Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can I sue my home builder if its preferred lender denies my loan? Jackson v. Ivory Homes

2026 UT App 165No. 20241234-CADecided Nov 5, 2026Contracts & Business DisputesAffirmed

Holding

Where the purchase agreement addressed the subject of the builder’s alleged inducing assurances, the economic loss rule under HealthBanc Int’l, LLC v. Synergy Worldwide, Inc., 2018 UT 61, ¶ 19, 435 P.3d 193, barred the buyer’s fraud-based claims, and Hermansen v. Tasulis, 2002 UT 52, 48 P.3d 235, created no exception because real estate brokers owe no statutory duty to advise buyers whether they qualify for financing.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with Ivory Homes and its sales agent and upheld the dismissal of the home buyer’s lawsuit.

  • When a written contract covers the same subject as the promises a buyer says led her to sign, fraud claims about those promises can be barred, and the contract controls.
  • A buyer cannot recover for unjust enrichment when an enforceable contract governs the same conduct.
  • A breach-of-contract claim needs a specific contract duty the other side broke; a claim that a contract is unfair is a different claim.

What happened?

Brooke Jackson met with Ivory Homes LTD (Ivory), a home builder, in early 2022 about buying a new home in Provo. She alleged that Ivory told her it “had every confidence” she would qualify for a loan with its preferred lender, My Move Mortgage LLC dba Momentum Loans (Momentum), and that Momentum would “take care of” her.

She paid a $5,000 deposit and signed a purchase agreement. After choosing upgrades, she paid a $126,000 pre-construction deposit. Both deposits were nonrefundable under the agreement. The agreement also said her duty to buy did not depend on getting financing, that Ivory had no control over the lender’s decisions, and that she was not relying on any promises not written into the agreement.

Momentum’s underwriters later declined to count a tax strategy on her returns as income and did not approve her loan. Jackson withdrew, and Ivory kept the $131,000.

What did Jackson ask the courts to do?

She sued Ivory, its sales agent Derek Wenn, and Momentum for fraud, unjust enrichment, breach of contract and other claims. The district court dismissed every claim and refused to let her amend her complaint. On appeal she challenged only some of those rulings, and none about Momentum.

Why did the fraud claims fail?

The court applied the “economic loss rule,” which says that when parties have a contract covering a subject, disputes about that subject are handled under the contract, not as tort claims like fraud. Jackson did not dispute that the agreement covered the promises she said led her to sign.

She argued that Wenn, a licensed associate broker, had a separate duty to be honest under Hermansen v. Tasulis, 2002 UT 52, 48 P.3d 235. The court disagreed. Real estate brokers have no duty under the licensing laws to tell buyers whether they will qualify for financing, so that case did not help her.

The court added that, because she did not allege she gave Ivory or Wenn details about her finances, relying on their general reassurances was not reasonable.

What about unjust enrichment and breach of contract?

Unjust enrichment is a claim that someone unfairly kept a benefit. It is not available when an enforceable contract governs the same conduct, and Jackson herself relied on the agreement being enforceable. The court also noted she had waived equitable claims in the agreement.

For breach of contract, she had to point to a duty Ivory agreed to and then broke. The only duty she identified was her own duty to provide a lender letter. The court said her real complaint was that the agreement was unfair, which is a different claim she never made.

Could she fix her complaint?

No. She did not explain what her proposed amended complaint changed or why it would survive dismissal, so the court held her argument was not developed enough to carry her burden.

What happens now?

The dismissal of her claims and the denial of her request to amend stand. All three judges agreed.

What should people take from this?

Written terms in a home purchase contract, such as nonrefundable deposits, no financing contingency and a clause disclaiming spoken promises, can decide a later dispute about what a sales agent said.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Luthy, J., joined by Orme and Tenney, JJ.). Jackson paid $131,000 in nonrefundable deposits under a purchase agreement with Ivory, failed to obtain financing from Ivory’s preferred lender, withdrew, and sued (¶¶ 1–2, 13). The court affirmed dismissal of her fraud-based, unjust enrichment and breach-of-contract claims and the denial of leave to amend (¶ 31). Dismissal of the implied-covenant claim stands because it rose or fell with breach of contract, and unchallenged dismissals, including all claims against Momentum, stand (¶ 15 n.4).

