Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can I get paid for design work on a home deal that fell through? Hutchings v. Cedar Pointe Homes

2026 UT App 116No. 20250034-CADecided Aug 6, 2026Contracts & Business DisputesAffirmed/Reversed in part

Holding

Emails expressing interest and a draft REPC formed no contract to buy Lot 130, and the partial-performance and estoppel theories fail, but a lot reservation agreement silent on the buyer’s design contributions did not bar his unjust enrichment claim, which presented a genuine factual dispute.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals mostly sided with the sellers, but it revived Hutchings’s claim that they should pay for the value of his design work.

  • Thanking a seller for information and saying you are “very interested” does not accept an offer.
  • A lot reservation agreement saying it is “NOT an offer to purchase” undercut the buyer’s claim that a purchase contract already existed.
  • Because the reservation agreement did not cover the buyer’s design work, his claim to be paid for that work could go forward.

What happened?

Steven Hutchings talked with Cedar Pointe Homes LLC and Trendline Group LLC (the sellers) about buying two lots, each with a custom home to be built on it. On June 4, 2020, the sellers emailed proposed prices: $1,200,000.00 for Lot 130 and $1,320,000.00 for Lot 131, not counting pools. Hutchings wrote back the same day that he was “very interested.” He asked for the plat and asked whether a rooftop patio, fire pit and landscaping were included.

In July 2020 the parties signed a lot reservation agreement for each lot, and Hutchings paid a $10,000 deposit on each. Each agreement said it was “NOT an offer to purchase.” It also said Hutchings had no right or interest in the property until a purchase contract was signed.

Hutchings gave the sellers his own custom floor plan. He said he spent more than 100 hours working with a plan designer. Lot 131 sold for $1,833,234. For Lot 130, the sellers offered a price of $3,995,000 in the fall of 2022. Hutchings would not sign, and the sellers sent back his deposit.

What did Hutchings argue?

He sued. He claimed the emails created a contract. He also claimed his work on the deal took it outside the rule that land sales must be in writing, that the sellers were unjustly enriched (they got a benefit it would be unfair to keep without paying), and that two kinds of estoppel (doctrines that can hold someone to a promise or position another person relied on) applied. The district court ruled for the sellers on every claim without a trial.

Was there a contract?

No. Thanking the sellers for information and saying he was interested was not an unconditional “yes” to their terms. Hutchings later sent a draft purchase contract, but it was unclear and was itself an offer. The reservation agreement also showed that no purchase contract existed yet. Without a contract, he had nothing to “partly perform,” so the exception to the writing rule did not help him.

What about his design work?

Here Hutchings won. He offered evidence that he gave the sellers a custom floor plan and did unpaid design work, and that the sellers knew it. The reservation agreement said nothing about design work, so it did not block this claim. The sellers argued they bought the plans from the designer, but the court held there was a real factual dispute, so the claim needs a trial or further proceedings.

Did the estoppel claims survive?

No. The June 4 email was not a clear and definite promise about a final price, since it said nothing about upgrades or rising construction costs. And equitable estoppel can be used as a claim on its own only in insurance coverage disputes, which this was not.

What happens now?

The case goes back to the district court only on the unjust enrichment claim. The court said it is not certain Hutchings will win that claim.

Bottom line

Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded (Luthy, J., joined by Mortensen and Oliver, JJ.). Summary judgment for Cedar Pointe Homes LLC and Trendline Group LLC (the sellers) stands on Hutchings’s contract, implied covenant, statute of frauds and estoppel theories. It is reversed on unjust enrichment, which goes back for further proceedings (¶ 36). Hutchings did not appeal the quiet title ruling (¶ 15 n.2). Summary judgment is reviewed de novo (¶ 13).

