Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Is it entrapment when police pose as a 13-year-old online? State v. Kent

2026 UT App 127No. 20230563-CADecided Aug 13, 2026Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

Evidence of a defendant’s texts and interview statements sufficed to show he believed the undercover persona was thirteen and enticed her, and police who merely afforded an opportunity and asked follow-up questions after his own innuendo did not entrap him as a matter of law.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld Kent’s conviction for enticing a minor, rejecting every argument he raised.

  • A defendant’s own texts and interview statements can be enough for a jury to find he believed the person was a minor, even if her profile photos showed an adult.
  • Police asking follow-up questions about what someone wants, after he has steered the chat toward sex, was not entrapment as a matter of law here.
  • Keeping a witness from repeating testimony the jury already heard from another witness was, at most, harmless.

What happened?

An undercover police sergeant made a dating-app profile for “Jen,” listing her age as 19 with photos of an adult woman. Kent, a man in his fifties, messaged her. Early on, Jen told him she was “really only 13 but almost 14.” Kent kept talking with her for about a week, asked about her sexual experience, sent a text using cartoon images, and repeatedly asked her to promise she was not a cop. A female detective voiced Jen in three phone calls.

When Kent arrived at a meeting spot, officers detained him. In a police interview he said he believed Jen was “13, almost 14.” He was charged with enticing a minor, a second-degree felony. A jury convicted him. The trial court suspended a prison sentence and put him on probation, including 180 days in jail.

What did Kent argue?

Kent raised four points: the evidence did not prove he believed Jen was a minor or meant to have sex with her; police entrapped him, meaning they pushed him into a crime he was not otherwise ready to commit; his trial lawyer should have objected to some officer testimony; and the judge wrongly stopped his lawyer from asking a second officer about “catfishing,” which is pretending to be someone else online to start a relationship.

Was the evidence enough?

Yes. Kent’s texts (“I got a daughter your age”), his worry about police, and his interview statements gave the jury enough to find he believed Jen was a minor. The court said the question is what Kent believed, not what a reasonable person would have believed. His offer to have Jen “clean” his house and his cartoon text gave enough evidence that he was trying to lure her into sex.

Was Kent entrapped?

Not as a matter of law, which means the judge did not have to take the question away from the jury. Police offered no money, made no appeals to pity, and did not hound him. Kent kept the conversation going, brought in sexual hints, and continued even after Jen gave him chances to back out. Jen’s follow-up questions came after Kent’s own vague hints. Whether Jen was attractive does not count toward entrapment.

Was his lawyer ineffective?

No. The lawyer could reasonably have wanted the jury to hear the officer’s pressure tactics, so Kent’s steady denials would look more believable. Calling Kent “not very forthcoming” could reasonably be read as a comment on how much he talked, not on whether he lied. The officers’ other statements could reasonably be seen as descriptions of their own investigation, not expert opinions about Kent’s state of mind.

What about the catfishing questions?

The court assumed the judge may have been wrong, but held it made no difference. The jury had already heard the sergeant agree that the definition of catfishing fit, and Kent’s lawyer argued it in closing.

What happens now?

Kent’s conviction stands. The court left open, for a later case, whether a defendant convicted at trial can still appeal the denial of a pretrial entrapment motion.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Harris, J., joined by Tenney and Oliver, JJ.). This amended opinion replaces one issued June 25, 2026, after the State’s petition for rehearing, which the court granted only to the extent of revisions largely in Part II.A; its conclusions are unchanged. The jury’s enticement verdict stands on all four challenges (¶ 86).

Issue 1: Sufficiency of the evidence on the directed verdict (sufficiency of the evidence, ¶ 33): affirmed (no error)

The court held that the trial court correctly denied Kent’s directed verdict motion, because some evidence supported the jury’s findings on both challenged points (¶¶ 37, 49).

Part 1: Belief that Jen was a minor

Some evidence supported a finding that Kent believed Jen was a minor. His texts (“I got a daughter your age”), repeated concern about police, and interview statements (“13, almost 14”) sufficed (¶¶ 39–41). The adult photos and voice did not matter, because the question is whether the defendant believed she was thirteen, not whether a reasonable person would, following State v. Dickerson (Dickerson II), 2025 UT App 173, ¶ 23, 582 P.3d 1219, cert. denied, 585 P.3d 47 (Utah 2026) (¶¶ 42–43).

Part 2: Intent to entice

Some evidence showed Kent knowingly enticed Jen to engage in illegal sexual activity under Utah Code § 76-5-417(2). The house-cleaning offer carried sexual undertones, and the cartoon text “more or less clinches the matter” (¶¶ 46–47). Evidence cutting both ways presents a jury question, not grounds for a directed verdict (¶ 48).

