Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can I be retried if my trial was stopped over a judge’s busy calendar? State v. Mitton

2026 UT App 137No. 20221076-CADecided Sep 11, 2026Criminal AppealsRemanded

Holding

Under Utah Code section 76-1-403, prosecution on amended charges from the same altercation is barred because the first jury trial was improperly terminated, and a newly assigned judge’s calendaring constraints do not satisfy the “physical impossibility” exception, which requires a tangible impediment to proceeding.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with Mitton and ordered the district court to dismiss the amended charges against him.

  • Under Utah’s single criminal episode statute, a trial stopped after the jury is sworn and before a verdict can bar new charges from the same episode, unless an exception applies.
  • A judge’s scheduling problems are not “physical impossibility” under the statute; the court gave a wildfire that shut down courthouses as an example of what is.
  • Because the statute decided the case, the court did not redo the constitutional double jeopardy analysis.

What happened?

In late 2020, Richard Scott Mitton and his brother-in-law got into an altercation that left the brother-in-law seriously injured. The State charged Mitton with two counts of aggravated assault, and the case went to a jury trial before Judge Maynard.

After the first day of trial, Judge Maynard told the parties he was distantly related to one of the witnesses. Mitton asked that the judge be removed. The next morning, the presiding judge, Judge Cannell, granted that request, moved the case to Judge Walsh, and declared a mistrial, meaning the trial ended without a verdict.

The next day, the State filed new charges based on the same altercation: one second-degree felony and one third-degree felony. Mitton asked the court to dismiss them, arguing that trying him again would be double jeopardy, which means being put on trial twice for the same thing.

Why did the district court refuse to dismiss?

Four months after the mistrial, Judge Cannell issued another order explaining that keeping the jury would not have been possible because of “calendaring constraints.” Relying entirely on that order, Judge Walsh ruled that the mistrial was legally necessary and denied Mitton’s motion.

How did the case get back to the Court of Appeals?

Mitton appealed before trial. In 2024 the Court of Appeals agreed with him under the Utah Constitution. The Utah Supreme Court reversed that decision and sent the case back, asking the Court of Appeals to look again at whether Judge Cannell had reasonable alternatives to a mistrial.

What did the court decide this time?

It ruled for Mitton on a different ground he had raised: Utah’s single criminal episode statute. That law says that if a person was prosecuted for crimes from one episode, a later prosecution for the same or different crimes from that episode is barred if the first case was “improperly terminated.”

The court found both parts met. The new charges came from the same altercation, so they were a single criminal episode. The first trial was improperly terminated because the jury had been sworn and the trial ended before a verdict, for reasons that were not an acquittal (a not-guilty finding).

Didn’t an exception apply?

The State argued that the “physical impossibility” exception applied because Judge Walsh’s full calendar meant a trial could not happen for months. The court disagreed. It said “physical” refers to real, tangible things, such as an earthquake, a fire, or something else that makes the courthouse unusable. It pointed to the 2026 Cottonwood Fire, which led Utah courts to suspend operations in Garfield and Piute counties, as the kind of situation the statute means. A busy schedule is not.

What happens now?

The case goes back to the district court, which must enter an order granting Mitton’s motion to dismiss. Because the statute decided the case, the court did not redo the constitutional analysis the Supreme Court had asked about.

What should people take from this?

In Utah, the reason a trial is stopped matters. When a jury has been sworn and a trial ends early, the State may be barred from starting over on charges from the same episode, and scheduling trouble alone did not get around that bar here.

Bottom line

Reversed and remanded with instructions to enter an order granting Mitton’s motion to dismiss on double jeopardy grounds (Oliver, J., joined by Harris and Tenney, JJ.). The Utah Supreme Court had held that the legal necessity exception can apply even when the parties had no chance to object to a mistrial, and remanded for an independent assessment of reasonable alternatives (¶ 5, citing State v. Mitton, 2026 UT 11, ¶ 20, 589 P.3d 724). The panel instead decided Mitton’s statutory argument, which its earlier opinion had not reached, and held that the single criminal episode statute bars the prosecution (¶¶ 7, 14–15).

Issue 1: Single criminal episode statute (correctness, ¶ 6): reversed

Utah Code section 76-1-403 bars prosecution on the amended information, so the district court erred in denying the motion to dismiss (¶ 14). Correctness review applied because the newly assigned judge was in no better position than the appellate court to assess the need for a mistrial (¶ 6). The amended charges rested on the same altercation, a “single criminal episode,” and the first trial was improperly terminated because the jury had been “impaneled and sworn” and it ended before verdict for reasons not amounting to acquittal (¶ 9). The State relied only on the “physical impossibility” exception in section 76-1-403(4)(c)(i) (¶ 11). The court held that “physical” means a tangible impediment, such as an earthquake, fire, or a situation making the courthouse unusable, and cited the Cottonwood Fire court closures as an example (¶ 12). Reading the exception to cover calendaring difficulties would ignore the word “physical,” contrary to State v. Sanders, 2019 UT 25, ¶ 17, 445 P.3d 453 (¶ 13).

In footnote 3, the court agreed with the State that Judge Cannell had discretion to amend his initial three-sentence order, citing IHC Health Services Inc. v. D&K Mgmt., Inc., 2008 UT 73, ¶ 27, 196 P.3d 588 and Utah R. Civ. P. 54(b), so it did not address the State’s alternative argument that the legal defect exception applied if the initial order controlled (¶ 11 n.3).

Not reached

Issue 2: the constitutional legal necessity analysis the supreme court remanded for. Because the statute bars the prosecution, the court “need not conduct a new constitutional legal necessity analysis” (¶ 7).

Takeaways

  • Raise the section 76-1-403 bar alongside the constitutional claim; here the statutory ground decided the case after the constitutional ground was reversed on certiorari (¶ 7).
  • The “physical impossibility” exception requires a tangible impediment; a judge’s full calendar did not qualify (¶¶ 12–13).
  • Correctness review applied where the judge ruling on the motion to dismiss was not the judge who declared the mistrial (¶ 6).
  • A presiding judge may amend a mistrial order before final judgment, and the court treated the amended order as operative (¶ 11 n.3).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State v. Mitton
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 137
Case no.
20221076-CA
Filed
2022
Decided
September 11, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Mitton
Disposition
Remanded
At stake
Whether the State could prosecute Mitton on amended assault charges after his first jury trial ended in a mistrial when the trial judge was disqualified mid-trial.

The panel

Amy J. OliverAuthor
Ryan M. HarrisConcurred
Ryan D. TenneyConcurred
Trial court
First District Court, Brigham City Department · Judge Brandon J. Maynard

Parties & counsel

Mitton — AppellantIndividual(s)Wayne K. Caldwell
State — AppelleeState of UtahDerek E. BrownConnor Nelson

Practice Tip

When a trial ends after the jury is sworn, consider the single criminal episode statute as a separate basis for dismissal, and hold the State to the statute's text: scheduling problems are not "physical impossibility" (¶¶ 12–14).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.