Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can an old fence become the property line despite a survey? Christiansen Family v. Haas Land Livestock

2026 UT App 166No. 20251107-CADecided Nov 5, 2026Real Property & Land UseAffirmed

Holding

Testimony that the claimant farmed and grazed up to a long-standing fence, and that the neighboring prior owner never claimed land beyond it, was legally sufficient to support the clear-error findings of occupation for twenty years and mutual acquiescence, so title to the disputed strip was properly quieted by boundary by acquiescence.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with the Christiansen Family Trust on every issue Haas Land & Livestock raised, though it denied the Trust’s request for fees on appeal.

  • A long-standing fence can become the legal boundary if the neighbors treated it as the line for at least 20 years, even when a survey puts the record line elsewhere.
  • Occupation up to the fence does not have to mean use every day of every year. Farming and grazing that put a reasonable neighbor on notice were enough here.
  • A neighbor can accept a fence as the boundary just by staying silent or doing nothing about it.

What happened?

Haas Land & Livestock (Haas) bought a parcel in Mayfield, Utah, in 2021. The Christiansen Family Trust (Christiansen) owns the parcel just to the east and has owned it for at least seventy years. A county road runs near the line between them, and a fence has stood on the east side of the road since at least 1965.

Haas’s 2021 survey showed that its record boundary actually ran past the fence, into land Christiansen had been using. That strip is called the Disputed Strip. Without talking to Christiansen, Haas began tearing out the fence and putting in new posts along the survey line.

Christiansen sued. It asked the court to declare it the owner of the strip and claimed trespass.

What is boundary by acquiescence?

It is a rule that can make a visible line, like a fence, the legal boundary. The person claiming the land must show four things: a visible line treated as a boundary; their own use of the land up to that line, enough to put a reasonable neighbor on notice; both neighbors accepting the line as the boundary; and all of this for at least 20 years. Each must be proven by clear and convincing evidence, a higher bar than “more likely than not.”

What did the trial court decide?

After a one-day trial without a jury, the judge ruled for Christiansen. She relied on testimony from a woman whose family owned the Haas parcel for about fifty years. That witness said her family never claimed land east of the fence. Christiansen’s trustee and its current lessee (the person leasing the land) testified that the land was farmed and grazed up to the fence. The court gave the strip to Christiansen, found Haas liable for trespass, and awarded $4,420 in damages for the destroyed fence.

What did Haas argue on appeal?

Haas said the evidence did not prove two elements: use of the land up to the fence for 20 years, and the former owners’ acceptance of the fence as the line. It pointed to a gap between the sprinklers and the fence, a possible break in farming from 1999 to 2004, and cattle being there only “sometimes.” Haas also argued the court wrongly refused to watch a video showing the fence in disrepair.

What did the court decide?

The Court of Appeals affirmed on every point. On the evidence, it does not reweigh testimony. It asks only whether the evidence supports the trial judge’s findings, and here it did. Use of the land did not have to be constant, and the record showed earlier lessees farmed before the current lessee arrived in 2004. The former owner’s testimony supported a reasonable inference that her family treated the fence as the line, and silence or inaction can count as acceptance.

On the video, the damages hearing was only about the cost of the destroyed fence, not about farming or containing cattle. Photos already in evidence showed the fence’s condition, so the judge could reasonably find the video irrelevant or repetitive.

What about attorney fees?

Christiansen asked Haas to pay its appeal fees as a sanction. The court said no, because this was not an “egregious” case.

What happens now?

The ruling giving the strip to Christiansen and the trespass damages stand.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Harris, J., joined by Luthy and Oliver, JJ.). Haas held record title to the Disputed Strip, but a fence had stood along its west side for decades. The trial court quieted title in Christiansen by boundary by acquiescence, found Haas liable for trespass, and awarded $4,420 (¶¶ 10–13). Both challenged elements, occupation and mutual acquiescence, were supported by legally sufficient evidence (¶ 36).

