Utah Supreme Court · Published Opinion

Can a judge toss my workers’ comp claim on a defense my employer dropped? Darden Restaurant v. Labor Commission

2026 UT 32No. 20250066Decided Aug 20, 2026Employment & Workers' CompensationReversed & Remanded

Holding

An employer that pleads a limitations defense under Utah Code § 34A-2-407 but never asks the ALJ for relief based on it waives the defense, and the ALJ’s sua sponte ruling does not preserve it when that ruling fails the fairness principle of Abu-Ulba v. Ananda Scientific, Inc., 2026 UT 24.

Key takeaways

The Utah Supreme Court sided with the injured worker, Chinyu James Sun, and sent the case back for more proceedings on both of his injury claims.

  • An employer that pleads a late-notice defense but never asks for relief based on it can be found to have waived the defense.
  • When a judge raises such a defense on her own, that ruling does not save it if the worker had no fair chance to respond.
  • The Court of Appeals must now decide the employer’s challenges on the neck claim, and the Labor Commission must then decide the shoulder claim on its merits.

What happened?

Chinyu James Sun managed an Olive Garden in St. George owned by Darden. On July 1, 2020, he slipped on fallen ice in the kitchen and hurt his shoulder and neck. He had shoulder surgery in August 2020. A later scan showed his neck needed surgery too.

Utah’s Workers’ Compensation Act says an injured worker must tell the employer about the injury within 180 days. If not, the worker is “barred” from benefits. The parties treated this as a statute of limitations, a time limit the employer must raise and prove.

How did the late-notice rule come into the case?

Darden listed the notice rule as a defense in its answer. At the hearing before an administrative law judge (ALJ, a judge who hears agency cases), Sun testified that he told his supervisor about the fall three times that first week. The supervisor said he did not.

But Darden never asked the ALJ to dismiss the claims for late notice. It used the missing report to argue that no injury happened at all. The ALJ raised the notice rule on her own and dismissed both claims.

What happened on appeal before the agency and the Court of Appeals?

The Commissioner rejected Sun’s argument that Darden had given up the defense. He kept the shoulder claim barred but revived the neck claim. Sun later won benefits for his neck after a medical panel, a group of doctors the agency uses, linked the injury to the fall. The Appeals Board affirmed.

The Court of Appeals held both claims were too late. It did not decide Sun’s argument that Darden had given up the defense, treating it as a different question.

What did the Supreme Court decide?

It ruled for Sun on both questions. First, Darden waived the defense, meaning it knowingly gave it up. Darden knew about the defense because it pleaded it, yet it chose not to ask for any relief based on it. The court said that in our system, the parties decide which defenses to pursue, and the ALJ “stepped into the role of advocate rather than arbiter.”

Second, the ALJ’s ruling did not preserve the issue. Preservation means an issue was properly raised below, so it can be argued on appeal. A judge’s ruling on her own can preserve an issue only if it serves both efficiency and fairness. It was not fair here. Sun knew notice mattered only to whether the fall happened, so he had no reason to defend against the notice rule itself.

What happens now?

The Court of Appeals’ decision is vacated, meaning it is wiped out. The Court of Appeals must decide Darden’s challenges to the neck award, about the medical panel report and whether the fall caused the injury. It must then send the case to the Labor Commission to decide the shoulder claim on its merits.

Did all the justices agree?

Yes. Justice Nielsen wrote for a unanimous five-member court, which included two district court judges sitting in for absent justices.

What should people take from this?

Listing a defense is not the same as pursuing it. The court also noted that it has never decided whether the 180-day notice rule is really a statute of limitations, and it left that open.

Bottom line

Vacated and remanded with instructions (Nielsen, J., joined by Petersen, J., Pohlman, A.C.J., and District Judges Shaughnessy and Conklin, sitting for Durrant, C.J., who was recused, and Hagen, J., who left the court). An employer that pleads a limitations defense and builds a supporting record, but never asks for relief on it, waives the defense (¶¶ 28–29). An ALJ’s sua sponte ruling on that defense does not preserve it where the ruling fails the fairness principle (¶¶ 34–38).

Issue 1: Waiver and preservation of the notice defense (mixed, ¶ 26): reversed

The court held that Darden waived its notice (limitations) defense by not asking for relief on it, and that the ALJ’s sua sponte ruling did not preserve the issue, so the court of appeals’ opinion resting on the time-bar was vacated (¶¶ 30, 39).