Issue 1: Contract formation (correctness, ¶ 13): affirmed (no error)

The June 4 emails and the later partially completed REPC formed no contract for Lot 130 (¶ 22). Hutchings’s reply (“Thanks for the info. We are very interested”) was not unconditional assent, and his question about a rooftop patio, fire pit and landscaping was either a request for more information or a counteroffer (¶ 18, citing Cea v. Hoffman, 2012 UT App 101, ¶ 24, 276 P.3d 1178). The court did not decide whether the email was an offer (¶ 18 n.3). The draft REPC listed two prices and two lots and was itself an offer (¶ 19). The LRA stated it was “NOT an offer to purchase” and gave Hutchings no interest in the property, which confirmed that no purchase contract existed (¶¶ 20–21). The Lot 131 sale and the lack of an integration clause did not change the result (¶ 20 n.5, ¶ 21 n.6). With no contract, the implied covenant claim also failed (¶ 22, citing Vander Veur v. Groove Ent. Techs., 2019 UT 64, ¶ 20, 452 P.3d 1173).

Issue 2: Partial performance (correctness, ¶ 13): affirmed (no error)

The partial-performance exception to Utah Code § 25-5-3 does not apply (¶ 24). Applying Jenkins v. Percival, 962 P.2d 796, 801 (Utah 1998), the court held the emails were no contract to perform, and Hutchings alleged no breach of the LRA (¶ 24).

Issue 3: Unjust enrichment (correctness, ¶ 13): reversed

Summary judgment on unjust enrichment was improper (¶ 30). Hutchings’s declaration showed that he supplied a custom floor plan and spent more than 100 hours on the designs, and that the sellers knew it (¶¶ 26–27, applying Howard v. Manes, 2013 UT App 208, ¶ 30, 309 P.3d 279). The test is whether the conduct falls “within the subject matter” of the contract, not whether any contract exists (¶ 28, quoting United States Fid. v. United States Sports Specialty, 2012 UT 3, ¶ 14, 270 P.3d 464). The LRA said nothing about design work, its disclaimer of interest in the property did not reach the plans, and much of the work came after the LRA’s 90-day term (¶ 29). Buying the stamped plans from the designer did not defeat the claim, and a possible claim against the designer does not bar one against the sellers (¶ 30 & n.7).

Issue 4: Promissory estoppel (correctness, ¶ 13): affirmed (no error)

The June 4 email was not a sufficiently clear and definite promise (¶ 34, applying E & H Land, Ltd. v. Farmington City, 2014 UT App 237, ¶ 29, 336 P.3d 1077). It addressed only the cost of a pool and set no formula for upgrades or construction costs (¶¶ 33–34). Hutchings’s own complaint alleged he agreed to a higher base price for Lot 131 (¶ 34 n.8).

Issue 5: Equitable estoppel (correctness, ¶ 13): affirmed (no error)

An affirmative equitable estoppel claim is not available here (¶ 35). Following Youngblood v. Auto-Owners Ins. Co., 2007 UT 28, ¶ 12, 158 P.3d 1088, and Hammon v. Zoom Inc., 2026 UT App 106, ¶ 37, the court declined to extend the insurance-coverage exception (¶ 35).

Takeaways

  • An LRA disclaiming any offer and any interest in the property can defeat a claim that earlier emails formed a purchase contract (¶¶ 20–21).
  • An express contract bars unjust enrichment only for conduct within its subject matter (¶¶ 28–29).
  • A third party’s sale of stamped plans does not, as a matter of law, defeat a buyer’s unjust enrichment claim for his own design contributions (¶ 30 & n.7).
  • An affirmative equitable estoppel claim remains limited to insurance coverage disputes (¶ 35).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Hutchings v. Cedar Pointe Homes
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 116
Case no.
20250034-CA
Filed
2025
Decided
August 6, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Hutchings
Disposition
Affirmed in part and Reversed in part
At stake
Whether Hutchings had a binding deal to buy Lot 130 and a custom home at the price in a June 4, 2020 email, and whether he could recover for his design work on the home

The panel

John D. LuthyAuthor
David N. MortensenConcurred
Amy J. OliverConcurred
Trial court
Fifth District Court, St. George Department · Judge Eric R. Gentry

Parties & counsel

Hutchings — AppellantIndividual(s)Erik A. OlsonConnor B. Arrington
Cedar Pointe Homes — AppelleeBusinessSeth D. NeedsDavid W. Hunter

Practice Tip

When opposing an express-contract defense to unjust enrichment, show that the conduct at issue falls outside the contract's subject matter, as the court found the LRA silent on the buyer's design work (¶¶ 28–29).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.