Issue 1: Occupation and mutual acquiescence (clearly erroneous, ¶ 14): affirmed (no error)

The findings on occupation for twenty years and on mutual acquiescence were not clearly erroneous. The court treated these determinations as “fact-like” and reviewed them for clear error, following Lundahl Farms LLC v. Nielsen, 2021 UT App 146, ¶¶ 43, 45, 504 P.3d 735, and Dean v. Kang Sik Park, 2012 UT App 349, ¶¶ 10, 28–31, 293 P.3d 388 (¶ 14). It took the occupation and twenty-year challenges together as one argument (¶ 16 n.2).

Occupation. Total occupation is not required, only occupation that would put a reasonable party on notice (¶ 17, citing Dean v. Kang Sik Park, 2012 UT App 349, ¶ 29, 293 P.3d 388). Farming, irrigation and grazing can qualify (¶ 17, citing Bahr v. Imus, 2011 UT 19, ¶ 36, 250 P.3d 56). Testimony that Christiansen “almost always farmed right up to the [F]ence,” that the gap varied from year to year, that earlier lessees farmed before 2004, and that cattle grazed up to the fence supported the findings (¶¶ 21–22). Contrary evidence in the record does not matter under Kimball v. Kimball, 2009 UT App 233, ¶ 20 n.5, 217 P.3d 733 (¶ 23).

Mutual acquiescence. The prior owner testified that her family’s land lay west of the road and that her family never claimed land east of the fence. That supported a reasonable inference that she recognized the fence as the boundary (¶ 28). Acquiescence may come from “silence or indolence” (¶ 28, quoting B.G.T.S. Props., LLC v. Balls Bros. Farm, LLC, 2024 UT App 37, ¶ 17, 547 P.3d 215). Haas’s claim that she acquiesced to the road rather than the fence could not help it, because the road line would give Christiansen more land, not less (¶ 28 n.3). The court would not reweigh her “never paid much attention” testimony (¶ 29).

Issue 2: Exclusion of the fence video (abuse of discretion, ¶ 15): affirmed (no error)

The court did not abuse its discretion in excluding the video at the damages hearing. Rule 52(b) of the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure did not apply. It works on a party’s motion, and Haas’s rule 52(b) motion had been decided without mention of the video before Haas raised it (¶ 33). The exclusion rested on relevance and cumulativeness under Utah Rules of Evidence 401–403. Christiansen sought no damages for lost farming or grazing, and trial photos already showed the fence’s 2021 condition (¶¶ 31, 34).

Issue 3: Appellate fees (none stated, ¶ 36 n.4): Christiansen’s request for rule 33 fees denied

Rule 33 fees are for “egregious cases,” and this was not one (¶ 36 n.4, quoting Freestone v. Walton, 2025 UT App 41, ¶ 26 n.6, 567 P.3d 616).

Takeaways

  • Occupation does not require use “365 days per year.” Notice to a reasonable neighbor is the test (¶¶ 17, 20).
  • A predecessor’s testimony that her family never claimed land past a fence can support an inferred acquiescence (¶ 28).
  • Rule 52(b) needs a pending motion. Evidence raised only after that motion is decided does not come in under it (¶ 33).
  • At a damages hearing limited to the cost of a removed fence, evidence about the fence’s ability to hold cattle may be excluded as irrelevant (¶ 34).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Christiansen Family v. Haas Land Livestock
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 166
Case no.
20251107-CA
Filed
2025
Decided
November 5, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Haas Land Livestock
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Title to a strip of land between neighboring parcels in Mayfield, Utah, quieted in the Christiansen Family Trust by boundary by acquiescence, plus $4,420 in trespass damages for Haas's removal of the fence

The panel

Ryan M. HarrisAuthor
John D. LuthyConcurred
Amy J. OliverConcurred
Trial court
Sixth District Court, Manti Department · Judge Mandy L. Larsen

Parties & counsel

Haas Land Livestock — AppellantBusinessWilliam B. IngramWesley J. Alexander
Christiansen Family — AppelleeOtherDouglas L. Neeley

Practice Tip

To get post-trial evidence in under rule 52(b), raise it in the rule 52(b) motion itself; once that motion is decided, the rule gives no basis for offering new evidence at a later damages hearing (¶ 33).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.