Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Is it defamation if my old company says I mistreated workers? Fielding v. GBS Benefits

2026 UT App 138No. 20250606-CADecided Sep 11, 2026Personal Injury & TortsAffirmed

Holding

Statements that a former CEO had “deeply unfortunate interactions” with and “mistreatment” of employees, followed by an investigation and his departure, were not capable of conveying, expressly or by implication, the alleged defamatory meaning that he engaged in sexual misconduct, so his defamation and dependent claims were properly dismissed.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with GBS Benefits, the Leavitt Group and Eric Leavitt, upholding the dismissal of all of Fielding’s claims.

  • Vague statements that a former executive did something wrong were not enough to support Fielding’s claim that he was accused of sexual misconduct.
  • A settlement clause barring only “maliciously untrue” defamatory statements did not stop the companies from talking about why Fielding left.
  • A request to amend a complaint tucked into a response brief, with no proposed amended complaint attached, could be refused.

What happened?

Rick Fielding founded GBS Benefits, an employee benefits consulting firm. The Leavitt Group later bought a majority interest. Fielding stepped down as CEO in 2021 but stayed at the company. In 2023, after some employees raised concerns that he “was tough, intense, and demanding,” GBS had a law firm investigate and then ended his employment.

At a May 2023 “townhall” meeting, GBS’s new CEO said Fielding had committed “infractions” and called it a “me-too” moment. Fielding sued over that and settled. The settlement barred the companies from making “maliciously untrue” defamatory statements about him.

In June 2024, Eric Leavitt, CEO of the Leavitt Group, gave a banquet speech to about eight hundred people. He praised the former CEO’s vision, but also described “deeply unfortunate interactions,” “mistreatment” of employees, and an investigation after which the company had “no other choice” but to part ways with him.

What did Fielding claim?

Fielding sued GBS, the Leavitt Group and Leavitt for defamation (a false statement that harms someone’s reputation), false light (a privacy claim about being portrayed falsely), breach of contract, and breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing (a promise read into every contract not to undercut the other side’s benefits). He said the speech accused him of sexual misconduct.

The trial court dismissed the case at the start, ruling the statements were protected opinion. It also refused to let him amend his complaint.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It affirmed, but for a different reason on the defamation claim. The court held the statements could not reasonably be understood to say Fielding committed sexual misconduct, which was the meaning he relied on. So it did not need to decide whether they were protected opinion.

Nothing in the speech mentioned anything sexual. The words were vague and could describe many reasons a company might part ways with an executive. Leavitt also never referred back to the townhall meeting, and Fielding did not claim that anyone at the banquet had attended it.

Because Fielding agreed his false light and contract claims depended on the defamation claim, those failed too. The implied covenant claim failed because the settlement barred only malicious defamatory falsehoods, not all talk about why he left. Reading it more broadly would create new duties the parties never agreed to.

What about amending the complaint?

Fielding asked to amend only in a short section of his response to the motion to dismiss. He did not file a separate motion or attach a proposed amended complaint, both of which Utah’s rules require. The court held the trial judge did not abuse his discretion, meaning the decision was within reasonable bounds. It added that without a proposed complaint, there was no way to tell whether an amendment would have helped.

What happens now?

The dismissal stands. The case does not go back to the trial court.

What should people take from this?

In this case, general remarks that an executive mistreated people and was let go after an investigation were too vague to carry the specific sexual-misconduct meaning Fielding claimed. A request to amend needs its own motion and a proposed amended complaint.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Tenney, J., joined by Christiansen Forster and Oliver, JJ.). The district court dismissed on protected-opinion grounds; the court instead affirmed because the statements were not capable of sustaining the defamatory meaning Fielding pleaded, that he engaged in sexual misconduct (¶¶ 24, 30, 41, 46). It upheld dismissal of the remaining claims and the denial of leave to amend (¶ 55).

Issue 2: Express defamation (correctness, ¶ 19): affirmed on other grounds

The statements did not expressly say Fielding engaged in sexual misconduct. Relying on Bailey v. Bayles, 2002 UT 58, ¶ 10, 52 P.3d 1158, the court affirmed on a ground apparent in the record (¶ 24). Because Fielding’s briefs anchored his claim to sexual misconduct, the court analyzed only that meaning and held any broader non-sexual meaning was not adequately briefed (¶¶ 28–29 & n.6). The word “sexual” appears nowhere in the remarks (¶ 30).

