Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can a parent in a mental health crisis be found to have abused a child? In re A.K.

2026 UT App 167No. 20260077-CADecided Nov 5, 2026Juvenile & Child WelfareAffirmed

Holding

Under the parties’ agreed nonaccidental framework, a parent’s general intent to engage in conduct that objectively places a child at an unreasonable risk of harm supports a threatened-harm abuse adjudication, whether or not the parent appreciated the risk, and the adjudication is not insulated as harmless by an unchallenged dependency adjudication.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals ruled against the mother, who appealed, and upheld the juvenile court’s finding that her infant son was abused.

  • A parent who intends the physical acts can support a finding of “threatened harm” abuse even without appreciating the risk those acts created.
  • Whether the risk was “unreasonable” is judged objectively, not by what the parent believed at the time.
  • An abuse finding can still be appealed after the case closes, and alongside an unchallenged dependency finding, because an abuse finding carries extra legal consequences.

What happened?

In November 2025, S.K.-A. (the mother) was seen screaming on the street while holding her three-month-old son, A.K.-A. (the child). She shouted that someone was trying to harm them with a gun and tried to give the child to a passing couple. Bystanders reported she was shaking him.

Officers saw her holding the child by the shoulders, then swinging him by the arm. They took the child, and the mother was placed on an involuntary psychiatric hold. At the hospital, staff found the child’s skull was fractured, but it was unknown when or how that happened.

What did the juvenile court decide?

The mother chose neither to admit nor deny the State’s allegations, so they were treated as true. The juvenile court could not tie the skull fracture to her. But it ruled her conduct was “threatened harm,” a form of abuse, and said the law did not require her actions to be knowing, intentional or reckless. It found the child abused and also “dependent,” a no-fault category for a child without proper care.

Why didn’t the case end when the child went home?

While the appeal was pending, the juvenile court returned the child to the mother and closed the case. That made the appeal technically “moot,” meaning a ruling would no longer change the parties’ practical positions.

The court heard it anyway because an abuse finding has lasting side effects, called collateral consequences. It could count toward ending her parental rights in a future case, and it stays in a state child abuse database that could affect fostering and future investigations.

Couldn’t the court just call any error harmless?

The State argued that because the mother did not challenge the dependency finding, any mistake on abuse made no difference. The court disagreed. An abuse finding carries consequences that a dependency finding does not. The court said due process, the right to fair procedures, requires letting a parent challenge a fault-based finding on appeal.

What did the court decide about her state of mind?

The State agreed with the mother that the harm must be “nonaccidental,” meaning done intentionally, knowingly or recklessly. The court accepted that shared framework without deciding the point itself.

The mother’s lawyers conceded at oral argument that she intended the acts. She argued she still lacked any goal of putting the child at risk. The court disagreed. Child welfare cases protect children and do not punish parents, and they focus on whether the child was abused. A parent need only intend the act, not the risky result. The word “unreasonable” points to an objective test. Because her conduct objectively put the child at unreasonable risk, the abuse finding stands.

What happens now?

Nothing further. The abuse finding stands, and the child is already back with the mother.

What should people take from this?

In a child welfare case, a parent’s mental health crisis does not by itself defeat an abuse finding if the parent intended the acts that created the risk. The court left open whether the law requires any mental state at all, and whether a past abuse finding can always be used as a ground to end parental rights.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Orme, J., joined by Mortensen and Luthy, JJ.). The juvenile court adjudicated the child dependent and abused (threatened harm) as to the mother; she appealed only the abuse adjudication (¶¶ 1, 11, 15).

Two threshold rulings came first. Mootness: the juvenile court returned the child and terminated jurisdiction during the appeal, but the collateral consequences exception applies because the abuse adjudication could satisfy the first termination element under Utah Code section 80-4-301(1)(b) and remains in the DCFS database under section 80-2-707(7)(a) (¶¶ 16–19), citing In re M.S., 2023 UT App 74, ¶ 39, 533 P.3d 859, and In re J.M., 2020 UT App 52, ¶¶ 28–30, 463 P.3d 66. Harmless error: the court declined the State’s alternative ground. Unlike the paired abuse and neglect adjudications in In re K.J., 2024 UT App 47, ¶ 43, 548 P.3d 886, and In re G.B., 2022 UT App 98, ¶ 34, 516 P.3d 781, a fault-based abuse adjudication carries consequences a no-fault dependency adjudication does not, and “due process requires” letting a parent challenge it on appeal (¶¶ 20–26).

Issue 1: Mental state for threatened-harm abuse (correctness, ¶¶ 15, 27–36): affirmed on other grounds

The mother’s intentional handling of the child, which objectively created an unreasonable risk of harm, supports the abuse adjudication whether or not she appreciated the consequences (¶¶ 30, 36). The juvenile court had ruled that no culpable mental state was required (¶ 11); because the State conceded the harm must be “nonaccidental,” the court left that statutory question open and applied the parties’ framework (¶ 15 n.2, ¶ 27). Nonaccidental covers intentional, knowing or reckless conduct (¶ 27, quoting In re J.A., 2018 UT App 29, ¶ 54, 424 P.3d 913). Because child welfare proceedings are protective rather than punitive and focus on the child’s status, the parent needs general intent to engage in the act, not specific intent to cause the risk (¶¶ 32–33, citing In re A.R., 1999 UT 43, ¶ 18, 982 P.2d 73). The word “unreasonable” in section 80-1-102(93) signals an objective standard, and the definition is silent on the parent’s subjective beliefs (¶ 34). The mother conceded she intended the acts, and it was undisputed the conduct objectively created an unreasonable risk (¶ 36).

Not reached

  • Whether section 80-1-102(1)(a)(i)(B) requires a culpable mental state at all, left “for another day” given the State’s concession (¶ 15 n.2).
  • The guardians ad litem’s constitutional challenge to the “permanent ground theory,” reserved for a future case; the court assumed its validity (¶ 17 n.4).
  • Whether the mother acted knowingly or recklessly (¶ 30 n.6).

Takeaways

  • Threatened-harm abuse turns on intent to act and an objectively unreasonable risk; a parent’s delusion or failure to appreciate the risk does not defeat it (¶¶ 33–35).
  • An unchallenged dependency adjudication does not make an abuse adjudication harmless, given the distinct collateral consequences (¶¶ 24–26).
  • Termination of juvenile court jurisdiction does not moot an appeal from an abuse adjudication under the collateral consequences exception (¶¶ 17–19).
  • The court noted statutory exceptions where abuse or neglect labels can change dispositions, such as section 80-3-406(5) and (11), though none applied here (¶ 22 n.5).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
In re A.K.
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 167
Case no.
20260077-CA
Filed
2026
Decided
November 5, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Heard
Argued
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
A juvenile court adjudication that the mother abused her infant son, entered alongside an unchallenged dependency adjudication

The panel

Gregory K. OrmeAuthor
John D. LuthyConcurred
David N. MortensenConcurred
Trial court
Third Juvenile Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Aaron Flater

Parties & counsel

Appellant — AppellantIndividual(s)Emily AdamsAllison Herr
Appellee — AppelleeGovernment agencyDerek E. BrownDeborah A. WoodJohn M. Peterson
Guardian ad litemOtherMartha PierceAlisha GilesHeath Haacke

Practice Tip

When defending a parent against a threatened-harm abuse allegation, focus on whether the risk was objectively unreasonable in the circumstances, since the parent's subjective understanding of the risk does not control (¶¶ 34–35).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.