Issue 2: Entrapment as a matter of law (mixed, ¶ 34): affirmed (no error)

The court held that the trial court properly sent entrapment to the jury, whether measured by the pretrial hearing record or the trial record (¶¶ 55, 64), and it did not decide the State’s procedural harmless-error question (¶¶ 53–54).

Part 1: The State’s procedural question (¶¶ 50–54) — not reached. The State argued that when a jury rejects an entrapment defense and convicts, any error in denying the pretrial motion to dismiss is harmless, so the only question is whether the trial evidence was sufficient to disprove entrapment (¶ 51). The court “need not address the merits of this question,” because Kent was not entitled to a determination that he was entrapped as a matter of law on either body of evidence (¶ 51). The court explained that the evidence at the pretrial hearing was “largely the same as, and simply a subset of,” the trial evidence, and it left the question for a later case in which the answer might affect the outcome (¶ 54).

Part 2: The merits of the entrapment claim (¶¶ 55–64) — affirmed. None of the classic methods from State v. Dickerson (Dickerson I), 2022 UT App 56, ¶ 37, 511 P.3d 1191 were used, and Kent pursued the chat and declined repeated “outs” (¶¶ 58–59). Jen’s clarifying questions followed Kent’s own evasive innuendo (¶ 60). Attractiveness of the decoy is not a material factor (¶ 62, quoting State v. Qayum, 2025 UT App 178, ¶ 42 n.6, 582 P.3d 1245). State v. Smith, 2024 UT 13, ¶ 42, 548 P.3d 874 did not help Kent, because he stayed aware the conduct was criminal (¶ 63).

Issue 3: Counsel and credibility statements (ineffective assistance, ¶ 35): affirmed (no error)

Counsel was not deficient for forgoing rule 608 and 702 objections. Four statements about interview tactics could be left in to make Kent’s denials look more credible, following State v. Gourdin, 2024 UT App 74, ¶ 63, 549 P.3d 685, cert. granted, 564 P.3d 958 (Utah 2025) (¶¶ 69–70; see ¶ 71 n.6). “Not very forthcoming” could reasonably be read as about willingness to talk, relying on United States v. Jones, 74 F.4th 1065, 1071 (10th Cir. 2023) (¶ 72).

Issue 4: Counsel and intent statements (ineffective assistance, ¶ 35): affirmed (no error)

Counsel could reasonably conclude rules 704(b) and 702 did not apply. The officers were percipient witnesses describing their investigation (¶ 77), and the statements described the sergeant’s own purpose or experience, or an interview tactic, not an opinion on Kent’s mental state (¶¶ 78–79; see State v. Hosman, 2021 UT App 103, ¶¶ 26, 29, 496 P.3d 1162).

Issue 5: Catfishing cross-examination (abuse of discretion, ¶ 36): affirmed (harmless error)

Assuming error, Kent was not prejudiced. The excluded testimony was cumulative of the sergeant’s (¶ 83, citing State v. Miranda, 2017 UT App 203, ¶ 47, 407 P.3d 1033), and counsel argued catfishing in closing (¶ 84).

Not reached

Issue 3: the State’s argument that a jury’s rejection of entrapment makes any error in denying a pretrial motion to dismiss harmless. The court found the two records materially the same and left the question for a case where it matters (¶¶ 51–54).

Takeaways

  • Belief about age is judged from the defendant’s own perspective, not a reasonable person’s (¶ 43).
  • Decoy follow-up questions prompted by a defendant’s evasive innuendo are not “excessive pressure or goading” (¶ 60).
  • When challenging specific testimony on appeal, give a list of the statements (¶ 67 n.5).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State v. Kent
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 127
Case no.
20230563-CA
Filed
2023
Decided
August 13, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Kent
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A jury conviction for enticing a minor, a second-degree felony, after Kent tried to meet a person posing online as a thirteen-year-old girl who was in fact an undercover officer

The panel

Ryan M. HarrisAuthor
Amy J. OliverConcurred
Ryan D. TenneyConcurred
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Vernice S. Trease

Parties & counsel

Kent — AppellantIndividual(s)Andrea J. Garland
State — AppelleeState of UtahDerek E. BrownHwa Sung Doucette

Practice Tip

In an online-sting appeal, arguments about the decoy's adult photos, voice or attractiveness go to the jury, not to entrapment as a matter of law or to the defendant's subjective belief about age (¶¶ 43, 61–62).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.