Issue 1: Fraud-based claims and the economic loss rule (correctness, ¶¶ 17–24): affirmed (no error)

The economic loss rule barred the fraud-based claims against Ivory and Wenn. Under HealthBanc Int’l, LLC v. Synergy Worldwide, Inc., 2018 UT 61, ¶ 19, 435 P.3d 193, a fraudulent-inducement claim is barred when the subject of the inducing promises is later negotiated for and included in the contract (¶ 18), and Jackson did not challenge the finding that the agreement covered those promises (¶¶ 20, 24). Hermansen v. Tasulis, 2002 UT 52, 48 P.3d 235, does not apply: brokers do not hold themselves out as having financing expertise and have no statutory duty to advise buyers whether they qualify for financing (¶¶ 21–23). Alternatively, reliance on general assurances was not reasonable where she did not allege giving Ivory or Wenn her financial particulars, citing Gerwe v. Gerwe, 2018 UT App 75, ¶ 11, 424 P.3d 1113 (¶ 24 n.5).

Issue 2: Unjust enrichment (correctness, ¶¶ 25–26): affirmed (no error)

An enforceable contract governing the conduct at issue bars unjust enrichment, per Ashby v. Ashby, 2010 UT 7, ¶ 14, 227 P.3d 246. Jackson relied on the agreement’s enforceability for her own contract claims (¶ 26). The agreement’s waiver of “all claims in equity of any nature” also barred the claim, whether or not she knew what her equitable rights were (¶ 26 n.6).

Issue 3: Breach of contract (correctness, ¶¶ 27–29): affirmed (no error)

The claim failed because Jackson identified no contracted duty Ivory breached, as Hale v. Big H Constr., Inc., 2012 UT App 283, ¶ 41, 288 P.3d 1046, requires (¶ 28). The only obligation she pointed to was her own duty to deliver a lender qualification letter by the Firm Date (¶ 29). Her theory sounded in unfairness or unconscionability, a distinct claim neither complaint pleaded (¶ 29 n.7).

Issue 4: Leave to amend (mixed, ¶ 30): affirmed (no error)

The court noted that leave-to-amend denials are generally reviewed for abuse of discretion, but for correctness when futility is the basis (¶ 16). Jackson identified no changes in the proposed amended complaint and did not explain how they would survive dismissal, so her argument was inadequately briefed and did not meet her burden of persuasion, citing State v. Davie, 2011 UT App 380, ¶ 16, 264 P.3d 770, and Crossgrove v. Stan Checketts Props., LLC, 2015 UT App 35, ¶ 6, 344 P.3d 1136 (¶ 30).

Takeaways

  • A fraudulent-inducement plaintiff facing HealthBanc should contest whether the contract covers the inducing promises; conceding it was fatal here (¶¶ 20, 24).
  • Hermansen’s independent broker duty does not reach assurances about a buyer’s ability to obtain financing (¶ 23).
  • Pleading the contract as enforceable forecloses unjust enrichment on the same conduct (¶ 26).
  • On appeal from denial of leave to amend, identify the proposed changes and explain why they cure the defects (¶ 30).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Jackson v. Ivory Homes
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 165
Case no.
20241234-CA
Filed
2024
Decided
November 5, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Jackson
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A home buyer's suit to recover $131,000 in nonrefundable deposits paid to a builder after its preferred lender did not approve her for financing

The panel

John D. LuthyAuthor
Gregory K. OrmeConcurred
Ryan D. TenneyConcurred
Trial court
Fourth District Court, Spanish Fork Department · Judge Jared W. Eldridge

Parties & counsel

Jackson — AppellantIndividual(s)Justin D. HeidemanJustin R. Elswick
Ivory Homes — AppelleeOtherBenson L. Hathaway Jr.Justin W. StarrRyan C. CadwalladerAlyssa NielsenAnalise Q. Wilson

Practice Tip

A breach-of-contract claim must identify a specific duty the defendant contracted for and breached; a complaint that the deal was unfair states, at most, an unconscionability theory that must be pleaded separately (¶ 29 & n.7).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.