Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can a jury reject self-defense when the shooter started the fight? State v. Martinez

2026 UT App 171No. 20240889-CADecided Nov 5, 2026Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

Viewing the evidence in the State’s favor, sufficient evidence showed Martinez was the aggressor who never effectively withdrew and lacked any reasonable or actual belief in imminent deadly harm, so the State disproved perfect and imperfect self-defense beyond a reasonable doubt.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld Daniel Martinez’s two aggravated murder convictions.

  • When a defendant raises self-defense, the State must disprove it beyond a reasonable doubt, but on appeal the defendant must show no evidence could support the jury’s rejection of it.
  • Evidence that Martinez started the confrontation and never clearly backed out of it supported the jury’s verdict.
  • Video, witness testimony, physical evidence and Martinez’s conduct after the shooting allowed the jury to find he did not reasonably fear for his life.

What happened?

In April 2022, seventeen-year-old Daniel Martinez went to a house party with his cousin and friends. The court used made-up names for everyone except Martinez. The house was an Airbnb rental, and the property manager shut the party down.

Out on the street, Martinez threw beer bottles, including toward a parked Tesla. The Tesla’s owner, Alex, asked him to stop. Martinez cursed at him and threw another bottle, and the two traded insults.

Alex got into his car and buckled in. Martinez asked his friend Earl for his gun, saying “I saw a beam,” then skipped toward the Tesla and fired ten shots. One bullet killed Alex. Another killed Martinez’s cousin, Jeff, who was walking on the sidewalk behind the car.

Police later found a handgun with a red laser sight on the Tesla’s floor. Martinez gave detectives several conflicting stories, including blaming his friends.

What did Martinez argue?

At trial, Martinez admitted he did the shooting but said he acted in self-defense because he saw a laser aimed at his body. A jury convicted him of two counts of aggravated murder.

On appeal, he argued the State had not offered enough evidence to disprove self-defense. He also argued “imperfect self-defense,” a partial defense for someone who reasonably, but wrongly, believes force is legally justified.

What did the court decide?

The court affirmed. When self-defense is raised, the State must disprove it beyond a reasonable doubt, the highest standard of proof. But on appeal, Martinez had to show that no evidence, viewed in the State’s favor, could support the jury’s verdict. He did not meet that burden.

The court pointed to three things. First, witnesses described Martinez as the aggressor who threw bottles at the Tesla and kept going after being asked to stop. He turned away only briefly, then spun back, gestured and kept yelling, so he never clearly signaled that he was backing out of the fight.

Second, the jury could find any fear was unreasonable. Only Martinez said he saw a laser. Other witnesses saw none, video showed him acting aggressively, and he moved toward the supposed danger instead of taking cover.

Third, the jury could find Martinez did not believe he was in danger at all. The medical examiner concluded Alex was sitting in the driver seat with the backs of his hands facing the windshield when he was shot, and other evidence showed he was buckled in. Afterward, Martinez fled, was heard laughing, and lied to police.

The same evidence defeated the imperfect self-defense claim, because it showed Martinez did not reasonably believe deadly force was justified.

What about the State’s argument that the issue was not preserved?

The State argued Martinez had not properly raised the issue at trial. The court noted some tension in its past cases about this situation but did not resolve it, because his argument failed either way.

What happens now?

Both aggravated murder convictions stand.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Mortensen, J., joined by Tenney and Luthy, JJ.). Martinez challenged the denial of his directed-verdict motion, arguing the State failed to disprove perfect and imperfect self-defense. Viewing the evidence in the State’s favor, he did not show that “no evidence existed” from which a reasonable jury could reject self-defense (¶¶ 36, 41, 44, quoting State v. Gonzalez, 2015 UT 10, ¶ 27, 345 P.3d 1168).

Issue 1: Sufficiency of evidence to disprove perfect and imperfect self-defense (sufficiency of the evidence, ¶ 33): affirmed (no error)

The State presented sufficient evidence to disprove both perfect and imperfect self-defense beyond a reasonable doubt.

Perfect self-defense (Utah Code § 76-2-402(2)(b), (3)(a)(i), (iii)). The court relied on three independent grounds. (1) Aggressor and withdrawal: witnesses described Martinez throwing bottles at the Tesla and continuing after requests to stop; his brief turn away followed by spinning back, gesturing and yelling was not an effective communication of withdrawal (¶¶ 37–38). (2) Reasonableness: only Martinez’s “self-serving testimony” supported a continuing laser threat; doorbell video showed aggression, no other witness saw a laser, he took no evasive action, and Alex was buckled in by the time Martinez turned back (¶ 39). (3) Actual belief: video showed no fear, he fled laughing and high-fiving, never mentioned self-defense to police, and blamed others; autopsy findings placed Alex’s hands facing the windshield when shot (¶ 40). See State v. Sorbonne, 2022 UT 5, ¶ 26, 506 P.3d 545 (objective component of reasonable belief) (¶ 35).

Imperfect self-defense (Utah Code § 76-5-203(4)(a)). Imperfect self-defense requires only a reasonable belief, per State v. Palmer, 2025 UT App 135, ¶ 30, 577 P.3d 1285, cert. denied, 585 P.3d 46 (Utah 2026), but the evidence in ¶¶ 39–40 showed Martinez lacked a reasonable belief and was driven by “free-floating anger” (¶¶ 43–44).

Preservation (¶ 33 n.5). The State argued the claim was unpreserved because Martinez put on a defense case after the motion was denied, which changed the evidence from what the district court had considered when it ruled (n.5); he did not renew the motion after resting (¶ 32). The court noted tension between State v. McCallie, 2016 UT App 4, ¶ 41, 369 P.3d 103, and State v. Kihlstrom, 1999 UT App 289, ¶ 9, 988 P.2d 949, on whether post-motion evidence may be considered, invited future briefing, and declined to resolve it because the claim failed on the totality of the record. Cf. State v. Kitches, 2021 UT App 24, ¶ 28, 484 P.3d 415.

Takeaways

  • A momentary turn away, followed by renewed gestures and shouting, does not effectively communicate withdrawal under § 76-2-402(3)(a)(iii) (¶ 38).
  • A defendant’s own testimony about a threat does not defeat sufficiency where video, witnesses and physical evidence point the other way (¶¶ 39–40).
  • Post-offense flight, celebration and false accusations can support a finding that the defendant held no belief in imminent harm (¶ 40).
  • Whether post-motion defense evidence counts on review of a directed-verdict denial remains unsettled; the court invited briefing in a future case (¶ 33 n.5).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State v. Martinez
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 171
Case no.
20240889-CA
Filed
2024
Decided
November 5, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Martinez
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Two jury convictions for aggravated murder for a shooting that killed a Tesla owner and the defendant's cousin.

The panel

David N. MortensenAuthor
John D. LuthyConcurred
Ryan D. TenneyConcurred
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Linda M. Jones

Parties & counsel

Martinez — AppellantIndividual(s)Sarah J. Carlquist
State — AppelleeState of UtahDerek E. BrownTera J. Peterson

Practice Tip

When a directed-verdict motion is denied at the close of the State's case and the defense then puts on evidence, consider renewing the motion; the court flagged unresolved tension over whether post-motion evidence may be considered on review (¶ 33 n.5).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.