilt (¶ 60 n.7).

Issue 6: Independent duty (correctness, ¶ 20): affirmed (no error)

No independent duty exists on these facts (¶¶ 69–70). The alleged duty not to harm the tractors arose only because Bingham brought them in under the warranties and overlapped the contractual repair duties (¶ 70, citing Grynberg v. Questar Pipeline Co., 2003 UT 8, ¶ 43, 70 P.3d 1).

Takeaways

  • Future-tense “will be free from defects” language tied to a warranty period can trigger § 70A-2-725(2)’s discovery rule (¶¶ 41–44).
  • Discovery-rule rulings on summary judgment should be claim-by-claim, not blanket (¶ 53).
  • Raise concealment within the statutory discovery inquiry, not as equitable tolling (¶ 58).
  • The economic loss rule can reach parties in the same contract chain without privity (¶ 67).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Bingham Livestock v. Paccar LLC
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 136
Case no.
20250608-CA
Filed
2025
Decided
September 11, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Bingham Livestock
Disposition
Affirmed in part and Reversed in part
At stake
Breach-of-warranty and negligence claims over three tractors bought for a combined price of a little over $460,000 that repeatedly broke down.

The panel

Ryan M. HarrisAuthor
Michele M. Christiansen ForsterConcurred
David N. MortensenConcurred
Trial court
First District Court, Brigham City Department · Judge Brandon J. Maynard

Parties & counsel

Bingham Livestock — AppellantBusinessMarlin J. Grant
Paccar LLC — AppelleeBusinessMarshall J. HendricksonS. Spencer Brown

Practice Tip

When a sale-of-goods warranty uses future-tense language tied to a warranty period, argue accrual under the statutory discovery rule in § 70A-2-725(2) and press for a claim-by-claim discovery analysis rather than a blanket limitations ruling (¶¶ 41–44, 53).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.