Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can I attack today’s version of a law for a crime from years ago? State v. Avina

2026 UT App 135No. 20240906-CADecided Sep 11, 2026Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

A defendant who challenges only the current version of the “position of special trust” non-consent statutes, rather than the materially different 2013 version in effect when he acted, has not carried his burden of showing unconstitutionality; and rule 16 does not require pretrial disclosure of added detail in a non-defendant witness’s unrecorded, non-exculpatory account.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals upheld Zachariah Lee Avina’s convictions and rejected both of his challenges.

  • A criminal case is governed by the version of the statute in effect when the acts happened, so a constitutional challenge has to target that version.
  • Arguments raised for the first time in a reply brief are treated as waived.
  • Under rule 16, the State did not have to disclose small added details in a witness’s trial testimony that did not come from written or recorded statements and did not help the defense.

What happened?

Zachariah Lee Avina is the uncle of the victim, whom the court calls “Mary” (a made-up name). Between 2010 and 2013, when Mary was fourteen to sixteen, he engaged in sexual acts with her. Years later, as adults, the two exchanged emails discussing those events, and Mary eventually went to the police.

In 2023 the State charged Avina with two counts of object rape, two counts of forcible sexual abuse, and one count of lewdness. A jury convicted him on all five counts, and he received consecutive prison sentences for the felonies.

What did Avina argue?

The rape and sexual abuse charges required proof that Mary did not consent. The State’s theory was that Avina, as her uncle, held a “position of special trust,” which the law treats as showing a lack of consent for a victim under 18.

Avina argued that this part of the law is unconstitutional because it lets the State prove non-consent just by showing he was her uncle. He also argued the case should have been dismissed because Mary’s trial testimony included details the State had not shared with the defense before trial.

Why did the constitutional challenge fail?

Courts apply the version of a criminal law that was in effect when the acts happened. Here that was the 2013 version.

Under that older version, being an uncle was not enough. The State also had to show the uncle could use his position to exercise “undue influence” over the victim. Only after a 2013 Utah Supreme Court decision did the Legislature change the law so that being an uncle alone counts.

Avina’s opening brief attacked only the current law. He tried to address the 2013 version in his reply brief (the appellant’s last brief, which answers the State’s), but the court treats arguments raised there for the first time as given up. So he did not show that the law that actually applied to him was unconstitutional.

Why did the discovery challenge fail?

Rule 16 of the Utah Rules of Criminal Procedure lists what the prosecution must hand over before trial. For witnesses other than the defendant, it covers written or recorded statements, plus evidence that helps the defense.

The details Avina pointed to, such as the depth of penetration or Mary moving to the back of a truck, did not come from written or recorded statements, and none helped him. The court said witnesses sometimes add detail at trial, and that is part of how trials work. Because the State had no duty to disclose those details, the trial judge did not misuse his discretion by refusing to dismiss.

What happens now?

Nothing further. The court affirmed both rulings and all five convictions.

What should people take from this?

A challenge to a criminal law has to be aimed at the version that governed the conduct, and it has to be made in the first brief. The court did not decide whether the current version of the law is constitutional.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Harris, J., joined by Christiansen Forster and Luthy, JJ.). The constitutionality of the non-consent provisions is measured against the version in effect when the acts occurred (2010 to 2013), and Avina’s opening brief challenged only the current version (¶¶ 26–33). Rule 16 did not require disclosure of the trial-testimony details he identified (¶¶ 38–41).

Issue 1: Constitutionality of the non-consent statutes (correctness, ¶ 23): affirmed (no error)

Avina did not carry his burden of showing that the applicable statutes were unconstitutional, so the denial of his motion to dismiss stands (¶ 34). Courts apply the law in effect at the time of the offense (¶ 26, citing State v. Clark, 2011 UT 23, ¶ 11, 251 P.3d 829). Under Utah Code § 76-5-404.1(4)(h) (2013), as read in State v. Watkins, 2013 UT 28, ¶ 17, 309 P.3d 209, superseded by statute as stated in Christensen v. Juab School Dist., 2017 UT 47, ¶ 14, 424 P.3d 108, an enumerated position such as “uncle” established only a position of authority; the State also had to prove undue influence (¶ 30). The equal-protection infirmity Avina asserted, that status alone proves non-consent, exists only in the post-Watkins amendments (¶¶ 31–32), and ruling on that version would be advisory (¶ 27). His attempt to address the 2013 version in reply came too late (¶ 33, quoting Monticello Wind Farm, LLC v. Public Service Comm’n, 2019 UT 43, ¶ 80, 449 P.3d 128). The court noted that his opening brief raised no sufficiency challenge on undue influence and no challenge to the jury instructions, some of which appear to reference the current statutes, and did not address those points (¶ 34 n.5).

Issue 2: Rule 16 discovery motion (abuse of discretion, ¶ 24): affirmed (no error)

The State had no duty to disclose the five details, so denying the motion to dismiss was not an abuse of discretion (¶ 41). Rule 16(a)(1)(A) reaches unrecorded oral statements only of the defendant or codefendants. Rule 16(a)(1)(D) reaches only written or recorded statements of other witnesses. None of the items was exculpatory under rule 16(a)(1)(F) (¶ 38). State v. Kallin, 877 P.2d 138, 143 (Utah 1994), described a practice, not a rule 16 duty to disclose inculpatory evidence (¶ 39; see also State v. Rugebregt, 965 P.2d 518, 522 (Utah Ct. App. 1998)). The plain text of rule 16(a)(1)(A) does not extend to complaining witnesses (¶ 40, citing Gardiner v. Taufer, 2014 UT 56, ¶ 26, 342 P.3d 269).

Takeaways

  • Aim a constitutional challenge at the statute in effect on the offense date. The court will not rule on a materially different later version (¶¶ 26–28).
  • Develop the argument in the opening brief; a fix offered in reply is waived (¶ 33).
  • Absent other circumstances, small added detail in a witness’s trial account is not a rule 16 violation when it comes from no written or recorded statement and is not favorable to the defense (¶ 38).
  • The court did not decide whether the current version of § 76-5-404.1 is constitutional (¶ 32).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State v. Avina
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 135
Case no.
20240906-CA
Filed
2024
Decided
September 11, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Avina
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Convictions for two counts of object rape, two counts of forcible sexual abuse, and one count of lewdness, with consecutive prison sentences for the felonies.

The panel

Ryan M. HarrisAuthor
Michele M. Christiansen ForsterConcurred
John D. LuthyConcurred
Trial court
Fifth District Court, St. George Department · Judge Jay Winward

Parties & counsel

Avina — AppellantIndividual(s)K. Andrew Fitzgerald
State — AppelleeState of UtahDerek E. BrownJonathan S. Bauer

Practice Tip

When challenging a criminal statute that has since been amended, build the opening brief around the version in effect on the offense date; arguments about that version raised first in reply are waived (¶¶ 26, 33).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.