Issue 3: Implied defamation (correctness, ¶ 19): affirmed on other grounds

No reasonable listener could take the banquet remarks to imply sexual misconduct. Given Fielding’s own allegation that complaints concerned his being “tough, intense, and demanding,” references to “unfortunate interactions” and “mistreatment” could describe virtually anything (¶ 34). Following HR process and consulting counsel implies nothing about the reason for termination (¶ 35). The statements implied something negative but were vague; see, e.g., Hogan v. Winder, 762 F.3d 1096, 1107 (10th Cir. 2014), and a statement is not defamatory merely because it is “nettlesome or embarrassing,” Cox v. Hatch, 761 P.2d 556, 561 (Utah 1988) (¶¶ 36–37). The Townhall “me-too” remark did not help: Leavitt never referred back to it, and Fielding did not plead any overlap between the audiences (¶¶ 39–40).

Issue 4: Defamation by incomplete disclosure (correctness, ¶ 19): affirmed on other grounds

Assuming the Restatement (Second) of Torts § 566 doctrine is available in Utah and was pleaded, the claim fails. Utah’s appellate courts have not definitively adopted it, citing Keisel v. Westbrook, 2023 UT App 163, ¶ 62, 542 P.3d 536 (¶ 43). Because the remarks did not convey sexual misconduct, they did not imply undisclosed investigation findings of such misconduct (¶ 46). The court left open whether the doctrine applies in Utah.

Issue 5: Breach of contract and false light (correctness, ¶ 19): affirmed (no error)

These claims fall with the defamation claim. Fielding conceded both depend on it (¶ 47).

Issue 6: Implied covenant (correctness, ¶ 19): affirmed (no error)

The covenant cannot bar speech about Fielding’s termination that the Non-Disparagement provision allows. That provision prohibited only “maliciously untrue defamatory, libelous, or slanderous statements”; Fielding’s reading would create broader duties than the parties agreed to (¶ 50), applying Far West Bank v. Robertson, 2017 UT App 213, ¶¶ 29–30, 406 P.3d 1134 (¶ 49).

Issue 7: Leave to amend (abuse of discretion, ¶ 20): affirmed (no error)

Denying a leave request made in an opposition memorandum, without a proposed amended pleading, was not an abuse of discretion. Rule 7(n) bars making a motion in a memorandum opposing a motion, and rule 15(a)(2) requires attaching the proposed pleading (¶ 52). “The rules are the rules” (¶ 54), following Holmes Dev., LLC v. Cook, 2002 UT 38, ¶ 59, 48 P.3d 895, and Coroles v. Sabey, 2003 UT App 339, ¶ 47, 79 P.3d 974. Alternatively, with no proposed complaint in the record, Fielding could not show prejudice (¶ 54 n.8).

Not reached

Issue 1, whether the statements were protected opinion under the Utah Constitution (the district court’s ground). Because the statements were not capable of defamatory meaning, the court had no need to decide it (¶¶ 23–24), noting under Mathews v. McCown, 2025 UT 34, ¶ 97, 575 P.3d 1114, that the two are “separate inquiries.”

Takeaways

  • Define the defamatory meaning carefully; the court held Fielding to the sexual-misconduct meaning his briefs stressed and treated broader readings as inadequately briefed (¶ 29 n.6).
  • To rely on earlier statements as context for implication, plead that the later audience heard them (¶ 40).
  • A non-disparagement clause limited to malicious defamation will not be broadened through the implied covenant (¶ 50).
  • Request leave to amend by separate motion with the proposed amended pleading attached (¶¶ 52–54).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Fielding v. GBS Benefits
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 138
Case no.
20250606-CA
Filed
2025
Decided
September 11, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Fielding
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Fielding's claims for defamation, false light, breach of contract and breach of the implied covenant based on a CEO's banquet speech about his termination

The panel

Ryan D. TenneyAuthor
Michele M. Christiansen ForsterConcurred
Amy J. OliverConcurred
Trial court
Third District Court, West Jordan Department · Judge Matthew D. Bates

Parties & counsel

Fielding — AppellantIndividual(s)Gregory M. SaylinTyson C. Horrocks
GBS Benefits — AppelleeOtherMatthew N. EvansWhitney Hulet KrogueStephen R. Arroyo

Practice Tip

A request for leave to amend buried in an opposition to a motion to dismiss, with no proposed amended complaint attached, violates rules 7(n) and 15(a)(2), and denying it is not an abuse of discretion (¶¶ 52–54).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.