Part 1: Waiver of the defense (no standard of review, ¶ 26)

Darden waived its limitations defense under Utah Code § 34A-2-407(2), (3) by not asking for relief based on it (¶¶ 28–29). The Court of Appeals never addressed waiver, so the court decided it in the first instance (¶ 26). An affirmative defense must be “expressly plead[ed] and prove[d]” (¶ 28, quoting Beehive Tel. Co. v. Pub. Serv. Comm’n, 2004 UT 18, ¶ 52, 89 P.3d 131). It can be waived by failing to plead it (Brown & Root Indus. Serv. v. Indus. Comm’n, 947 P.2d 671, 677 (Utah 1997)) or by failing to offer evidence of it (Barnard & Burk Grp., Inc. v. Lab. Comm’n, 2005 UT App 401, ¶ 13, 122 P.3d 700). The court held it can also be waived by not seeking relief on it. Darden used the lack-of-report evidence to argue no injury occurred, and the ALJ assembled the defense herself (¶ 29, citing State v. Johnson, 2017 UT 76, ¶¶ 74–75, 416 P.3d 443 (Lee, J., concurring)). Footnote 4 explains why this is waiver rather than forfeiture: Darden knew of the defense and declined to pursue it (¶ 28 n.4). Footnote 5 notes the court has never decided whether the notice provision is a statute of limitations, a claims-processing rule or jurisdictional (¶ 29 n.5).

Part 2: Preservation by the ALJ’s sua sponte ruling (correctness, ¶ 26)

The ALJ’s sua sponte ruling did not preserve the notice issue (¶ 30). Under Abu-Ulba v. Ananda Scientific, Inc., 2026 UT 24, ¶ 28, — P.3d —, a sua sponte ruling preserves an issue only if it serves both judicial economy and fairness (¶ 34). Judicial economy may have been served, because the ALJ ruled and the hearing developed facts about reporting (¶ 36). Fairness was not. Sun knew notice mattered only to whether an accident occurred, so he had no reason to defend compliance with the notice requirement itself (¶¶ 37–38). The Court of Appeals’ footnote rejecting the preservation argument predated Abu-Ulba (¶ 34 n.6).

Disposition

The Court of Appeals had not reached Darden’s challenges to the neck claim (medical causation and admission of the medical panel report) (¶ 39). It must decide them, then remand to the Labor Commission to decide the shoulder claim on its merits and any other issues arising from the neck ruling, under Utah Code § 63G-4-404(1)(b)(v) (¶ 40).

Takeaways

  • Pleading a limitations defense and putting on evidence that could support it is not enough; the party must ask for relief on it (¶¶ 28–29).
  • A tribunal’s sua sponte ruling preserves an issue only if it serves both judicial economy and fairness (¶ 34).
  • Fairness fails where the opposing party had no reason to know it had to meet the theory (¶ 38).
  • Whether the § 34A-2-407 notice provision is a statute of limitations remains open (¶ 29 n.5).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Darden Restaurant v. Labor Commission
Court
Utah Supreme Court
Citation
2026 UT 32
Case no.
20250066
Filed
2025
Decided
August 20, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Heard
Argued
Who appealed
Darden Restaurant
Disposition
Reversed and Remanded
At stake
Workers' compensation benefits for shoulder and neck injuries from a slip-and-fall in a restaurant kitchen

The panel

NielsenAuthor
ConklinConcurred
Paige PetersenConcurred
Jill M. PohlmanConcurred
ShaughnessyConcurred
CHIEF JUSTICE DURRANTDid not participate
JUSTICE HAGENDid not participate
JUSTICE JORGENSENDid not participate
JUSTICE DENTDid not participate
Trial court
Labor Commission

Parties & counsel

Darden Restaurant — AppellantOtherAaron J. PrisbreyChristopher C. Hill
Labor Commission — AppelleeBusinessEric J. PollartJeffrey A. Callister

Practice Tip

Pleading a limitations defense is not enough: ask the tribunal for relief on it, or risk waiver even when the record could support it (¶¶ 28–29). Do not count on a sua sponte ruling to preserve a theory the other side had no reason to meet (¶¶ 37–38).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.